1st, I do not own a pair but I have always thought Bose owners get treated extremely rude. Many people, who i believe are just parroting what they have heard, cite the fact that they are direct reflecting speakers so they just do not sound good and can not sound good - no way a speaker reflecting the music at you can cut it.
Yet you may see these very same people extolling the virtues of a planar speaker in other posts, a dipole speaker i might add.
So, what i have always thought and wondered.
Of course anyone who knows anything about them understands that you just do not pull out a pair of planar speakers, plop them down and enjoy them. You could spend days, if not weeks, shuffling them around just a few inches at a time in order to get them to sound like sonic bliss - being a dipole, as much music is coming out of the back as it is the front - reflecting if you will.....
Enter the Bose 901 - now more then 50% of the music is reflected, virtually all of it is, so it obviously is going to be even more demanding, but, as I have always stated, if one takes the time and has the proper area, please tell me why they can not do what a dipole does ?
lack the bass because they use such small speakers - pretty much the consensus opinion on the magnepans who cuts it off around 80hz i believe.
Takes a lot of time to set up properly - same as a dipole
requires the appropriate room in order to get them to sound their best - yep, just like my maggies which are currently sitting in my bedroom until i get a listening area completed for them.
Point is, besides the always stated fact that they use cheap materials, the number one reason i always read when people are telling a Bose 901 owner that they are deaf and their speakers suck is that no way a diret reflecting speaker an reproduce the music accurately - now excuse me while i listen to my martin logans, magnepans etc......
Now I do not believe them to be as good, or maybe they are as i have not heard them in so long, as a planar, mainly because the planar is more then likely using a ribbon tweeter and does have a few advantages.....but I also do not expect a $400.00 pair of bookshelf speakers to sound as good as a pair of $2k ones....but they can still sound really darn good.
I have always submitted the the vast majority of bashers have never even heard a pair, but only parrot what they heard trying to sound knowledgeable, but there are also plenty that have heard them and did not like them - but i would have to ask, were they set up properly ?
Seems many people just sit them by a wall, put them on their stands or hang them by some chains and are done with it - how many people have heard a pair where someone actually took the time and effort to place them appropriately - as we know with our planars, an inch either way can make a big difference.....
so, i guess my question would be, forget the fact that you believe they use cheap materials - can someone explain to me why a direct reflecting speaker properly set up could not be every bit as accurate as a dipole speaker ?
Is it that 50% coming out of the front ?
i would prefer real answers as opposed to "Bose sux" - I am not smart enough to know , just never made sense to me. But i guess that is because I had a roomie who had a pair and tho my memory is not that good, I remember them as being a very capable speaker, much better then a whole lot of box speakers that were floating around -
Yet you may see these very same people extolling the virtues of a planar speaker in other posts, a dipole speaker i might add.
So, what i have always thought and wondered.
Of course anyone who knows anything about them understands that you just do not pull out a pair of planar speakers, plop them down and enjoy them. You could spend days, if not weeks, shuffling them around just a few inches at a time in order to get them to sound like sonic bliss - being a dipole, as much music is coming out of the back as it is the front - reflecting if you will.....
Enter the Bose 901 - now more then 50% of the music is reflected, virtually all of it is, so it obviously is going to be even more demanding, but, as I have always stated, if one takes the time and has the proper area, please tell me why they can not do what a dipole does ?
lack the bass because they use such small speakers - pretty much the consensus opinion on the magnepans who cuts it off around 80hz i believe.
Takes a lot of time to set up properly - same as a dipole
requires the appropriate room in order to get them to sound their best - yep, just like my maggies which are currently sitting in my bedroom until i get a listening area completed for them.
Point is, besides the always stated fact that they use cheap materials, the number one reason i always read when people are telling a Bose 901 owner that they are deaf and their speakers suck is that no way a diret reflecting speaker an reproduce the music accurately - now excuse me while i listen to my martin logans, magnepans etc......
Now I do not believe them to be as good, or maybe they are as i have not heard them in so long, as a planar, mainly because the planar is more then likely using a ribbon tweeter and does have a few advantages.....but I also do not expect a $400.00 pair of bookshelf speakers to sound as good as a pair of $2k ones....but they can still sound really darn good.
I have always submitted the the vast majority of bashers have never even heard a pair, but only parrot what they heard trying to sound knowledgeable, but there are also plenty that have heard them and did not like them - but i would have to ask, were they set up properly ?
Seems many people just sit them by a wall, put them on their stands or hang them by some chains and are done with it - how many people have heard a pair where someone actually took the time and effort to place them appropriately - as we know with our planars, an inch either way can make a big difference.....
so, i guess my question would be, forget the fact that you believe they use cheap materials - can someone explain to me why a direct reflecting speaker properly set up could not be every bit as accurate as a dipole speaker ?
Is it that 50% coming out of the front ?
i would prefer real answers as opposed to "Bose sux" - I am not smart enough to know , just never made sense to me. But i guess that is because I had a roomie who had a pair and tho my memory is not that good, I remember them as being a very capable speaker, much better then a whole lot of box speakers that were floating around -
