• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

PMC, Polk or Paradigm?

PeterFCassidy

Nikko+Apt-Holman = OMG!
Heroes,

I am taking delivery of a Sansui G8000. ALL KNEEL! Preparing for that eventuality, I am considering acquisition of something with a little deeper available power resource and available bass. In terms of positioning logistics, I like the flexibility of bookshelf speakers. In my research I have been considering these models:

Polk LSi9
PMC IB-1
Paradigm S4

Any opinions on their relative merits and models that I should be considering as well that are omitted from this list?

Peter
 
Register to hide this ad
I can't speak for everyone else, but I've always been a Polk afficionado, and I've read nothing but great things about the LSi series, so that's where I'd plop down my cash.
 
The Paradigms have me intrigued...

...My first decent speakers were Paradigms and I'd like to try some of their new high-end offerings, but I'm really impressed with my LSi9s. I purchased them at Crutchfield a little over a year ago when they were on sale for $700. For better or worse they are 4 ohm, so my old receiver didn't handle them well at all, but they were still remarkable for the price.

Recently I bought a mcintosh ma6900 and I can't say enough good things about these speakers when paired with a powerful amplifier. They did experience some bass roll off but adding a 12" B&W subwoofer took care of that problem. Regardless, they still have more bass than one would expect from bookshelfs in this price range or even for $2000.The mid/high range is beautiful and better sounding in many ways than the $3000 B&W 805s through which I had demoed the MA6900.

Granted, my new Mac is deserving of much better speakers, but until I'm ready to pony up $4000+, I don't think I'll be giving up my Lsi9s. Alot of audiophiles sneer at Polk, but I doubt most of them have heard the Lsi9s through an appropriately powered amplifier. Just make sure your amplifier is up to the task of driving them.
 
Having spent a great deal of time discussing the virtues and power needs of the LSi9's, I can tell you that the Sansui is not a good match. A separate amp is imperative for either the LSi9's or the Paradigm S4 (the S4 has more depth IMHO). Now, the Paradigm Studio40's would be a good match for the Sansui as it is an 8 ohm speaker.
 
http://signature.paradigm.com/Flash_Site/Catalog/Downloads/Sig_Specifications.pdf

I read the specification document for the S4 and it rates the S4 at 8 ohm, as it does for the entire Signature line. -pfc

markmarc said:
Having spent a great deal of time discussing the virtues and power needs of the LSi9's, I can tell you that the Sansui is not a good match. A separate amp is imperative for either the LSi9's or the Paradigm S4 (the S4 has more depth IMHO). Now, the Paradigm Studio40's would be a good match for the Sansui as it is an 8 ohm speaker.
 
Peter: I have listened to the S4's thru both a receiver (100 wpc Marantz) and a 100 wpc amp (adcom 545), the sound difference is huge. I am convinced that the S4's are a much truer 4 ohm than eight.

Another way to look at it is you'll save a bundle in buying the Lsi9's over the S4's which you could put into buying one of a number of high quality amps, and even preamp.

Hopefully, you can arrange it so you can hear either speaker with your Sansui in comparison to a separate amp. Enjoy the experience!
 
Haven't heard the Polks or PMCs, but I own the Paradigm S2s and have heard the S4s and S8s - fabulous speakers!
 
I'll try if they're all available at the same dealer

I thought a 120 WPC receiver should be enough, given that Sansui's already run higher than rated. Still, I will do what I can to audition with the receiver with the speakers but the retail scene in Boston is pretty pathetic. These days, there's big box retail and brow-beating extortionist retail. The former would just refuse to allow anyone to touch anything and have anyone competent to switch leads. The latter would accuse me of destroying their reputation by being seen near the building with a piece of equipment that cost less than $100,000 retail.

[SEE: http://audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=39825&page=3&highlight=sales+chimp

And search for "goodwins" or "sales chimp" in the thread.]

What used to be a robust and fully catalogued marketplace for audio has turned into a retail platform only imaginable by Rod Serling.

"Mr Cassidy leaves his house with a vintage Sansui receiver, in search of new audio excitement. In search of a dimension of sound that could compliment his recordings and assuage his sense that something is missing in his music. A sales chimp knaws contemptuously on the door jam of a high-brow stereo store watching his prey with rheumy, blood-shot eyes, practicing a well-worn phrase, 'You think you can afford anything here, asshole? You think you can afford anything here, asshole? You think you can afford anything here, asshole?' Little does Mr Cassidy know, when he enters this pretentious madhouse, he will be crossing the threshold to The Twilight Zone."

Dut-dut-ta/ta/ta-ta-taaaaaaaaaaaaaa!

The other problems is lines. The high end shops carry a handful of lines. Still, two should cover what I am interested in, though I will have to work out the logistics of a listening tour.

Thankest,

Peter


markmarc said:
Peter: I have listened to the S4's thru both a receiver (100 wpc Marantz) and a 100 wpc amp (adcom 545), the sound difference is huge. I am convinced that the S4's are a much truer 4 ohm than eight.

Another way to look at it is you'll save a bundle in buying the Lsi9's over the S4's which you could put into buying one of a number of high quality amps, and even preamp.

Hopefully, you can arrange it so you can hear either speaker with your Sansui in comparison to a separate amp. Enjoy the experience!
 
Peter:
If the salesperson is in their forties the will understand all too well the quality of older equipment. I remember some 15 years ago when I sold audio a guy brought in a 1970's wood-sided piece of equipment. A 20 yr old co-worker told the guy he needed new as wood stuff was outdated. Turned out the piece was a McIntosh, we both proceeded to educate the kid on reality.
 
Go demo them, and decide which one you like. Haven't heard, or heard of PMC - I like both Polk and Paradigm.

Cheers,
Russ
 
The sales chimp was socially impaired by some cognitive disability - or probably just stupid. Had no idea how insulting he was - which is probably why they hired him. He could not pull the "Prove you are self hating enough to need to prove you are worthy of our obnoxiously overpriced gear-routine" on his own. This kind of approach, given the chimp's sloping brow, must have come with a good deal of institutional support and repetition of the concept of culling by shame. "Keep asking about the money, over and over again. People who we want in here never want to be viewed as unwilling to throw unlimited amounts of money at any piece of trivia we tell them they need. Get crackin', Bonzo. . ."


markmarc said:
Peter:
If the salesperson is in their forties the will understand all too well the quality of older equipment. I remember some 15 years ago when I sold audio a guy brought in a 1970's wood-sided piece of equipment. A 20 yr old co-worker told the guy he needed new as wood stuff was outdated. Turned out the piece was a McIntosh, we both proceeded to educate the kid on reality.
 
Back
Top Bottom