• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Steven Wilson -"Hand Cannot Erase"

Register to hide this ad
That synth solo in Regret #9 gets the gold medal for me. As a whole, the albums very good but definitely not Wilsons best. Porcupine Trees "Fear Of A Blank Planet" or his first solo album "Insurgentes", holds that title imho.I have a soft spot for "Up The Downstair" too. A really talented dude Mr. Wilson is.
 
Not his best. I fear those days are gone along with Porcupine Tree.

I've been trying to like the album, but so far, all I like is bits and pieces. That's the problem. It seems like leftover clips from other projects, sewn together in no particular order, with no unifying theme or flow. For me anyway, the wOw factor has been replaced by the wTf factor ...

PS ... I realize that a lot of his stuff takes time to sink in, but I really feel after a few listens that enough is enough.
 
Well don't hate me but I just love it. I have it in the car, on vinyl. I also have "The Raven that Refused to Sing and Other Stories" as well as most of the Porcupine Tree and Blackfield releases. I've just pre ordered Transience which is due for release soon. I just think the guy can do no wrong. Ok some is better than others but I always buy his stuff and I'm rarely dissapointed.
 
Don't get me wrong ... I'm a big PT fan. Just that the Wilson solo efforts have strayed far from what I expect, and unfortunately, to places I never wanted to be.

* Add Storm Corrosion (self titled) to the list of likes ... SW collaborated with Mikael Åkerfeldt of Opeth on that one. I look forward to a reprise, but not holding my breath as it seems that was more a one shot deal ...

Someone also mentioned Up the Downstair ... I'd put that right up there as some of their most musical moments ... prepare to sit back and be mesmerized ... :thmbsp:
 
Don't get me wrong ... I'm a big PT fan. Just that the Wilson solo efforts have strayed far from what I expect, and unfortunately, to places I never wanted to be.

* Add Storm Corrosion (self titled) to the list of likes ... SW collaborated with Mikael Åkerfeldt of Opeth on that one. I look forward to a reprise, but not holding my breath as it seems that was more a one shot deal ...

Someone also mentioned Up the Downstair ... I'd put that right up there as some of their most musical moments ... prepare to sit back and be mesmerized ... :thmbsp:

It sounds like you prefer the more Metal - like stuff. I like his music that is more like Pink Floyd and Genesis, which this album very much resembles.
 
I'd add FOABP to that list ...

It sounds like you prefer the more Metal - like stuff. I like his music that is more like Pink Floyd and Genesis, which this album very much resembles.

Strangely enough, PT ended up replacing Genesis as my "go to" band for overall wOw factor.

Then again, I do tend to wander musically ... recent spins here are Kompendium, Strangers on a Train, Beth Hart, Ben Harper, Steve Martin, and Betty Fox, with a smattering of Bach, Grofé, and Dvorak for texture ...

Oh, and Genesis ... pre-disco, of course ... ;-}
 
I bought the LP it comes with a flac download. Beautifully packaged and sounds fantastic. About the solo on regret #9, Steve manipulated an envelope filter in real time with Guthrie laid it down.

Overall I love it, but I like the Raven a bit more, and Grace for Drowning is my favorite. I still prefer the Porcupine Tree but I do enjoy his new stuff very much.
 
Fun Fact: Hand Cannot Erase is NOT mastered. SW claims that the mastering process is mostly useless, if of course your mixes are nearly perfect. Leave it to Wilson to make such a claim but if anybody can, it's him. I remember reading that he wasn't happy with the mastering on Insurgentes so maybe that experience ruined it for him. Either way, his records sound incredible.
 
Back
Top Bottom