• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

True Grit, round II

Copa1934

My ears are bleeding
Remake? Not really sure. Definitely not as good as the original. I feel Bridges actually could have worked in the part, but it seemed over acted or something wasn't quite right. When you consider his role in Iron Man as a not so likeable character and well acted, I think the directing missed the mark with Bridges potential, for the role at least.

Just didn't really do it for me, but it wasn't a bad movie. If it didn't have a predecessor to compare to it would have ranked above average with some good action, some good humor, etc. There were some good scenes to be sure, but just not as complete and seemed over edited, not very smooth transitions at times from scene to scene.

Oh, finally watched it last night on instant. Image was terrific, for a change.
 
Register to hide this ad
Haven't seen it yet, maybe I'll spring for a rental if it's on Comcast. Like so many remakes I guess this falls to the same fate ... it pales to the original which I truly loved BTW ... (Wayne in the closing scene) ... "Well ... come see a fat ol' man someday!." Maybe somebody ought to start a "Remakes Better Than The Original" thread. Bet it wouldn't have very many post.
 
Last edited:
I liked the remake much more, of for no other reason than Hailee Steinfeld was much better as Mattie Ross than Kim Darby.

I also thought bridges did a great job.


Vacuum tubes are where it's at!
 
Funny, I just rented this movie today. Watching it tonight with the wife after supper.
Ill let ya know what I think.
 
Remake? Not really sure. Definitely not as good as the original. I feel Bridges actually could have worked in the part, but it seemed over acted or something wasn't quite right. When you consider his role in Iron Man as a not so likeable character and well acted, I think the directing missed the mark with Bridges potential, for the role at least.

Just didn't really do it for me, but it wasn't a bad movie. If it didn't have a predecessor to compare to it would have ranked above average with some good action, some good humor, etc. There were some good scenes to be sure, but just not as complete and seemed over edited, not very smooth transitions at times from scene to scene.

Oh, finally watched it last night on instant. Image was terrific, for a change.

I liked the remake a lot better. In the original there was zero chemistry between Wayne and whoever played Mattie. Wayne himself thought she was terrible in the role. Also, the remake is MUCH closer to the book and you don't have to watch Glen Campbell try to act and fail miserably.
 
I liked the remake better. And I'm a big fan of old westerns, I remember seeing The Searchers with my Dad in 1956. (What 7 year old wouldn't remember The Searchers? The "hero" shooting men in the back, shooting a dead man's eyes out and scalping his foe? Raw stuff in the 1950s.)

I must say I was surprised that the Coens pulled it off, I thought they were too smarmy and smart-alecky to make a good western.
 
Last edited:
I liked the remake better. And I'm a big fan of old westerns, I remember seeing The Searchers with my Dad in 1956. (What 7 year old wouldn't remember The Searchers? The "hero" shooting men in the back, shooting a dead man's eyes out and scalping his foe? Raw stuff in the 1950s.)

I must say I was surprised that the Coens pulled it off, I thought they were too smarmy and smart-alecky to make a good western.

+1. Though I'm a Coen Brothers fan, I was uncertain if a western was in their wheelhouse.
 
I liked the remake much more, of for no other reason than Hailee Steinfeld was much better as Mattie Ross than Kim Darby.

I also thought bridges did a great job.

Also, Glen Campbell was terrible in the original.

+1. Though I'm a Coen Brothers fan, I was uncertain if a western was in their wheelhouse.

It was a departure, for sure, but those guys have some serious talent.
 
I also liked the remake better. If you look at the original every scene was nice and sunny out. Very unrealistic...
 
Remake? Not really sure. Definitely not as good as the original. I feel Bridges actually could have worked in the part, but it seemed over acted or something wasn't quite right.

the "something" that wasn`t quite right is jeff bridges. jeffie looks quite disheveled these days, he needs a haircut, shave, and a blood transfusion but rather than waste all that money better to send him off to the glue factory like you would an old horse that has no more use on the farm.
 
I also liked the remake better. If you look at the original every scene was nice and sunny out. Very unrealistic...
As realism goes, yes the remake was more believeable. Many scenes reminded me of Arizona, Nevada, etc. more so than a movie set. However, back in those days (John Wayne, etc.) camera equipment cost significantly more than many of the actors, not to mention foul weather was not condusive to "people" or shooting. I know, poor excuse, but that's the way it was back then, with few exceptions. More about the actors "image" and looks on screen than realism.

Maybe I'm just a died in the wool Marion Ross fan. Oh well.

As for Cambell, I feel he played his part as perceived by Waynes character. The remakes character was more realistic.

Maybe I need to watch it again. As for remakes in general, I agree most are sub quality, but I believe I've seen a few that did justice or were better than the original.
 
the "something" that wasn`t quite right is jeff bridges. jeffie looks quite disheveled these days, he needs a haircut, shave, and a blood transfusion but rather than waste all that money better to send him off to the glue factory like you would an old horse that has no more use on the farm.

Which is pretty much exactly how you'd expect drunkard Rooster Cogburn to look and act.

Remake? Not really sure. Definitely not as good as the original. I feel Bridges actually could have worked in the part, but it seemed over acted or something wasn't quite right.

The overly-stiff language is probably what is tripping you here. It's very true to the source novel, which was somewhat poking fun of the perception of that era. Remember, what we're seeing is old Maddie's recollection of what happened, and she's giving everyone very formal phrasing rather than the "rough and tumble" English dialects that would have been spoken by the grizzled men of the frontier.
 
Last edited:
the "something" that wasn`t quite right is jeff bridges. jeffie looks quite disheveled these days, he needs a haircut, shave, and a blood transfusion but rather than waste all that money better to send him off to the glue factory like you would an old horse that has no more use on the farm.

Nah, he just needs, you know, like a couple of White Russians, man!
 
the "something" that wasn`t quite right is jeff bridges. jeffie looks quite disheveled these days, he needs a haircut, shave, and a blood transfusion but rather than waste all that money better to send him off to the glue factory like you would an old horse that has no more use on the farm.

Easy, buster.:nono:

The Dude was also great in Crazy Heart.
 
As realism goes, yes the remake was more believeable. Many scenes reminded me of Arizona, Nevada, etc. more so than a movie set. However, back in those days (John Wayne, etc.) camera equipment cost significantly more than many of the actors, not to mention foul weather was not condusive to "people" or shooting. I know, poor excuse, but that's the way it was back then, with few exceptions. More about the actors "image" and looks on screen than realism.

In the original, the Duke's horse had wheels on it for the final charge across the meadow scene; at least for the closeups.
 
I have always liked the original, but thought it to be corny. The remake (to me) is superior in every way.
 
Back
Top Bottom