• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

PSVane tube testing and screening

BmWr75

Top octave? pfffffftttttt
Subscriber
A while back I found somebody from PSVane active on another forum and answering folks questions about their tubes. I've not had great luck buying PSVane tubes (i.e. DOA, mismatched, wrong tubes in box) and shared those experiences. So asked them how they test and screen their tubes prior to shipment. Never got an answer. Asked the same question a second time..........crickets.

 
Register to hide this ad
Their track record does not seem appealing. Do they make good, replacing at no cost to you ?
Melody sounds like a robot.
I think only you can decide the most important aspects, here.
Personally, I don't ever believe that new tubes are better. NOS or "tested by trusted collectors" has worked for me, for five decades.

Even from the mid-1970s through the mid-1980s, I worked as a sound engineer for a performing arts complex, within a university. All our amps were tube amps.
When we needed tubes, I was sent to an electronics distributor. When asked what brand I wanted, the rep said: "I can make them any brand you want." That's what they did, rebrand modern tubes, with old looking branding and new looking boxes !
Needless to say, the quality of USA tubes was already going down by the mid '70s. However, if we asked for Mullard, we sometimes got real, vintage Mullard. Likewise, if we asked for Genalex KT88s, we sometimes got the real goods.

Today, the options are slim. If you start a BarterTown WTB ad, some of us will race to help you.
Remember, new is NOT necessarily better...
 
Last edited:
A while back I found somebody from PSVane active on another forum and answering folks questions about their tubes. I've not had great luck buying PSVane tubes (i.e. DOA, mismatched, wrong tubes in box) and shared those experiences. So asked them how they test and screen their tubes prior to shipment. Never got an answer. Asked the same question a second time..........crickets.

If they don't give you test results showing how tested , actual measured results (Printout) and some form of guarantee you can sorta assume this testing/matching is just made up.

Frannie
 
Today, the options are slim. If you start a BarterTown WTB ad, some of us will race to help you.
Remember, new is NOT necessarily better...
Not currently needing any tubes. Probably have a lifetime supply in my stash. When PSVane started selling via Amazon, I was just curious about their tubes and bought some. Not every purchase was poor. Am running some PSVane 2A3s and 6SL7s in an amp right now and they sound great. Not many hours on it though, so have no idea about reliability.
 
I'm not opposed to new production, I just want reasonable testing and a warranty. The best warranty is of course the one you don't need but DOA is not good. I get that things happen, dropped in shipment, whatever but it should be an outlier. You shouldn't be getting mismatches or wrong tubes. How they handle such problems is extremely important too though.

I really miss Jim McShane, he would screen things before they shipped to weed out any factory duds and any poor matching that may have happened. He also refused to sell tubes that he had reliability issues with. Never had a single bad tube from him.
 
I really miss Jim McShane, he would screen things before they shipped to weed out any factory duds and any poor matching that may have happened. He also refused to sell tubes that he had reliability issues with. Never had a single bad tube from him.
Yep in total agreement here.

Frannie
 
Not currently needing any tubes. Probably have a lifetime supply in my stash. When PSVane started selling via Amazon, I was just curious about their tubes and bought some. Not every purchase was poor. Am running some PSVane 2A3s and 6SL7s in an amp right now and they sound great. Not many hours on it though, so have no idea about reliability.
I've had a quad of Psvane Horizon CV181-AT (6SN7GTB) tubes in my office systems Schiit Freya+ preamp for a year. I installed them on 11/11/24 (sold as a matched pair, so I bought two pair) they have about 1,000 hours on them (20 hours a week) and they sound great and have had no problems with them. I had them tested when pretty new, one pair is stronger than the other but the pairs were well matched so the stronger pair is in the gain side. They will make sound if you tap on them or drum on the preamp case hard, but in regular use they are quiet.

I've also had a quad of Apos RAY Select 6SN7 GTBs in my main stereo since late Nov 2024. These are also made by Psvane, but are actually matched near perfectly (2% difference in the whole quad). These also have about 1,000 hours on them and they are exceptional (and expensive- twice the price of the Horizons). The ceramic bases are heavy, the glass is very thick- you can whack on them hard and they make no sound, and you can play drums on the case and they make not a peep. They are almost 1/2" taller than the Horizons and have a larger circumference.

Psvane has a new line out, the "Summit" but they are nutty expensive- $340 for a pair ($170 each). IIRC I paid $340 for the quad of ray tubes ($85 each), and $220 for the quad of Horizons ($55 each).

Last Pic I pulled off the web- shows Horizon CV181-AT side by side with Ray Select 6SN7 in a Schiit Freya +

new Freya+  003.jpg

RAY Tubes 001.jpg
Tube comparison.jpg
 
Last edited:
I have several pairs of EML tubes: 2A3 mesh, 2A3 solid plate, and 320BXLS. All these tubes come with a 5 year warranty. I have owned most of them for over five years and have never had a failure. They are not cheap tubes, but the five year warranty is an expression of their quality control.
 
I really miss Jim McShane, he would screen things before they shipped to weed out any factory duds and any poor matching that may have happened. He also refused to sell tubes that he had reliability issues with. Never had a single bad tube from him.
Jim was my go-to guy for tubes for many years. I too miss him and wish him a great retirement.
 
Jim was my go-to guy for tubes for many years. I too miss him and wish him a great retirement.
Jim was a straight shooter. And that is saying a LOT in this industry.

One thing about any Chinese-made output tubes — run them in for a good 30 minutes — before doing any measurements or biasing — zero input signal.

If you have a fixed-bias amp, set your bias to the coolest setting (over-bias) to avoid red plating while breaking them in.

Chinese tubes are notorious (even boutique ones) for needing a healthy run-in time to burn off contamination from manufacturing. These contaminants can cause the tube to perform inconsistently at the beginning.

It is one of the reasons Chinese tubes tend to glow blue more than others.
 
The experience I have with Chinese outputs are Shugang 6CA7 and EL34S. Both need less bias voltage than anything else, and they don't always come up to reasonable idle current in amps that have limited adjustment range. My Pilot SA-260 can just barely get there, the Marantz 8b that is visiting cannot. My Rauland-Borg amps manage it but they have an arguably excessive bias adjustment range. The one set of EL34S I had lost vacuum on one of the tubes so they are just sitting around. Not sure what happened, they were fine, they got put away for a while, and one had a white top when I went to use them again.

The Ruby EL34BSTR in the Marantz I think are Shugang-produced and they bias up fine. I can't really tell you much of anything else about them.
 
Back
Top Bottom