• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Powerful sub vs Powerful Main speakers??

ultumax

Super Member
I was always wondering if you needed VERY LARGE front speakers to create a great soundstage for Hifi

Are cheap Towers /MID level bookshelves + A GOOD sub better than
GOOD towers + a cheap or mid levels sub-woofer??
VS
I am happy with my current fronts 2 8" (Goldwood woofer 160W Rms) Realistic speakers Which sound amazing
+ my KLH 10" Tremor series sub , which is not quite as accurate as modern subs I got mine 6-7 years ago or so :thmbsp: (Clearly not a high end sub-woofer!!!)
My Tremor Sub can Shake the Entire upstairs...... so its not a low end sub Either!!!

Would better fronts give me a better sound-stage? I currently have weak rears(Sony duel 5 1/2" bookshelves & NO center speaker!!!!
My Goal is to improve BASS to movie theater levels(close enough for HIFI[/SIZE)] I didn't think they were worth all the money I have left !!! LOL thrift shops CON people so bad $150 dollars for Obsolete speakers
TWO Subs perhaps might work or building duel subwoofer DIY
** I Missed a pair of Vintage Techniques 10" & 12" incher due to them being on hold at storee**:pity:
Hopefully i can self build or buy a speaker /Sub woofer that easily puts them to shame when I find a job!!!!
Thanks!!!:thmbsp:
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I would say over powering the mains with a bigger or better sub is useless, unless the bigger sub is more accurate. But even then there will be a limit or balance that you have to abide by. If you love, tight accurate base then it would be worth a better sub, even tough you’re not using it to its full potential.
But then you may fine yourself wanting better mains so you can turn up the sub.
Even though sub frequencies are not directional, I still like 2 subs over just one.
 
There is no substitute for displacement, except more displacement.

I feel its true with loudspeakers. 2 big Klipschhorns or other really big, good loudspeakers will ALWAYS sound better than small (good) bookshelf speakers.

More so when you turn it up louder.

(This is how I feel, not saying its valid for anyone else)
 
IMHO Front Main speakers come first. Get the best you can and try to allow for future gains in power and fidelity. Don't think about the sub yet. Best is to have the mains capable of everything you need. Think of the sub later and think of it only as a way to supplement notes below where your mains roll off or as a boost when the recording itself rolls off. If you depend on a sub for anything above 50hz you may loose separation.
When you are finished you will have a good setup for music. If you use surround on movies you can change the settings and turn the sub up because the monsters always need more bass.:yes:
 
IMHO Front Main speakers come first. Get the best you can and try to allow for future gains in power and fidelity. Don't think about the sub yet. Best is to have the mains capable of everything you need. Think of the sub later and think of it only as a way to supplement notes below where your mains roll off or as a boost when the recording itself rolls off. If you depend on a sub for anything above 50hz you may loose separation.
When you are finished you will have a good setup for music. If you use surround on movies you can change the settings and turn the sub up because the monsters always need more bass.:yes:

Well put, and exactly the way I see it too. :thmbsp:
 
Reference speakers + mid-fi sub >>> mid-fi speakers + reference level sub.

Actually, I'd always go for the best speakers I could afford that were relatively easy to drive then worry about a sub later.

For many years, I ran a pair of NHT 2.5is in a combination home theater/music system with a separate, smaller music-only system that was a bit more refined. I bi-amped the NHTs so I could boost the level of the subs when listening to home theater and keep them flat when listening to music.

Having said that, I currently have a pair of Polk Monitor 30s with a Mirage BPS-150i sub in a bedroom home theater/music system and most would probably agree the Mirage is a better sub than the Polks are speakers, but it works for me. This was hobbled together via craigslist scores and I have less in it than I had in cables in the NHT-based system. I normally wouldn't seek out such a system.

Bottom line, don't skimp on the speakers. I'd get the speakers I wanted then I'd figure out how to afford a better sub down the road if I couldn't afford it now.
 
I agree with most of the other responses. Get the best front speakers you can afford. Worry about the sub (s) later.
 
I have a pair of Dynaudio Audience 42s and a pair of JM Jabs Tantal 509s which both throw a large soundstage when placed correctly and driven with decent gear.

The 42s are tiny but both pairs of speakers mentioned are bookshelf speakers.
 
Get a good pair of main speakers first; spend enough - or search out used speakers long enough - to get a pair that will get down to at least 50hz cleanly, 40hz or lower even better. Then you can later add a real subwoofer which has a variable adjustment for 'cut-off' (actually roll-off) frequencies that provides a setting beginning at 50hz, and adjustable phase angle. IMO, one subwoofer which provides these adjustments is better than two which don't. Most subwoofers bought these days are really just woofers. The lower you can cross over from a sub to the mains, the greater the chance of getting them to properly mesh, ime.
 
There is no substitute for displacement, except more displacement.

I feel its true with loudspeakers. 2 big Klipschhorns or other really big, good loudspeakers will ALWAYS sound better than small (good) bookshelf speakers.

More so when you turn it up louder.

(This is how I feel, not saying its valid for anyone else)
Know any CHeap good 15" inch woofer mains??? Or any build plans for future ?lol
Best displacement prolly 15s or 12s:thmbsp:
 
I use Energy C-2 Connoisseur for my mains sometimes alternating them with modified Polk S4. My subwoofer is a powered DIY 250 watt Parts Express Titanic 12”. My crossover is a DBX 234.
I’ve owned many relatively big speakers over the years like Klipsch Forte and Def Tech BP-10. None of them could even begin to approach the clean palpable and tactile bass along with a great soundstage that my present three-piece setup presents.
 
Last edited:
I use Energy C-2 Connoisseur for my mains sometimes alternating them with modified Polk S4. My subwoofer is a powered DIY 250 watt Parts Express Titanic 12”. My crossover is a DBX 234.
I’ve owned many relatively big speakers over the years like Klipsch Forte and Def Tech BP-10. None of them could even begin to approach the clean palpable and tactile bass along with a great soundstage that my present three-piece setup presents.

Can you tell me how You built that sub??Id love the 15"inch version!!!
MY KLG subwoofer CRUSHES every sub & Tower speaker bestbuy near me sells easily.
Klipsh subs are clearer though.
15" inch Titanic would end my Bass cravings!!! for a while:thmbsp:
 
The kind of subs sold in most Best Buys really don't make the grade around here. Crushing what they carry really doesn't say much.

Parts Express has several sub woofer kits in the Titanic line and others in less expensive lines. All of them will outperform most of what Best Buy sells.
 
Excellent thread. I would like to offer this:

I started with my Paradigm S8's with the idea of running them full range with subs. Worked fine. However, adding the subs made the low end (lowest end anyway) in the mains redundant, especially below 60hz. IF I had to choose again.... I would of gone with the best possible minimonitors with the subs I have. My only plus was that the price of the mains, at the time, was too good to pass up (and they do sound awesome). But had their been no deal, looking back, you could get some VERY good minimonitors for the same money, and they are easier to place in the room. Think the KEF Reference minimonitors.

But on your point, there is a big difference between low end subs and high end subs in terms of musical resolvement and refinement. I tried the home brew idea and there is no comparision to getting them from those who specialize in the field.
 
Would better fronts give me a better sound-stage?

Sound-stage is a function of tolerance between the left and right channels, the tighter the tolerance, the better the sound-stage,

Speakers have the worst tolerance of all the components in your system, but if you could find a pair matched to with-in 1db of each other, I bet you'd be amazed.

Also, power has nothing to do with sound-stage.
 
The kind of subs sold in most Best Buys really don't make the grade around here. Crushing what they carry really doesn't say much.

Parts Express has several sub woofer kits in the Titanic line and others in less expensive lines. All of them will outperform most of what Best Buy sells.
I agree a Low end sub like KLH ...... outperforms bestbuy because they sell Garbage.,. Not because my SUb is that good...

Any TRUE" High quality sub easily beats my LOW Budget SUb IMO.
JBL Powered monitors from the 80s with 12 inch woofers have better base I think!!:D
Perhaps not ground shaking but Clearer better imaging:thmbsp:

KLH is a dead brand??? WOnder why :(
I was Skepticall of this sub, I really wish I had Picked MTX Instead ....Personally (BAD Choice)

Perhaps I am wrong... but KLH brand clearly is dead for a reason... R.I.P:tears:
 
You think MTX is better? I doubt if many here would agree.

I'm inclined to ask, "better than what?".

You should investigate the offerings from Parts Express.
 
You think MTX is better? I doubt if many here would agree.

I'm inclined to ask, "better than what?".

You should investigate the offerings from Parts Express.
I do not know if they were better.. I could of had Duel 12s rather than a single 10" SUb-woofer for $50 dollars more,
Thanks for advice anyone!!!:thmbsp:
Regardless my sub is better bang for Buck than anything my best-buy currently has including KLipsh(overpriced models in-store)
I woulda rather had the 12" KLH SUB :( a 15" inch sub or two would be amazing though
 
I've tried many DIY subs using car audio drivers back in the day. The only ones that were really tolerable to me were the Aura Force 12, the Illusion Audio ND12 and an Image Dynamics IDQ12 SVC. All were used in a 1.2 (Aura and Illusion) or 1.5 cu ft (Image Dynamics) sealed box and I also tried the IDQ in a box that was about 2.2 cu ft with a vent tuned to roughly 25 Hz that was actually built for another sub.

In general, I'd suggest against using subs designed for car audio. Possibly with a properly designed cabinet, tuned for home audio, some of them might be decent but most lower level/entry level car audio subs are designed for maximum thump within a certain band, not for smooth extension.

Having said that, if you are getting used drivers somewhere for dirt cheap, then go ahead and experiment. Might even be a good thing. Listen to your stuff at home then after a few months, try to find an actual high end stereo shop that has a really nice sub that is properly set up.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom