• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Using SS replacement for 5u4/5ar4/5y3 rectifiers

gogofast

Addicted Member
Someone gave me a few solid state replacement rectifiers for 5u4. When using these in place of tube rectifiers, since there's no warmup time, I'm guessing the output tube cathodes will be greatly stressed. Will installing a thermistor take care of the problem? or do I need to install a standby switch?
 
Register to hide this ad
Some I've seen claim soft start but I'm skeptical. An add on soft start board or a standby switch might be a good idea.
 
Thank them politely for the offer, then give them back.

LOL. While I'm really on your side for the matter, I wonder what a SS rectifier can do in some of my higher powered amps. I assume that these SS replacements have some sort of circuit inside to compensate for the lack of voltage sag. :scratch2:
 
... When using these in place of tube rectifiers, since there's no warmup time, I'm guessing the output tube cathodes will be greatly stressed. ...

For the kind of tubes we use in our amplifiers, cathode stripping is not an issue. Ever wonder how the rectifier tube's cathode survives after the amp is turned on but before the cathode (or filament) gets hot?

People who operate broadcast radio and TV station tube transmitters do have to worry about cathode stripping. As those tubes use a different secret sauce on their cathodes.

So you can use the solid state rectifiers without worry.
 
Cathode stripping is not the only worry. At turn-on the power supply capacitors charge to a high voltage, many times exceeding the capacitor’s voltage rating. Depending on the overload margin, this can be fatal for the capacitor.

A solid state substitute may also produce a higher B+ that could cause the output tubes to exceed their maximum safe operating rating.
 
The whole concept of cathode stripping at audio amp voltages is greatly over-exaggerated. Its really not a problem. There were a lot of amplifiers made with solid state rectifiers.


What is a problem is potentially incorrect voltages when running, and possibly under-rated components elsewhere. Parts that may never see more than 200v with a typical rectifier may see 500v for a brief bit with an SS one, and if they are not rated for it stuff will blow up. If done properly, with appropriate resistors to mimic the vacuum rectifier's voltage drop when running and components that can deal with the full B+ before tubes conduct it works fine, otherwise you may be asking for trouble.
 
...What is a problem is potentially incorrect voltages when running, and possibly under-rated components elsewhere. Parts that may never see more than 200v with a typical rectifier may see 500v for a brief bit with an SS one, and if they are not rated for it stuff will blow up. If done properly, with appropriate resistors to mimic the vacuum rectifier's voltage drop when running and components that can deal with the full B+ before tubes conduct it works fine, otherwise you may be asking for trouble.
Well stated. :thmbsp:
 
The whole concept of cathode stripping at audio amp voltages is greatly over-exaggerated. Its really not a problem. There were a lot of amplifiers made with solid state rectifiers.


What is a problem is potentially incorrect voltages when running, and possibly under-rated components elsewhere. Parts that may never see more than 200v with a typical rectifier may see 500v for a brief bit with an SS one, and if they are not rated for it stuff will blow up. If done properly, with appropriate resistors to mimic the vacuum rectifier's voltage drop when running and components that can deal with the full B+ before tubes conduct it works fine, otherwise you may be asking for trouble.

Hi,

I have a Valve Amp which was built from a kit. The rectifiers are all solid state. The output from the transformer goes through a large dropper resistor which gets shorted out after a delay to feed full HT. The delay gives all heaters a chance to get up to operating temperatures.

As I understand it, it is not a good idea to apply full DC voltages to valves which have not achieved enough temp at the heater to achieve emission. As the valves are not conducting large voltages will be present across the Anode/Cathode which are not present under normal running circumstances. You could end up with arcing over within the tube. This will right off the tube.

A valve rectifier needs time to achieve conduction itself so this problem does not arise. By the time the HT starts to grow, the rest of the tubes are conducting anyway.

I first came across this on a very large Tektronix Oscilloscope. This had so many valves in it that it was a room warmer!!! The delay on that was approx 45 sec before the HT was enabled.

The capacitors should have been rated to withstand higher HT than the norm as this could quite easily happen due to a defective tube. This does not necessarily include ALL the tubes being defective by being cold!!!

Hope this helps.

Cheers

GPS16
 
A 5U4( or any of the DH diode tubes) conduct effectively instantly and as such behave just like SS diodes. If the design is marginal, the higher B+ SS diodes can deliver under load may be an issue. Tube gear is rather infamously famous for crappy, marginal design like this, so figure out just exactly what is going on in your equipment.
cheers,
Douglas
 
Thanks for all the inputs.

So, I guess, once again, it boils down to having to try it and see what happens. :D
 
There is a neat little pic based mosfet b+ delay that could fairly easily be built into a 5ar4 substitute can size for plug and play ss conversion. It was designed by Jan Didden. It detects mains zero crossing and applies b+ at just the right time after a delay of 40 seconds or so. Details are here: http://linearaudio.nl/sites/linearaudio.net/files/AX1402JanDidden.pdf Jan was kind enough to share the hex file with me as I'm going to attempt to build one of these so if anyone is interested in programming the pic and giving it a try I might be able to help. Without a dropping resistor as previously posted your b+ would be increased and that might not be so good for your amp. Actually a bucking transformer on the ac line isn't a bad idea just to get the ac voltage down to 120volts. Where I live we routinely have 130+ vac at the mains which raises all your voltages and can shorten tube life.
 
Back
Top Bottom