• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Tower 5.1 Package Advice

Monitor Audio is a good company - they are favorably reviewed by the pros.
Look here for reviews done well: http://www.whathifi.com/reviews

NHT is a respected name in speakers - if you didn't like them, you probably are looking to spend a lot more than $200 even used to better them. Perhaps the rest of the system was not up to par with the NHT, or the synergy was not there.

Other good speaker companies are:

Paradigm (Studio series are really good but they go for about $500 used)
PSB

If you look through the review section of whathifi, there you will get many good recommendations - then you just have to go hunting for them.

You want to shy away from Polk, Jamo, some of Klipsch... You can do better even for $200.

Also, really good sounding 5.1 receiver is the Panasonic SA-XR (series) - you can get them for about $100 on ebay. It has a digital amp section that is efficient and powerful despite their small size! I am listening to it right now, and it sounds really quite good...

Good luck and welcome to this exciting hobby...
 
Monitor Audio is a good company - they are favorably reviewed by the pros.
Look here for reviews done well: http://www.whathifi.com/reviews

NHT is a respected name in speakers - if you didn't like them, you probably are looking to spend a lot more than $200 even used to better them. Perhaps the rest of the system was not up to par with the NHT, or the synergy was not there.

Other good speaker companies are:

Paradigm (Studio series are really good but they go for about $500 used)
PSB

If you look through the review section of whathifi, there you will get many good recommendations - then you just have to go hunting for them.

You want to shy away from Polk, Jamo, some of Klipsch... You can do better even for $200.

Also, really good sounding 5.1 receiver is the Panasonic SA-XR (series) - you can get them for about $100 on ebay. It has a digital amp section that is efficient and powerful despite their small size! I am listening to it right now, and it sounds really quite good...

Good luck and welcome to this exciting hobby...

Thanks for your recommendations. The NHT speakers I have are the A400s from 1992, so they weren't exactly top of the line, just cheap bookshelves really. Perhaps if I buy NHT towers that will be different?

What kind of amp would I need if I wanted to drive those Monitor Audios or Mirage or ADS L1290s or something else similar for movie watching? I Don't watch much in surround sound, even the films I watch are often just 2.0, but they have to be good for voice reproduction/sound effects as well, not only music...
 
Magneplanars, ADS, Dynaudios, Linn, and similar are not home theater receiver friendly to drive. As in you will need much more amp than that to drive one pair correctly mind a surround set.

Much more amp than what? What would you suggest I purchase as far as an amp? Please my post in the Amp forum: http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?p=6632569&posted=1#post6632569 I was thinking something like the higher end Denon AVRs, Onkyo TX-NRs, or even older Arcam receivers, etc.. some of which still produce 150+ watts per channel? Should I be looking at dynamic range or wattage or what to be able to drive those speakers correctly?
 
More amp than an A/V receiver can deliver. And can handle 4 ohm loads demanding high current. Magneplanars and ADS are very demanding speakers. The Arcam better models yes, but definitely not a Denon or Onkyo A/V. 150 watt rating fine but must be into a 4 ohm rating from 20-20,000 Hertz and with all channels driven. Separates are best for the Magnepans, the ADS, the Linn, the Dynaudios and similar. Monitor Audio and Paradigm are nice A/V receiver friendly options which the middle of the line Onkyos and Denons play nice with. And the Marantz units are worth considering and good music choices too for the price. For less efficient speakers with reactive loads impedance wise, you need full range, high current amplification to drive with lots of headroom. Most home theater A/V units until you get to the upper end tend to drive less demanding loudspeakers with powered subwoofers filling in the middle to low bass.
 
Yes the NHT towers sound quite good...

As far as the receiver is concerned, Panasonic SA-XR (xx) will drive the speakers you mentioned OK. (xx) = model nos like 45, 57, 70, etc.

One professional reviewer said it's a Krell killer. The Krell is a world class gear, as you probably have heard. Perhaps it's not that good, but pretty close, for peanuts these days on ebay - about $100.

If you want to better it, you would have to spend many many times over, perhaps with a multi thousands of $ costing pre amp and a power amp setup.

Many have sold those for this receiver!
 
More amp than an A/V receiver can deliver. And can handle 4 ohm loads demanding high current. Magneplanars and ADS are very demanding speakers. The Arcam better models yes, but definitely not a Denon or Onkyo A/V. 150 watt rating fine but must be into a 4 ohm rating from 20-20,000 Hertz and with all channels driven. Separates are best for the Magnepans, the ADS, the Linn, the Dynaudios and similar. Monitor Audio and Paradigm are nice A/V receiver friendly options which the middle of the line Onkyos and Denons play nice with. And the Marantz units are worth considering and good music choices too for the price. For less efficient speakers with reactive loads impedance wise, you need full range, high current amplification to drive with lots of headroom. Most home theater A/V units until you get to the upper end tend to drive less demanding loudspeakers with powered subwoofers filling in the middle to low bass.

Thanks for the explanation and recommendation. I am MOSTLY looking at higher end units anyways. So far I have found a Denon 3805 for around $150, a Denon 5800 (amazing build quality monster of a machine) for $375, a Harman Kardon Signature 2.0 Processor for $150 (this was $2500 new and amazingly built), Kenwood Z1 combo (Amp and processor) for $300, and I found all these thanks to recommendations and offerings from people on this and other forums. I just need to make a list like this of all the choices I have and narrow down from there and see the pluses and minuses of both and which will work best for powering older speakers, etc...

What do you think would work best? Besides the 5803 all of these are fairly higher end offerings?

So you think these Monitor Audios will play well I am going to look at them on Monday-Tuesday? I bought an AudioVector Center Channel speaker for $50, will this be OK or should I get a Monitor Audio center channel too?

Yes the NHT towers sound quite good...

As far as the receiver is concerned, Panasonic SA-XR (xx) will drive the speakers you mentioned OK. (xx) = model nos like 45, 57, 70, etc.

One professional reviewer said it's a Krell killer. The Krell is a world class gear, as you probably have heard. Perhaps it's not that good, but pretty close, for peanuts these days on ebay - about $100.

If you want to better it, you would have to spend many many times over, perhaps with a multi thousands of $ costing pre amp and a power amp setup.

Many have sold those for this receiver!

Thank you but I can't seem to find them in the US. I see them in Europe only and all of them are made in Malaysia...

Good Luck buying speakers like that. The KEF's, for example, are outsourced as are many of lower price point speakers in name brands.

Honestly I find people who argue this way MOOT. Would you rather them get a good wage in 3rd world countries or not?

Yes, but just because the speakers were 2K in the 90's doesn't mean they would sell for that now. Aesthetics and sound are equally important. Speaker design, materials, and testing have improved so much since then.

Many items are built with parts made in china and YOU CANNOT SCREEN those out.

The Panasonic many talk about is OK but no great shakes. I have demoed one and it could not drive the speakers I have. It may be good for a small room just don't expect theatre type of sound (very dynamic). It was also built in China.

I am not looking for new. The KEFs I have found in my price range are the Q50s which were made in England. My point is speakers that were 2K in the 90s beat out most speakers even at the $200 range today which are made in China and if for $200 I can get an ultimate top of the line $2000 speaker why not?

I would disagree about materials and quality improving. A lot of electronics look and feel cheaper today, with the exception of some very very high end offerings from Meridian, Goldmund, etc... Most of the newer Pioneers, Denons, etc... look and feel cheaper than their counterparts which were built in Japan a decade ago...

Also I know that in modern times, many parts are made in China, but I doubt that the Monitor Audio speakers have many Chinese parts compared to modern day speakers, same goes with a lot of receivers from 10 years ago compared to today...
 
Any other speakers to look for similar to the Monitor Audio R952/MD Speakers I found? I would prefer something high end like this from the late 80s to early 00s, but would be even better if it had a high gloss finish and better aesthetics (and equal or better SQ).
 
Last edited:
Hmmmm - the only floor standing speakers in your price range that come to mind are the Sony FS-5000. Had a pair hooked up to my 5.1 system for a while. Great bass response with action movies. Oh - Never mind, made in China. You might look at Boston Acoustic speakers but don't think you will find any that come up to your standards for a $200.00 budget.
 
I think you will be happier with the Monitor Audio - they are well received speakers by the pros at many hifi magazines - even their entry level ones.
 
I think you will be happier with the Monitor Audio - they are well received speakers by the pros at many hifi magazines - even their entry level ones.

So I went to listen to the Monitor Audio RM952/MDs today. They look amazing, high quality and brand new looking with original boxes and manual, etc... Unfortunately he had a pretty old amp from the 70s which only produced 60W per channel. It really didn't impress me at all. In fact, my Beosound Century/2000 sounds a million times better (actually better than anything I have owned) and it didn't even sound as good as my NHT bookshelves hooked to my Sony surround sound amp... Am I missing something? Maybe it's because he had an amp that wasn't so great and the speakers are capable of 180W? The size and looks were great but they seemed a bit small, almost like elongated bookshelves... At the price of $175 it sounds like a great deal but how do I know if it was the amp or the speakers? Will they sound amazing on my amp in comparison?
 
I finally got the chance to listen to some ADS L1290s that were for sale in my budget range. WOW the best speakers I have ever heard in my life, they blew away my expectations. The bass was perfect, the mids were magical and there were even two tweeters that looked like they had been assembled by a wizard in some magical cave. Is it because they have two woofers and two tweeters that they sound so amazing? Besides the design and build quality which is top notch (way advanced for its time). Somebody grabbed it from under my nose unfortunately, but they sounded amazing even with the old Onkyo amp that was powering it and giving no more than 75Watts or so per channel. With my newer Denon 120W it would sound even better. This is what crystal clear transparency is all about I guess. Not even the KEF Reference Model One or Monitor Audios I had heard come close to that.

Unfortunately, even though they are musical, building a surround sound system from them might have been impossible. I don't think ADS ever made a center channel speaker, and even if they did it wouldn't be from the same line and therefore wouldn't match... I think I might have to go for the KEFs... I like them but still not as magic as the ADS...
 
Again with ADS of that caliber, Denon is only adequate. And they really need separates to sound their best which can handle high current, 4 ohm loads, which demand high current. I love the ADS with Bryston, McIntosh, and similar gear. 5 of those would be drivable by no A/V or surround receiver ever made by man. Separates or a very few 2 channel receivers could do them justice, but it really takes something special to drive them correctly.
 
Again with ADS of that caliber, Denon is only adequate. And they really need separates to sound their best which can handle high current, 4 ohm loads, which demand high current. I love the ADS with Bryston, McIntosh, and similar gear. 5 of those would be drivable by no A/V or surround receiver ever made by man. Separates or a very few 2 channel receivers could do them justice, but it really takes something special to drive them correctly.

I didn't realize they were 4 ohms and not 6 or 8. The amp the guy was running was probably about 70-80 watts per channel at 8ohms, mine runs 120 at 8 or 240 at 4 per channel and it sounded amazing on his Onkyo from the 90s so would sound even better on my amp with the extra power.

I have seen a conversion into a center channel which you can see here: http://www.adsspeakersservice.com/#!gallery

But as you say it is a lot of work and might not be able to drive 5 speakers, even if two will sound good. Therefore I know the KEF Reference series in my budget is the only thing I found where I can match five speakers :tears: They sound good, but not amazing like the L1290s...
 
I just stick with 2 channels - this way, you will end up with more quality, and I don't miss other channels at all, in watching movies...

Consider this, and your search will be easier - and you can have a stellar system with ADS speakers and a nice 2 channel receiver...
 
Why do you need a surround sound system? I'd rather have two blow me away speakers than 5.1 meh.

I used to have 5.1 and maybe I miss it a little for movies, but not really. I just turn up the volume.

Also you could just get a set of the towers, find a set of smaller bookshelves for the rears and just run a phantom center. You also probably wouldn't need a sub since you've got dual 8" woofers on each tower...
 
Last edited:
I just stick with 2 channels - this way, you will end up with more quality, and I don't miss other channels at all, in watching movies...

Consider this, and your search will be easier - and you can have a stellar system with ADS speakers and a nice 2 channel receiver...

Haha if I considered that there would be NO search. I would only be searching for A/D/S Lxx90 series!

Why do you need a surround sound system? I'd rather have two blow me away speakers than 5.1 meh.

I used to have 5.1 and maybe I miss it a little for movies, but not really. I just turn up the volume.

Also you could just get a set of the towers, find a set of smaller bookshelves for the rears and just run a phantom center. You also probably wouldn't need a sub since you've got dual 8" woofers on each tower...

Yes I find that when watching the movies the center channel speaker is super important. The problem is that 90% of what I do is watch movies, if it was the other way around I would not even be having this conversation. I am not sure how it would sound in Phantom mode? I have two center channel speakers I can try to pair it with a KEF Reference 100 and an AudioVector AVC series one... I could try to hook up A/D/S Woofers and tweeter to the AudioVector enclosure but how would that work with the crossover among other things :scratch2:

About the rears, that wouldn't be a problem if I got some nice A/D/S Bookshelves... However, now finding another pair of A/D/S' is a problem in its own. Especially for $250 :sigh:
 
Back
Top Bottom