Can I ask which turntable you have? Oooops, just now saw that several others have asked the same question. Also, what "clamp" did the salesperson provide with the table? This would be helpful in responding to your question.
I have a Nottingham Spacedeck, which has an "alloy" platter that looks and feels mostly metal. Trying a number of different mats, including the one that came with the deck (which Tom Fletcher, the originator of it, alludes to as more of a "dust mat"), left me with a very distinct preference for using no mat at all.
Here's where the details might contain the devil though.....my platter size is such that a record fits perfectly, with no overhang, nor are they typically smaller leaving space unless, of course, it is a 10" 45rpm or a 7" 45rpm. But let's focus on the 12" 33 1/3rpm record that most of us spin most of the time. Should your platter be similar to mine, the record will only touch the platter at the very outer edge and in the label area which are both (typically, not always, but only rarely not) raised slightly. The reason the industry contrived this configuration, as I understand it, was so that when a spindle is in use with a number of records stacked on it to be played, as each one drops down on the previous one, they will not touch in the groove area, only the label and outer edge. So, when I clamp my record down, it forces the outer edge of the record down firmly against the outer platter edge resulting in a very flat playing surface. This works perfectly in my situation, YMMV depending on your platter and the clamp, which is why I have requested more information about each.
Further, many clamp designs are really not very useful at all. 4-2-7 has an excellent thread on this subject and with his observations, I was able to modify my clamp (ADC, Pro-Grip - see my avatar) so that it actually performs the intended job and gets the record flat on the platter. That thread is here, should you wish to peruse:
https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...ntable-you-should-have-a-record-clamp.816837/
It's a bit long, but you will no doubt enjoy the learning along the way as I did. The crucial thing about it is, if you have a clamp, let's make sure it is actually doing what you want it to do. I was able to modify my clamp with a modest effort and it now does just that. Previously, when I attached it to the record over the platter, I could literally see the outer edges of the record forced upwards instead of downwards.
So, as some others have also said, whatever suits you and sounds best is the way to go.....I don't think there are any hard and fast rules due to the vast differences from one table to the next. I'm also not thinking your salesman would want to alienate a potential future customer by giving bad advice.....not intentionally anyhow.
Good luck with your new table and in time, this will all get sorted out and leave you listening happily.....hopefully!