• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

serious question for Bose 901 bashers

Status
Not open for further replies.

donberry

Super Member
1st, I do not own a pair but I have always thought Bose owners get treated extremely rude. Many people, who i believe are just parroting what they have heard, cite the fact that they are direct reflecting speakers so they just do not sound good and can not sound good - no way a speaker reflecting the music at you can cut it.
Yet you may see these very same people extolling the virtues of a planar speaker in other posts, a dipole speaker i might add.
So, what i have always thought and wondered.
Of course anyone who knows anything about them understands that you just do not pull out a pair of planar speakers, plop them down and enjoy them. You could spend days, if not weeks, shuffling them around just a few inches at a time in order to get them to sound like sonic bliss - being a dipole, as much music is coming out of the back as it is the front - reflecting if you will.....

Enter the Bose 901 - now more then 50% of the music is reflected, virtually all of it is, so it obviously is going to be even more demanding, but, as I have always stated, if one takes the time and has the proper area, please tell me why they can not do what a dipole does ?
lack the bass because they use such small speakers - pretty much the consensus opinion on the magnepans who cuts it off around 80hz i believe.

Takes a lot of time to set up properly - same as a dipole
requires the appropriate room in order to get them to sound their best - yep, just like my maggies which are currently sitting in my bedroom until i get a listening area completed for them.

Point is, besides the always stated fact that they use cheap materials, the number one reason i always read when people are telling a Bose 901 owner that they are deaf and their speakers suck is that no way a diret reflecting speaker an reproduce the music accurately - now excuse me while i listen to my martin logans, magnepans etc......
Now I do not believe them to be as good, or maybe they are as i have not heard them in so long, as a planar, mainly because the planar is more then likely using a ribbon tweeter and does have a few advantages.....but I also do not expect a $400.00 pair of bookshelf speakers to sound as good as a pair of $2k ones....but they can still sound really darn good.

I have always submitted the the vast majority of bashers have never even heard a pair, but only parrot what they heard trying to sound knowledgeable, but there are also plenty that have heard them and did not like them - but i would have to ask, were they set up properly ?
Seems many people just sit them by a wall, put them on their stands or hang them by some chains and are done with it - how many people have heard a pair where someone actually took the time and effort to place them appropriately - as we know with our planars, an inch either way can make a big difference.....

so, i guess my question would be, forget the fact that you believe they use cheap materials - can someone explain to me why a direct reflecting speaker properly set up could not be every bit as accurate as a dipole speaker ?
Is it that 50% coming out of the front ?

i would prefer real answers as opposed to "Bose sux" - I am not smart enough to know , just never made sense to me. But i guess that is because I had a roomie who had a pair and tho my memory is not that good, I remember them as being a very capable speaker, much better then a whole lot of box speakers that were floating around -
 
Register to hide this ad
I remember when I was young, the 901 was talked about all the time as being awesome.

2 years ago, I found a set of series 5 in a pawnshop for 135, excellent condition and had the EQ. I had them running in my house and loved them. They were in the corners and they were setting on top of my towers, so they were a bit higher than the stands they come with. But I think they were all they had been hyped up to be. They did not lack bass, nor treble. I loved em.

But thats when they were bringing 600 a set on ebay, so I sold them for the money. But thanks to all the bashing nowadays, the price is coming down. I may buy another set.

The first set i bought were the originals and had no EQ with them...those sounded hideous.
 
901's are unique in what they do, and how they do it. What that is was well explained in Holt's Stereophile review of them over 30 years ago.

There's that word, "accurate" again. I have no clue whether they are accurate with respect to frequency response or not, as there is no data published by Bose, intentionally so, presumably.

Their soundstage presentation is generally regarded as artificial and exaggerated. It is also regarded by many as pleasurable.

I know zip about dipoles or planars. If Linkwitz says dipoles work, they do, but in a different manner with a different result, obviously. In all cases relying upon room interaction for performance, proper listening environment and setup is paramount.

There are more versatile and less fussy ways to get the job done, in my view.... :yes:
 
The 901 have to have the EQ, or else they will sound bad. Again, placement is key with those, but so is the case for alot of speakers. I do agree with the statement, that lots of bashers have never heard a pair and are just jumping on the bandwagon. Every speaker has its fans and its detractors, thats just how life is. Now, I will agree that Bose has gone to mostly marketing and high unjustified prices, but some of the older stuff sounds good to me :)
 
I actually own a pair. - It may not have anything to do with direct reflecting or cheap components. They just don't sound that good. I have a pair of single driver speakers that use one 4 1/2 inch speaker, and they sound wonderful compared to the 901.

What the 901 does do is handle incredible power. You can hook up huge amplifers to them and they can emit a volume that is incredible for their size. That is how they were sold. So for people that are hard rockers that like room blasting volume that does not break up, the 901 does it!

This is similar to going to Old County Buffet and being impressed with the restaurant because they have a tremendous volume of food for 1 price. That doesn't make it a great restaurant, but it does fill a niche.

The Bose 901 got a bad rap because a lot of them were sold to budding audiophiles that pronounced them "The best speakers in the World - Bar None" - A lot folks just got tired of hearing that.

Why do I know this - I was a Bose 901 proponent back in the early 70's, when I didn't know any better. Had I heard a pair of Klipschorns with SET amps, I would have tried to fit them into my apartment. I own a pair of 901's now because I got a free pair that needed refoaming. I keep them around when someone shows up telling me how great they are. I let them listen to my Horns and then the 901s and ask them what they like better.

Edit: - I always use an EQ

901s' w/EQ definitely sounds much better than 901s w/o EQ
 
Last edited:
My experience says (and I've heard both configurations, although it was a few decades ago):

901's w/ EQ sound good
901's w/o EQ don't sound good

And there's always going to be the folks out there that are amazed at the Bose sound, regardless of what speakers or system they're listening to (and that's ok). :music:
 
During the early days of the 901, when Bose was still arranging for current owners to demo the speaker for prospective buyers, I heard a pair in someone's home, a big, converted barn in rural MA. The owner lived just a few miles from Framingham, and I think someone from Bose may have come set them up. They sounded phenomenal; they didn't seem to be lacking in anything, and the soundstage didn't seem artificially wide.

A few years later, I heard another demo in, of all places, a dealer showroom after the company had started selling through normal retail channels. They sounded awful.

I never found out whether it was because the product had been changed or the dealer had just not set them up correctly.
 
I have heard many models of Bose. I believe that the 901's are a feat of engineering that should not have happened. It was as if someone wanted to prove what tiny drivers could do, and they did. But I am with Zilch on this one, you can get the same sound with much fewer drivers. I'm not an audiophile or technician though, just an average listener.:thmbsp:
 
The thing about Bose bashing that I don't understand and particularly at AK is call any Bose product a pos and your ok. But call some guys plastic TT with a 30 cart a pos and you have attitude? I hate to break it to you but a plastic TT with a $30 cart is a pos.



marc mc
 
Last edited:
The thing about Bose bashing that I don't understand and particularly at AK is call any Bose product a pos and your ok. But call some guys plastic TT with a 30 cart a pos and you have attitude? I hate to break it to you but a plastic TT with a $30 cart is a pos.

marc mc

I don't even own a Turn Table any more, but I do own a pair of 901s.

Here is the deal : -- The guys with a plastic TT with a $30 Cart - do NOT go around saying that they own the Best Turntable in the World - Bar None.

Had the 901 proponents been less verbal in the 1970s and 80s, they would be treated just as AR3a's are treated today.
 
The speaker is almost 40 years old and has been continously available as a new item (albiet in various "upgraded" editions) since the early 1970s....
there must be something intrinsically good about this speaker....

nothing lasts for 40 years as a bad product no matter how savvy and expensive the marketing campaign.....

have we all been duped by BOSE? for 40 years?
I like my Klipsch and KLH/Advent Speakers more than my 901s I guess...and I would love to have a set of Hereseys and Klipschorns If I could afford them...

ok old timers excluding the 901 give me an example of a really bad product that has lasted in our market since the 1960s..audiophile or not...something totally awful that was brought out in the late 1960s which I can go out and by brand new today....
 
The speaker is almost 40 years old and has been continously available as a new item (albiet in various "upgraded" editions) since the early 1970s....
there must be something intrinsically good about this speaker....

nothing lasts for 40 years as a bad product no matter how savvy and expensive the marketing campaign.....

Here's the deal, Again......... McDonalds has been around for that long also, but if you wrote an Article in Bon Appetite that claimed that the Big Mac could compete with the finest resturants in New York and Paris, you'd get the same reaction as the 901s got....

It's not a bad product..........it's just not that great!
 
Actually the non ported 901's were not hateful. I bought a pair of 901 series II's new in the early 70's. (I just could not stretch to get the Dahlquist DQ 10's) Properly placed with the right amount of power (a Marantz 250) they really were a very good sounding speaker that offered a presentation most were not used to, and got a lot of very positive comments from many who heard them. I always thought the ported ones lost the solidity and tightness of the earlier models. It is easy to forget just how far back they went in production, and compared to most Japanese speakers of that time they were really able to hold their own and surpass most others. BTW after 2 years I sold them for what I paid for them so they were a good audio investment for me.
Regards,
Jim
 
The 901 depends on the room and setup more than any other speaker I can think of but that's not necessarily why they sound "bad" to some. The idea behind the drivers in the 901 is to take something nominally "full range" and eq the bejeebers out of it to get it to play where it didn't want to.

Bumping up the treble isn't really a big issue in this case because you're firing it into a wall before it gets to the listener. The treble would be very beamy if it was firing directly at the sweet spot but by using the wall the beaming becomes a moot point. Personally, I think that's a brilliant bit of engineering. Take a driver that can't naturally do what you want, push it into compliance with your will, and use the room to smooth/average the results.

However, when you start throwing eq at the low end you start getting into trouble. In order to keep a driver's response flat and output constant as you go down an octave you need 4x the excursion. So if those little 4.5" drivers were good for 80Hz normally and they are eq'd to give 40 then they'll need 4 times the excursion to produce it. If you're pushing them hard in their natural range then in the lower end they're going to be way beyond what they want to be producing. This manifests itself as distortion, otherwise known as sounding bad.
 
"excluding the 901 give me an example of a really bad product that has lasted in our market since the 1960s..audiophile or not...something totally awful that was brought out in the late 1960s..."

Englebert Humperdink
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom