I've seen a few horrific "hack jobs", even much worse even than that. I don't know what these people think they are doing. The worst is that often this is done by 'professiona;s' who charge people money for screwing up their gear that way.
I'm an "amateur tech", too... but I make it a point of pride to work carefully and methodically, to do research first (as/when needed), use good materials and tools, etc... and I usually get good results that I'm reasonably proud of. If I do a soldering job that doesn't look good enough to me, and I can't re-flow it nicely, I'll suck it out and start over again. If I have doubts about any component, I'll get a meter out and check it, or replace it. If I'm re-capping, I'll check ALL resistors and transistors, too, and re-mount transistors with fresh grease, etc...
It's just a matter of personal integrity and pride in one's craftsmanship, of having to live with what I've done, every time I look at the gear or use it. If I did 'hack jobs', I'd quit trying to fix anything, if not for my own peace of mind, then for the sake of the gear!
So why can't all 'professionals' do the same? If we were talking about some huge investment of time, I could understand. It would be un-economical. But it takes no more time, really, to install a proper component than a wrong one, or to solder well instead of poorly, etc...
At least this poor, abused example is finally in the hands of someone who will make it all right again. Looking forward to seeing the progress through this thread!