Nate was kind enough to sell me the BLH phono stage that he assembled (the one in the pics at the beginning of this thread), and it's been in my main system for several weeks now. When I received it, I did a brief comparison with my Acurus P10, meaning to write up my impressions for this thread. Well, other things got in the way, but seeing that there's some renewed interest in it now, I'll take this opportunity to go back over some of my thoughts. It's certainly a piece of equipment that deserves to have something said about it, even if I'm drawing mostly from memory here.
I contacted Nate about the BHL phono because, at the time, the Acurus was tied up and I wanted to be able to use a turntable with my Promitheus TVC, which pairs very nicely with the Odyssey Khartago that I have in my primary system. I should say from the outset that I don't have much experience with the wide variety of phono stages in the BHL's price range (last I checked, the kit, minus power supply, is ~$70), but for the money this strikes me as a very, very good preamp. It certainly has a more lively LF presentation than the Acurus, which tends, to my ear, to be more balanced across the frequency range. Listening to the Fela Kuti 10" reissue (which was the prize of my Record Store Day last year) through the Acurus is enjoyable, with very clear highs, but it lacks the propulsion and driving bass and drums of the BHL. In turn, the BHL gives up some of the air and upper-range clarity of the Acurus, but I found myself preferring its sound, perhaps because of the cartridge/turntable setup I was using: a Systemdek IIX and Audio Technica AT150mlx. I like both the table and the cart a lot, but, to my ear, the AT150mlx can sizzle at the top end, and perhaps the BHL mitigated this a little. If I had to describe each phono stage in a word, for the Acurus I'd say "clarity" and for the BHL, "musical."
Writing all this makes me think that I need to dress it up a little more. Right now, it's buttoned up in a plain black project box, but if I can find some time and the right enclosure, maybe I'll put that wenge veneer I bought recently to good use.
And thanks again, Nate, for parting with yours, and for starting this thread in the first place.