• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Pro-ject Debut Carbon hum

Bhob

New Member
I just got a pro-ject debut carbon this weekend and I'm getting a really annoying slight hum you can hear especially with headphone (which is all I'm using) or even without when the turntable is spinning. The turntable is grounded and I've tried a few 'fixes' such as adding a rubber washer to the mounting screws and removing the dust cover. They help but it's still noticeable. What does help alot is, believe it or not, moving the dust cover about halfway up and leaving it there, the hum almost all goes away. I find this a poor solution as eventually the hinges will probably loosen up and not hold anymore.

Coming from a retired super old Empire turntable I find this really disappointing to get a new pretty nice turntable and have this obvious of a flaw. I have a email into the manufacturers but I was wondering if there was any advice out there... I might have to return it.
 
Register to hide this ad
That sounds like it's not a rumble (ie vibration) problem, but electromagnetic of nature, unless somehow the dust cover picks up motor vibration in a weird way, but if it happens without the dust cover as well, doesn't seem plausible. Have you tried moving the table somewhere else? Check the cartridge connections, there might be an issues with the wiring? It seems like maybe it's picking up some electromagnetic interference from somewhere, maybe powersupply or other electronic devices in close proximity. Or there's an open ground somewhere which acts as an antenna.
 
I just got a pro-ject debut carbon this weekend and I'm getting a really annoying slight hum you can hear especially with headphone (which is all I'm using) or even without when the turntable is spinning. The turntable is grounded and I've tried a few 'fixes' such as adding a rubber washer to the mounting screws and removing the dust cover. They help but it's still noticeable. What does help alot is, believe it or not, moving the dust cover about halfway up and leaving it there, the hum almost all goes away. I find this a poor solution as eventually the hinges will probably loosen up and not hold anymore.

Coming from a retired super old Empire turntable I find this really disappointing to get a new pretty nice turntable and have this obvious of a flaw. I have a email into the manufacturers but I was wondering if there was any advice out there... I might have to return it.

My carbon has the same problem. I believe it is the hum of the electric motor running. I moved the turntable well away from the receiver and bought some 10' blue jeans cables with good connectors on the ends. I can still hear the hum at the table but there is no hum coming from the speakers. The connects that came with my turntable were very cheaply made and wouldn't stay on the output jacks. My turntable sounds really nice now, although the hum is still there at the turntable.
 
Try a different set of phono cables (if you can), make sure they are shielded. Any hum I had went completely away when I changed my Music Hall supplied cables to a set of PH3 Morrow Audio cables.

Also try grounding it to something else....you never know.
 
Thanks for all the feedback! I will try some of the suggestions. There is nothing worse than stressing out over something like this and not enjoying the music.
 
Return it. Unretire your Empire and fix whatever went wrong. If the tonearm crapped out, fit a modern arm. I got my 208 in a box in pieces with no tonearm and metal that was in such poor shape I had it powder coated.

It is right up there with my Thorens TD 124 in the sound and looks department and has a rather superior AudioMods arm, but a Jelco will work just fine.

At the very least a new turntable should be quiet. I agree with your thinking a new table should be a great experience.
 
You need to get a new motor or return the table. They have really bad quality issues with out of balance motors. They've apparently never deemed it necessary to get a new supplier or buy a better brand of motor.

This has been asked and answered many many times before.
 
If it is a new out of box table, bought from an authorized dealer, then contact them and request a different new table. Do not accept less.
 
The OP may be rolling the dice again with another Project if the OP goes the exchange route, I'd get a refund and invest the money in the refurbishing the Empire.
 
I just got a pro-ject debut carbon this weekend and I'm getting a really annoying slight hum you can hear especially with headphone (which is all I'm using) or even without when the turntable is spinning. The turntable is grounded and I've tried a few 'fixes' such as adding a rubber washer to the mounting screws and removing the dust cover. They help but it's still noticeable. What does help alot is, believe it or not, moving the dust cover about halfway up and leaving it there, the hum almost all goes away. I find this a poor solution as eventually the hinges will probably loosen up and not hold anymore.

Coming from a retired super old Empire turntable I find this really disappointing to get a new pretty nice turntable and have this obvious of a flaw. I have a email into the manufacturers but I was wondering if there was any advice out there... I might have to return it.

Although I'd agree with those who recommend returning it, I'd really like to see a photo of your attempted fix with the washers. I find this problem very interesting in that it eludes even the manufacturer after several years of it. No one that I've seen has produced hard data or definitive answers on the cause. I don't think there is truly reason to believe it's a long-running batch of bad motors...or at least, no hard evidence of it produced in the forums. I could certainly be wrong. Just looking for the answer out of curiosity.
 
The one I fixed up had the same issue. The tab where the ground wires from the arm and to the lug are soldered in the black box and had the wires soldered to it on top of the paint. A quick removal of the paint and a resolder of the ground wires and an iffy left channel connection and it was quiet.

I called the dealer several times and he ran me through all kinds of ground loop BS and even suggested it was my tube amp causing the problem. When I showed him the photos of the issue after figuring it out on my own via email it was the last I heard of him. I sent an email to Pro-Ject with the photos and they basically just said it was an entry level table and because I didn't deal with an authorized dealer for the repair work I had voided any warranty. (LOL?).

Since I had voided my warranty anyways I had some fun with it and mounted a spare jelco 250SA tonearm I had kicking around on it. Photos are posted here if you look. Don't care what anyone says, the cheaper Project decks are crap.
 
I wouldn't fool with it. Return it for a refund and buy a better vintage table for less money. 400 bucks will buy you a VERY nice vintage table head and shoulders above the ProJect.

Or, like has been said, put the money into the Empire. It's a better table anyway. imo anyway:-)
 
http://www.avsforum.com/t/1513521/eliminating-hum-on-a-pro-ject-debut-carbon-turntable - worth a shot if you think this might apply to your situation. Or just return the thing, it seems reading the internets, some of these have the hum issues.

I think Pro-Ject are shooting themselves in the leg with this if it really is a fairly common issue and the fix is a $1 worth of washers...

I have sometimes wondered about the fix that thread describes - soft washer above and below, with a flat washer on top, but I also probably would've removed the O ring. Since his turntable is quiet now, there's no need for the author of that thread to do any additional experimenting, but I suspect the O ring is now not helping anything and could actually transfer a little motor vibration to the plinth.
 
Return it. Unretire your Empire and fix whatever went wrong. If the tonearm crapped out, fit a modern arm. I got my 208 in a box in pieces with no tonearm and metal that was in such poor shape I had it powder coated.

It is right up there with my Thorens TD 124 in the sound and looks department and has a rather superior AudioMods arm, but a Jelco will work just fine.

At the very least a new turntable should be quiet. I agree with your thinking a new table should be a great experience.

It is a cool turntable and I was looking into it. I'll be honest though I probably lack the expertise to do it right. I'm going to store it away for now and save it for a project later down the road.
 
This afternoon when I got home I turned my Carbon on (spinning, but not playing a record ), turned my receiver on with the selector switch at phono1 and turned the volume up really high. There is no hum coming through my speakers. The only time I can here any hum is when I'm standing right over the turntable and that faint hum does not transfer itself to the other parts of my system. I am really liking my Pro ject Carbon now that it is isolated from the rest of the electronics.
 
i had the hum, vibration...took screws out holding down motor and placed 2 rubber and one brass washer on each side...there is rubber under but not on top...tightened down until washers started to buckle....made sure motor was level....and wowie....its all gone ( found fix in another blog)

Herbies mat, speed box s and tube box s.....

fantastic...
 
Still not acceptable to have audible hum generated from the turntable motor in a brand new turntable and even worse that the new owners have to attempt to fix the Projects and the mfg can't or wont do it.
 
Back
Top Bottom