• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Please explain how bi wiring works

OMGCat!

Super Member
i was reading the user manual for my B&Ws and they mentioned that bi-wiring may help with the lower end by keeping the two halves of the crossover separated.
This doesn't really make sense to me.
If you're using low impedance speaker wire then the two halves of the crossover are still very much connected, just somewhat upstream. Is there a sweet spot where bi-wiring should start? Does it have to go the 20 odd feet back to my amp terminals or could I pick up wherever and just splice into the wires? Do I need to run two grounds or just another positive?
To my mind with bi-wiring you're just increasing insertion loss and capacitance as well as adding an additional 10-20ft of antenna to pick up stray rf.
That said, I think B&W is a reputable company so they probably know what they are talking about, my brain just isn't capable of making sense of it.
I haven't tried it yet but I think I'll give it a go just out of curiosity. If it changes things I'll have to report back.
 
Register to hide this ad
I'd be interested in your listening experiences as it makes no sense to me that hooking up two sets of wires to a single source could result in a change in sound quality - how does the signal know which wire to travel down??
Now, if one were to bi-amp the signal (an active crossover feeding two separate amps) that could change things.
 
i was under the impression that it worked the other way, keeping interference from the low frequency 'resonance' from the woofer from interacting with the high-freq. signals. electrically it doesn't intuitively make sense....but then nearly every new set of speakers i see has bi-wire/bi-amp setup on it....can i hear the difference, i'm not really sure, i think so - but i always hook them up with the extra wire, just in case the stereo inspector shows up at my door someday. also i love heat shrink tube. that's like my bubble wrap.

of course, i don't use super-fancy (expensive) wires....plain old OFC for me.
 
That actually kind of makes sense. If the woofer is making stray voltage then maybe it dissipates by the time it runs down it's own dedicated length of wire. If that were the case I'd assume each woofer would have a specified gauge and length they'd recommend to use but maybe I'm over thinking it.
I'm going to try and find time this weekend to A/B it and see if I can hear any difference. I never really thought about using two wires from the same source until I decided to read the directions (ha, who would have thought). I always thought the second (and third) set of terminals was for using multiple amplifiers through active crossovers in place of the passive units in the speakers.

I use regular OFC 12 gauge here which ohms out pretty much at the same resistance as my meter leads for the 20ft runs I have here.
I like me some heat shrink too. Especially the kind with the glue in it that watertights the splice. I made some extra pretty interconnects using Mogami wire, Switchcraft connectors and that heat shrink. Love the stuff.
 
Bi-wiring makes bi-amping possible.

Bi-amping inherently lowers IM distortion, and some THD as well. Also, if you can get right to the drivers with no crossovers you can have the advantage of hearing really what a high damping factor can do.

Where bi-amping really comes in is when you want it loud. In the design you could have one amp at 350 watts and another at 100 and give any tweeters what they need as well as woofers. With an electronic crossover, the tweeter signal is not just on a different wire, it is on a different amp. This means even if you clip the bass it matters not.

On the other hand, if you design the active crossover right you can use a cap across the woofer without a coil and on occasional clipping it will keep the sound cleaner, tho0ugh compressed slightly. Still, you get a little bit more punch.

And, your tweeter amps have plenty of headroom because they are not being dragged down by all that bass and drums, whatever.

Some people tri-amp. I think my buddy's Maggies are triampable, which it surprising because they are not really a three way system in the way we think.

In the commercial realm there are alot of biamped powered speakers used all over the place. And the idiots do use that damping factor or whatever because there is no capacitor for the tweeter and it makes it blow when the amp shorts and puts DC on it. We NEVER had to worry about tweeters like that. Now we do. And there is usually no protection for the woofer either.

But if you take and use decent amps with protection, you can run them direct. but when you connect to the already made speaker terminals, that still goes through the crossover so you do not get THAT particular advantage.
 
All you are doing with bi-wire and present xover is effectively moving the jumpers from the speaker to the wire end where they connect to the receiver/amp. It's like connecting the entire wire length to the xover with its inherent resistance changing the xovers parameters. Powered monitors do this much better with minimal wiring going between each internal xover/amp/speaker circuit. Many have balanced input connections to maximize noise rejection.
 
The answer lies in whether you believe the hype or not. So the hype states that you are separating the signal and allowing better flow of because the current is changed differently at the speaker crossover. The fact is that you are doubling the wire and thus increasing the gauge. You would also be changing the resistance which may or may not have an effect on the sound. I have used it and I did hear a difference though I'm not sure it was better or worse. This was with Belden 10ga wire and 10 feet runs. Whether the difference was due to the hype or the facts I don't know. Was it worth the cost? Maybe and it certainly wouldn't be worth it when using megabuck cables. What I should've tried is Belden jumpers and a single run as kfalls mentions.
 
Bi-wiring makes bi-amping possible.

Bi-amping inherently lowers IM distortion, and some THD as well. Also, if you can get right to the drivers with no crossovers you can have the advantage of hearing really what a high damping factor can do.

Where bi-amping really comes in is when you want it loud. In the design you could have one amp at 350 watts and another at 100 and give any tweeters what they need as well as woofers. With an electronic crossover, the tweeter signal is not just on a different wire, it is on a different amp. This means even if you clip the bass it matters not.

On the other hand, if you design the active crossover right you can use a cap across the woofer without a coil and on occasional clipping it will keep the sound cleaner, tho0ugh compressed slightly. Still, you get a little bit more punch.

And, your tweeter amps have plenty of headroom because they are not being dragged down by all that bass and drums, whatever.

Some people tri-amp. I think my buddy's Maggies are triampable, which it surprising because they are not really a three way system in the way we think.

In the commercial realm there are alot of biamped powered speakers used all over the place. And the idiots do use that damping factor or whatever because there is no capacitor for the tweeter and it makes it blow when the amp shorts and puts DC on it. We NEVER had to worry about tweeters like that. Now we do. And there is usually no protection for the woofer either.

But if you take and use decent amps with protection, you can run them direct. but when you connect to the already made speaker terminals, that still goes through the crossover so you do not get THAT particular advantage.

I know this was eluded to in the quoted post, but for additional reinforcement...

Bear in mind about 99% of quoted post pertains only to "real" biamping where the signal frequencies are split out before the amps, and the amps are connected directly to the drivers.

Looking it it the other way, only about 1% of might apply if you are biwiring or biamping by simply removing the straps on the speakers and connecting more amps or two sets of wires to one amp.
 
IMO bi-wiring works very well ... at selling twice as much speaker wire to people who buy into the practice. It works less well at delivering a perceptible improvement in sound.
 
It seems like I was mostly right in what I figured but it's still strange to me that B&W would recommend something so out there. I still think I'll give it a shot since I'm curious now and happen to have enough spare wire to do it.
I definitely see the advantages of bi-amping using active crossovers and plan to do so in the next iteration of "the main system".
 
It seems like I was mostly right in what I figured but it's still strange to me that B&W would recommend something so out there.

It's good business to give your customers what they expect. Since B&W is a company aimed at audiophiles with a conventional high end mindset, and such audiophiles often expect to see provisions for bi wiring, it's only prudent for B&W to supply the capability. Whether or not the capability has benefits may not be the point.
 
From Vandersteen's FAQ:

What is bi-wiring and what are the advantages?

Bi-wiring uses two separate sets of speaker cables to connect a single pair of loudspeakers to an amplifier. Coupled with a crossover designed specifically for bi-wiring, it offers many of the advantages of bi-amplifying the speakers with two separate amplifiers without the cost and complexity of two amplifiers.

We began experimenting with bi-wiring back in the early '80s, an era when horizontal bi-amplification was considered the ultimate way to drive quality loudspeakers. (Horizontal bi-amplification used one amplifier to drive the low-frequency section of a speaker and a second amplifier to drive the high-frequency section.) We noted that speakers sounded better when bi-amplified by two amplifiers than when driven by a single amplifier. Surprisingly, this superior performance was evident even when the speakers were bi-amplified by two identical amplifiers at a low volume level and the amplifiers were each driven full-range without an electronic crossover. We initially believed that the double power supplies and other components of two amplifiers were responsible for the improvement, however building amplifiers with twice the power supply and doubling-up on other critical components failed to provide the bi-amplification benefit.

So we looked at the speaker wires. With two amplifiers, bi-amplification used two sets of speaker cables so we experimented with doubling-up the speaker wires and with larger wire. Neither duplicated the bi-amplification improvements. Then we considered that in a bi-amplified system, one set of wires carries the low-frequencies and the other set of wires carries the high-frequencies. We modified a speaker's crossovers to accept two sets of cables and present different load characteristics to each set so that the low-frequencies would be carried by one set of wires and the high-frequencies by the other set of wires. Finally we heard the sonic improvements of bi-amplification with a single amplifier.

Additional experiments with a Hall Effect probe revealed that high-current bass frequencies created a measurable field around the wires that expanded and collapsed with the signal. We believe that this dynamic field modulates the smaller signals, especially the very low level treble frequencies. With the high-current signal (Bass) separated from the low-current signal (Treble) this small signal modulation was eliminated as long as the cables were separated by at least an inch or two. (To keep the treble cable out of the field surrounding the bass cable.)

The crossovers in Vandersteen bi-wirable speakers are engineered with completely separate high-pass and low-pass sections. The bass inputs pass low-frequencies to the woofers, but become more and more resistive at higher frequencies. The treble inputs pass high-frequencies to the midrange and tweeter, but become more and more resistive at low-frequencies. The output from the amplifier always takes the path of least resistance so deep bass frequencies go to the bass input (Low impedance at low-frequencies) rather than to the treble inputs (High impedance at low frequencies). For the same reason, treble frequencies go to the treble input (Low impedance at high-frequencies) rather than to the bass inputs (High impedance at high-frequencies). At the actual crossover frequency, the output from the amplifier would be divided equally between the two inputs as they would both have the same impedance at that frequency. Because of the different reflected impedances of the cables, the crossover between the woofer and midrange actually occurs at the wire ends where they connect to the amplifier.

The benefits of bi-wiring are most obvious in the midrange and treble. The low-current signal to the midrange and tweeter drivers does not have to travel on the same wire as the high-current woofer signal. The field fluctuations and signal regeneration of the high-current low-frequencies are prevented from distorting or masking the low-current high-frequencies. The back EMF (Electro-Mechanical Force) from the large woofer cannot affect the small-signal upper frequencies since they do not share the same wires.

The effects of bi-wiring are not subtle. The improvements are large enough that a bi-wire set of moderately priced cable will usually sound better than a single run of more expensive cable.

All the cables in a bi-wire set must be the same. There is often great temptation to use a wire known for good bass response on the woofer inputs and a different wire known for good treble response on the midrange/tweeter inputs. This will cause the different sonic characteristics of the two wires in the middle frequencies to interfere with the proper blending of the woofer and midrange driver through the crossover point. The consistency of the sound will be severely affected as the different sounding woofer and midrange drivers conflict with each other in the frequency range where our ears are most sensitive to sonic anomalies. The disappointing result is a vague image, a lack of transparency through the midrange and lower treble and a loss of detail and clarity.

Some of the benefits of bi-wiring are from the physical separation of the high-current bass and low-current midrange/tweeter wires. So-called bi-wire cables that combine the wires in one sheath do not offer the full advantages of true bi-wiring although they may be an excellent choice for mono-wiring the speakers.

The cables should all be the same length. This is not due to the time that the signal takes to travel through a cable, but rather that two different lengths of the same cable will sound different. If the cables connecting one speaker are a different length than the cables connecting the other speaker, the resulting difference in sound between the two speakers will compromise the imaging and coherence of the system. If different lengths of cable are used for the bass and midrange/tweeter inputs of the speakers, the effects will be similar to those experienced when using two different cables as described above.

Since short runs of speaker cable sound better than long runs, consider placing your electronics between the speakers rather than off to one side. If for convenience or aesthetic considerations, the electronics must be located a considerable distance from the speakers, it is usually preferable to place the amplifier between the speakers and use long interconnect cables and short speaker wire.
 
From Vandersteen's FAQ:

What is bi-wiring and what are the advantages?

Bi-wiring uses two separate sets of speaker cables to connect a single pair of loudspeakers to an amplifier. Coupled with a crossover designed specifically for bi-wiring, it offers many of the advantages of bi-amplifying the speakers with two separate amplifiers without the cost and complexity of two amplifiers.
...

For the O.P., this should make it easy to wrap your head around what's going on with Bi-Wiring.

I like to go one step further and just use two amplifiers, with the inputs bridged using Y-cables. As long as one of them has level controls, you can use any pair of amps you want.

Still not quite as good as using an active XO where you can bypass the inductor on the woofer, but closer than just two cables...
 
Paying double for speaker wire.
Not necessarily. A number of manufacturers make speaker cables with isolated conductors. The conductors can be grouped together to allow bi-wiring with a single pair of speaker cables. Audioquest and Nordost come to mind immediately, but there are others.
 
Bi-Wiring speakers has the a similar goal as using speaker cables that use a braided configuration, And is not price dependent.

That goal is to reduce inductance caused by the back EMF (Electro-Mechanical Force) from the large woofer as described by Vandersteen in post # 13. While a rather lengthy description of Bi-Wiring, I suggest reading it through for those serious about Bi-Wiring.

This inductance interferes with high and mid frequencies reducing transparency. Braiding insulated conductors together in a single cable (as some cable manufactures have done) also reduces inductance, and is one reason such cables may indeed make an audible difference. This however typically increases capacitance and taken to extremes can initiate instability in an amplifier, especially with long cable runs.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom