• The move to the new server is done. There are some software and database maintenance updates in process. This has us passing the hat around to help out. We appreciate any donations. Seriously, even a dollar helps. The payment page may be found here - https://www.audiokarma.org/support.html

Speakers right up against a wall? (what do you think of this design?)

Register to hide this ad
The Sonab OA-5 were also upwards-playing speakers and they became one of swedens most sold speakers in their time. They used simple, cheap speakers but were designed with much care.

The against-the-wall speakers also seem to follow a simple concept. They have two tweeters and a small woofer, and I can't see how they wouldn't sound good. You probably need to pay a bit more attention to the room than with traditional speakers, maybe experimenting with sound absorbers on some walls and so on, but in general they should sound very good. The designer of the Sonab speakers said that the only way music would sound real is if it was reflected in the room rather than projected at the listnener.
 
I remember several John Cockroft designs from Speaker Builder in the 80s and 90s. They were usually meant to use wall reinforcement to boost the bass, and he has been an advocate of a variant of the transmission line, with a short, usually unfolded line, that is very heavily stuffed -- the stuffing is supposed to slow the speed of sound in the line so that it can be shorter. Often the woofer was mass loaded also, as it is in this design.
I do not know how these speakers sound, but I don't believe his views on line stuffing are commonly accepted (doesn't mean he's wrong, but that his view shouldn't be accepted as gospel).
But his advocacy of wall mounting may be part of what makes such speakers sound good (assuming that they do), since being close to walls, floors, or ceilings increases the amount of pressure, hence bass. But the frequencies increased (and also decreased because of cancellation) depend on the distances to all boundaries, so a speaker meant to be placed against the wall and on the floor can have a more predictable bass (re Allisons). The problem is that the higher frequencies will also be affected, and their the interference with the wall may be more detrimental, so often the tweeter is placed facing outward and away from the wall.
 
Back
Top Bottom