For anyone interested––we're all recapped now, and original Optimus 9 tweeters have been restored in place of the aftermarkets. (Turns out these were Realistic Super Tweeters, 40-1310.) This was actually my first ever recap––overall pretty smooth! Though I did have a hell of a time getting one of the woofers off, given the interior nuts had come loose from the cabinet.
I need to give it time, but so far my initial impressions hold. Honestly, to my ear, they sound pretty darn close to how they did when I first got them, minus the harsh tweeter. And they sound excellent! Quite a difference from the Nova 8Bs, which I'd characterize as extremely warm, lush, laidback, and impossibly non-fatiguing (if slightly lacking in detail). OTOH the 9s are (unsurprisingly) much more forward in the midrange, giving them an extremely visceral, detailed, "live" sound that is kind of addicting. They do seem a bit more shy with bass than the 8Bs, but cranking it on the receiver seems to put you right in the sweet spot.
I see what Adam S meant when he described the mids being too conspicuous in a way, appearing to float "above" at times, but to that I would say: (1) this seems to heavily depend on the music (Van Morrison, for example, sounds incredible on the 9s), and (2) after you get used to it, they do seem to blend much better. The midrange dial is fun, and one senses they could really dial these in perfectly given enough time and spatial rearrangement.
Overall I think the (modded) 8Bs are closer to the ideal for me. They're not fussy and do an all-around great job with everything. Granted, after listening to the 9s for a while the 8B mids sound almost veiled––but I think that's just by comparison. With the 9s, it's been harder to sit still (can't help fussing with the dials each time I change music).
BTW – thanks to all for the tip on Faderlube. This greatly improved (but did not completely cure) the issue with the tweeter/high-range dial. I can adjust this now, which is great, but it still occasionally cuts in and out during adjustment. Maybe I need to hit it again.
After a coat of Howards, I think they look pretty good! Wife has been very tolerant of this whole excursion.
