My replacement glass has arrived and all the other parts have been sitting around for ages so it looks like I will start my SX-1980 rebuild in earnest this weekend.
I've looked on and off at the nefarious power supply JFET current source. I've designed a current source or two and have always liked the elegance of the single FET current source. However, in the 1980 that JFET seems like it was a silly indulgence that only got through a design review because the 1980 was the biggest of the big and price was no object. The actual electrical advantages are unclear, especially compared to a two transistor current source, itself an indulgence over the normal pullup resistor, although there is a case to be made. The zeners are a kludge, that much is clear.
Anyway, I am thinking of using a depletion mode MOSFET in place of the 2SK34. The devices I have are Microchip (nee Supertex) DN2530N3 and are rated for 300V, so I could ditch the protection zeners. I expect to have to tweak the source resistor (22ohm stock) to set the current, although I'm not sure it's critical +/- 50% would probably be fine. There also exists a 500v part with an Rds much closer to the original, which I estimate is around 1k. The ones I have currently are about 12 ohms.
Has anyone ever tried an alternate approach like this? Not sure if I am missing something or not but I am going to try it, first on the tracking supply and then on the dim bulb.
I've looked on and off at the nefarious power supply JFET current source. I've designed a current source or two and have always liked the elegance of the single FET current source. However, in the 1980 that JFET seems like it was a silly indulgence that only got through a design review because the 1980 was the biggest of the big and price was no object. The actual electrical advantages are unclear, especially compared to a two transistor current source, itself an indulgence over the normal pullup resistor, although there is a case to be made. The zeners are a kludge, that much is clear.
Anyway, I am thinking of using a depletion mode MOSFET in place of the 2SK34. The devices I have are Microchip (nee Supertex) DN2530N3 and are rated for 300V, so I could ditch the protection zeners. I expect to have to tweak the source resistor (22ohm stock) to set the current, although I'm not sure it's critical +/- 50% would probably be fine. There also exists a 500v part with an Rds much closer to the original, which I estimate is around 1k. The ones I have currently are about 12 ohms.
Has anyone ever tried an alternate approach like this? Not sure if I am missing something or not but I am going to try it, first on the tracking supply and then on the dim bulb.
