Think of the slug(mass) of air within a port or duct as a weight attached(acoustically) to the cone. It is a VERY similar mechanism as defined by the laws of physics.Think of the cone as a weight on a spring- you don't want unwanted motion due to inertia.
Any open, non-sealed design does not have this mechanism so must require the spider and surround to maintain control.
An exception to your explanation would be the 10" woofer in the Marantz Imperial 6. It is high compliance driver in a ported cab.The most basic difference is that a woofer designed for use in a ported cabinet will require a stiffer suspension. The sealed cabinet will rely on the pressure/vacuum in the cabinet to restore the the woofer to its neutral position and help maintain control of the cone's motions when a signal is applied. Think of the cone as a weight on a spring- you don't want unwanted motion due to inertia.
Any open, non-sealed design does not have this mechanism so must require the spider and surround to maintain control.
I'm sure there are other issues that come into play such as coil design, cone construction, magnet choice, etc . . . but at its most basic this is the difference.
And one design is not better than another- think of the belt drive vs. direct drive turntable debate. You don't want to go there.
Think of the slug(mass) of air within a port or duct as a weight attached(acoustically) to the cone. It is a VERY similar mechanism as defined by the laws of physics.
You can indeed port a system using a woofer optimized for sealed alignment, as well as you can run woofers optimized for bass reflex enclosures in a sealed alignment. But, that is well beyond the limitations of any modeling program that i'm aware of. One would have to use the actual math and calculate the alignment the old fashioned way as has been done many times in the past.
Even the best modeling program will still only provide you with a prediction/estimate for results.
Well said!