• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Turntable Mat Or Not?

Dfndr

New Member
Anyone use a turntable without a mat?
My sales guy, who set up my new turntable, was adamant that I should not use the nice leather mat that came with it and that I should just play the records directly on the aluminum turntable. He felt so strongly that I went along with it and he set the VT with no mat.
What do you think? Did I make a mistake?
 
Register to hide this ad
The record will ring like a bell.
And it can get damaged against the hard surface.
And if the platter is as large as an LP., the record will be supported by its raised edge.
Sales guy is playing with you. What did you do to tick him off?
 
Yeah, I asked him if it would damage the records and he said, "Absolutely not!". Then he said a mat was to prevent ringing and he tapped the deck with his fingers/knuckles and said the deck would not ring.with its aluminum thickness. The deck came with a clamp that he said to use.
 
Counterpoint ... from threads I’ve seen elsewhere ... Seems most VPI Classic owners prefer the sound with no mat. I have a NOS NIB one not yet setup, but hope to finish my room within a couple weeks and can report back my own observations.

Heretofore I’ve used rubber or cork mats on metal and glass platters.

And while your platter is metal, I’d also say it seems most owners with acrylic platters prefer without mat. And see a lot of acrylic mats, which would seem to support using an acrylic platter naked.
 
And while your platter is metal, I’d also say it seems most owners with acrylic platters prefer without mat. And see a lot of acrylic mats, which would seem to support using an acrylic platter naked.

As I was reading through this topic, I was going to add that an acrylic platter might be the only type I would consider not using a mat.
 
Agreed. My Marantz 15S is acrylic and no mat but anything with an aluminum platter will ring. What turntable??
 
Well Tempered Lab Turntable no mat as designed.

All of my other tables with metal platters have mats, for various reasons they are part of the design. One as mentioned to reduce ringing of the platter, another the mats additional weight helps with speed accuracy, also tables without VTA adjustment were designed with the thickness of the mat in mind.
 
Anyone use a turntable without a mat?
My sales guy, who set up my new turntable, was adamant that I should not use the nice leather mat that came with it and that I should just play the records directly on the aluminum turntable. He felt so strongly that I went along with it and he set the VT with no mat.
What do you think? Did I make a mistake?
Dfndr, what turntable?
 
Can I ask which turntable you have? Oooops, just now saw that several others have asked the same question. Also, what "clamp" did the salesperson provide with the table? This would be helpful in responding to your question.

I have a Nottingham Spacedeck, which has an "alloy" platter that looks and feels mostly metal. Trying a number of different mats, including the one that came with the deck (which Tom Fletcher, the originator of it, alludes to as more of a "dust mat"), left me with a very distinct preference for using no mat at all.

Here's where the details might contain the devil though.....my platter size is such that a record fits perfectly, with no overhang, nor are they typically smaller leaving space unless, of course, it is a 10" 45rpm or a 7" 45rpm. But let's focus on the 12" 33 1/3rpm record that most of us spin most of the time. Should your platter be similar to mine, the record will only touch the platter at the very outer edge and in the label area which are both (typically, not always, but only rarely not) raised slightly. The reason the industry contrived this configuration, as I understand it, was so that when a spindle is in use with a number of records stacked on it to be played, as each one drops down on the previous one, they will not touch in the groove area, only the label and outer edge. So, when I clamp my record down, it forces the outer edge of the record down firmly against the outer platter edge resulting in a very flat playing surface. This works perfectly in my situation, YMMV depending on your platter and the clamp, which is why I have requested more information about each.

Further, many clamp designs are really not very useful at all. 4-2-7 has an excellent thread on this subject and with his observations, I was able to modify my clamp (ADC, Pro-Grip - see my avatar) so that it actually performs the intended job and gets the record flat on the platter. That thread is here, should you wish to peruse:

https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...ntable-you-should-have-a-record-clamp.816837/

It's a bit long, but you will no doubt enjoy the learning along the way as I did. The crucial thing about it is, if you have a clamp, let's make sure it is actually doing what you want it to do. I was able to modify my clamp with a modest effort and it now does just that. Previously, when I attached it to the record over the platter, I could literally see the outer edges of the record forced upwards instead of downwards.

So, as some others have also said, whatever suits you and sounds best is the way to go.....I don't think there are any hard and fast rules due to the vast differences from one table to the next. I'm also not thinking your salesman would want to alienate a potential future customer by giving bad advice.....not intentionally anyhow.

Good luck with your new table and in time, this will all get sorted out and leave you listening happily.....hopefully!
 
Last edited:
. . . Come to think of it, I've never seen a TT that did not come with a mat. Not saying it's impossible but it's quite a surprise for me.
Grenadeslio mentioned the Well Tempered Lab Turntable. I had the Well Tempered Record Player which also came without a mat but with a clamp. I know that the original VPI Scout also came without a mat and with a clamp, though reviewer Art Dudley said he preferred the sound using a thin felt mat and no clamp. I also preferred my WTRP with no clamp but borrowing the felt mat from my Linn. Those examples were with an acrylic platter; I can't recall a turntable with an aluminum platter coming without a mat.

Anyone use a turntable without a mat?
My sales guy, who set up my new turntable, was adamant that I should not use the nice leather mat that came with it and that I should just play the records directly on the aluminum turntable. He felt so strongly that I went along with it and he set the VT with no mat.
What do you think? Did I make a mistake?
If it were me, I'd simply try playing it with and without the supplied mat and see if I prefer it one way or the other. I might also try a Linn felt mat because I've really liked it with other turntables I've owned, whether matless or replacing a turntable's original mat.
 
If it were me, I'd simply try playing it with and without the supplied mat and see if I prefer it one way or the other.

There you go.....experiment, and don't get too hung up on the "shoulds" and "shouldn'ts".....sound is all about what hits YOUR ears so that's the most important aspect of all this and the only way you find what you're lookin' for is to try things out.
 
I have a Linn and I have tried the original felt mat, rubber, cork, and others I can't remember, and finally, leather (split cowhide). The leather mat creates a dead quiet, blacker background for the music than anything else I've tried. I'm done experimenting.And the leather mat cost 30+ bucks, the cheapest of the lot.
 
Welcome, ramon68.....would you mind telling me which mat you bought and from where you got it?
 
Last edited:
I have a Linn and I have tried the original felt mat, rubber, cork, and others I can't remember, and finally, leather (split cowhide). The leather mat creates a dead quiet, blacker background for the music than anything else I've tried. I'm done experimenting.And the leather mat cost 30+ bucks, the cheapest of the lot.
I think preferences come down to what sonic criteria we each pay the most attention to. For me, enjoying records is mostly about musical expression in terms of pace, rhythm, and dynamics, and my ears haven't heard anything as consistently good as the Linn felt mat (which is also $30). It will be interesting to hear if the OP prefers the sound with or without the leather mat supplied with his turntable. I would have thought that his dealer would demonstrate the difference to him with a display model prior to the purchase and setup of his 'table, but from the OP's uncertainty, I have to assume he didn't receive that kind of service.
 
Grenadeslio mentioned the Well Tempered Lab Turntable. I had the Well Tempered Record Player which also came without a mat but with a clamp. I know that the original VPI Scout also came without a mat and with a clamp, though reviewer Art Dudley said he preferred the sound using a thin felt mat and no clamp. I also preferred my WTRP with no clamp but borrowing the felt mat from my Linn. Those examples were with an acrylic platter; I can't recall a turntable with an aluminum platter coming without a mat.


If it were me, I'd simply try playing it with and without the supplied mat and see if I prefer it one way or the other. I might also try a Linn felt mat because I've really liked it with other turntables I've owned, whether matless or replacing a turntable's original mat.

not sure about your WTL, but mine has a dished platter designed specifically to be used with the clamp, and a mat screws up the designs functionality. Art Dudley commented the design worked as well as any vacuum hold down system he had ever seen.
 
not sure about your WTL, but mine has a dished platter designed specifically to be used with the clamp, and a mat screws up the designs functionality. Art Dudley commented the design worked as well as any vacuum hold down system he had ever seen.
At least with respect to the WTRP, Dudley mentioned disliking the "drastically concave platter," and ended up turning the platter upside down and playing records on the underside. He didn't think it sounded any better that way, but he liked the flatter surface:

"The sound? Precisely as before—which is to say, wonderful. My peace of mind? A tenfold improvement. Maybe twelvefold." https://www.stereophile.com/content/listening-47-follow-january-2008

I didn't end up using the upside-down platter method, but, as I mentioned before, it sounded best to me with a Linn mat and without the screw-down clamp.
 
If the platter rings then a mat should be used to damp the ringing. If it doesn't ring, the record can safely be used without provided the platter is stopped when handling the record.
 
At least with respect to the WTRP, Dudley mentioned disliking the "drastically concave platter," and ended up turning the platter upside down and playing records on the underside. He didn't think it sounded any better that way, but he liked the flatter surface:

"The sound? Precisely as before—which is to say, wonderful. My peace of mind? A tenfold improvement. Maybe twelvefold." khttps://www.stereophile.com/content/listening-47-follow-january-2008

I didn't end up using the upside-down platter method, but, as I mentioned before, it sounded best to me with a Linn mat and without the screw-down clamp.


I stand corrected, it was Brian Damkroger on the Reference Turntable much more akin to my table than the Record Player Art Dudley reviewed, maybe there was a design change.

"Like everything else about the WT, the screw-down clamp and dished platter work beautifully—easily as good as any vacuum hold-down system I've used."

https://www.stereophile.com/turntables/899wtt/index.html

And again, using any mat will completely negate this great design aspect of the table, I tried a mat and it was a disaster.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom