• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Sealed vs ported woofer construction

sinnerboy

AK Subscriber
Subscriber
What is the difference in woofer construction for a sealed vs ported application? Googling that just gives me tons of info on sealed vs ported, but nothing on what makes a driver specifically geared towards a sealed box vs on to use in a ported box.
 
Register to hide this ad
The most basic difference is that a woofer designed for use in a ported cabinet will require a stiffer suspension. The sealed cabinet will rely on the pressure/vacuum in the cabinet to restore the the woofer to its neutral position and help maintain control of the cone's motions when a signal is applied. Think of the cone as a weight on a spring- you don't want unwanted motion due to inertia.
Any open, non-sealed design does not have this mechanism so must require the spider and surround to maintain control.
I'm sure there are other issues that come into play such as coil design, cone construction, magnet choice, etc . . . but at its most basic this is the difference.
And one design is not better than another- think of the belt drive vs. direct drive turntable debate. You don't want to go there.
 
Get a subwoofer modelling program and start modelling ;)

Seriously, Q, Vas, Xmax, Vb, V3, and lots of other T-S paramaters only make sense when you play with the models. These numbers tell you which drivers are better for sealed or ported. Just saying more or less than 0.707 or whatever doesn't help much.
 
Think of the cone as a weight on a spring- you don't want unwanted motion due to inertia.
Any open, non-sealed design does not have this mechanism so must require the spider and surround to maintain control.
Think of the slug(mass) of air within a port or duct as a weight attached(acoustically) to the cone. It is a VERY similar mechanism as defined by the laws of physics.

You can indeed port a system using a woofer optimized for sealed alignment, as well as you can run woofers optimized for bass reflex enclosures in a sealed alignment. But, that is well beyond the limitations of any modeling program that i'm aware of. One would have to use the actual math and calculate the alignment the old fashioned way as has been done many times in the past.

Even the best modeling program will still only provide you with a prediction/estimate for results.
 
The most basic difference is that a woofer designed for use in a ported cabinet will require a stiffer suspension. The sealed cabinet will rely on the pressure/vacuum in the cabinet to restore the the woofer to its neutral position and help maintain control of the cone's motions when a signal is applied. Think of the cone as a weight on a spring- you don't want unwanted motion due to inertia.
Any open, non-sealed design does not have this mechanism so must require the spider and surround to maintain control.
I'm sure there are other issues that come into play such as coil design, cone construction, magnet choice, etc . . . but at its most basic this is the difference.
And one design is not better than another- think of the belt drive vs. direct drive turntable debate. You don't want to go there.
An exception to your explanation would be the 10" woofer in the Marantz Imperial 6. It is high compliance driver in a ported cab.
 
The important difference is in low pass cutoff SLOPE. A ported design will see good bass down to the port cutoff.
A sealed design will see a gradual roll off.
Hence a sealed design will could have some response below a ported design but be weaker above the port cutoff.
That's one reason the Large Advent speakers sound like they have more bass albeit weaker that ported designs of similar size.
 
OP?
Was your original question about the difference in "woofers" designed for sealed vs. non-sealed enclosures?
Or, were you asking about the difference between sealed and non-sealed enclosure design?
I thought I answered the first question, if not perfectly, well enough. I can't account for all exceptions with my limited knowledge.
It seems others are determined to discuss the latter
 
A woofer for a vented box generally has a lower Qts which generally means a lighter cone and stronger motor. Note the fudge words.
 
Think of the slug(mass) of air within a port or duct as a weight attached(acoustically) to the cone. It is a VERY similar mechanism as defined by the laws of physics.

You can indeed port a system using a woofer optimized for sealed alignment, as well as you can run woofers optimized for bass reflex enclosures in a sealed alignment. But, that is well beyond the limitations of any modeling program that i'm aware of. One would have to use the actual math and calculate the alignment the old fashioned way as has been done many times in the past.

Even the best modeling program will still only provide you with a prediction/estimate for results.

I have found this to be the case, I first built my speakers as sealed units, but the woofers have a V[as] of 19.8 cu ft each with a Q[ts] of .446 and F(s) of 18hz . With two of these 15" drivers in a cabinet with an internal V[as] of only 10.2 cu ft. This would not allow them much excursion thus low output. After some research with little success, I violated the rules and installed two 3" x 12" ports https://www.parts-express.com/preci...MIm8uokdT_3gIVdR-tBh2CegmaEAQYAiABEgJT7PD_BwE in each cabinet tuned to 17 hz. On a cabinet software program this allows up to 12 mm of woofer excursion at 20hz with 100 watts pushing them (4 ohm impedance in parallel) and at 97 db spl, that equals LOUD and house shaking. Experimentation yielded great results in my case any way, the speakers went from a roll off at 36hz to 26hz and only -6db at 20hz easily corrected with a 33 band per channel eq. Well worth the effort, instead of massive 20 cu ft cabinets I got what I wanted from 12 cu ft cabinets (externally). At 192 lbs, there not friendly to move around, can't imagine 20 cu ft.
 
Hello all. I'm not sure if this is the right forum to ask this question but I could not find the answer anywhere. My question concerns the physics of sealed speaker enclosures. If a speaker enclosure is sealed, isn't it then subject to pressure changes inside the box dependent on temperature changes? So that if it warms up, the pressure then increases and it should then tend to push the cones out a little. When it cools down, then the opposite happens. The same results would happen as you move from one altitude like Florida to another like Denver. Wouldn't that then have an ill effect on speaker performance?
 
Sealed is a relative term, I have not yet seen a box that will hold pressure. It should equalize fast enough to never notice.
 
Back
Top Bottom