Maybe someone can answer this for me.... Usually, when you ask a question like this, people just say "Deoxit". But what is the difference between say, 'electronics cleaner', 'contact cleaner', and finally the aforementioned 'Deoxit'. I've had trouble understanding this. You go to Radio Shack, and you'll see "electronics cleaner", and then right next to it you'll see a can of "contact cleaner". Which is better, and where does Deoxit fit in here? Is Deoxit an "electronics cleaner", a "contact-cleaner", or something different from either of them? It's time I figure this out once and for all.
I've been confused by the Radio Shack cleaners as well.
They used to have one of the cans labeled Tuner Cleaner. It sprayed out white and bubbly, then cleared up. The reviews were mixed from ok to made things worse.
I haven't tried their other cleaners, just because, we have Deoxit available locally. And Deoxit is maybe $2-$3 more.
Everybody has their own preference based on their own experiences.
Once they find something that works safely they stick with it because it is confusing to decipher all the labels. That's also why I avoid automotive cleaners. Things I would look for are words like for audio electronics, for potentiometers, circuit board contacts...
A lot of people use different formulations depending on what is available locally. Deoxit is just one of those with a shared common experience.
Here are tips from various threads and even this is not complete --- take from it what you will:
Pots/potentiometers are the rotary knobs. If you use Deoxit D5 recommended with Faderlube F5 to replenish lubrication.
Switches can be toggle levers or buttons. Use Deoxit.
Sliders are fader knobs that slide like on equalizers. Recommended to use Faderlube only on these. "Fader" - lube.
Some will recommend only Faderlube F5 or Deoxit D100 (can may be labeled D100S-2) on rotary knobs so as to play it safe and not lift and damage sensitive membranes or coatings. Although I don't know if it might just be the repeated working back and forth.
Some report damage to Sherwood volume knobs using D5.
Some recommend Deoxit D5, Faderlube, and Gold as a complete regimen for cleaning pots. Deoxit D5 to clean. Faderlube for lube, Gold for longer term preservative. Some just use Deoxit/Gold combintation.
I don't use the Radio Shack twin pack of Deoxit DN5 and Gold GN5 because it's uneconomical. And the 14 gram quick-drying breath sprays seem more suited for cleaning RCA jacks and connections rather than for fully flushing switches, pots and other contact cleaning. In fact the label on the package at RS now identifies it for what it is "Connector Cleaner." Quick dry, no flushing action.
So I prefer the 5 oz (142 gram) Deoxit D5 (which has more solvents and flushing action for cleaning) and/or Faderlube F5 (for more lube) for just about all my cleaning applications. Just my preference. They are more easily available locally.
Radio Shack has the DN5 GN5 twinpack Connector Cleaner. About $15 for 14 grams. They also have other house brand cans labeled electronic cleaner.
Deoxit D5 5oz 142 grams can be found for about $13.99, Faderlube F5 $11.99 at Fry's. You can also find Deoxit at Guitar Center or any musical instrument store. Prices can vary.
14 grams v 142 grams: You get 10 times more product for less than half as much more dollars.
Also do not confuse D100L which is listed as the ingredient in Deoxit D5 with Deoxit D100. If you want 100% Deoxit (no solvents) look for D100 or D100S-2 on the label of the can.
As far as alternatives some people like CRC. There are cheaper electronics cleaners than Deoxit, and for large cleanup to be economical, I will use Puretronics (or any specifically for audio electronics and non-residue) or anhydrous 99.9 alcohol from Fry's for general cleanup of boards/large surface areas and use Deoxit/Faderlube specifically for pots, Deoxit for switches and final contact cleanups or where I deem worthy of the best stuff. Careful of some sprays which spray out freezing cold which can damage solder joints. Or Radio Shack's special contact tuner cleaner which sprays out white bubbly and crackly like pop rocks before it clears up and leaves a greasy petroleum residue.
Tutorial on cleaning with Deoxit (sticky in General Audio):
The Idiot's Guide to Using DeOxit (revisited)
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=207005
Tips on cleaning tuner (sticky in Tuners):
How to clean a tuner (analog)
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=144163
See thread for recommendations on non-residual contact cleaners.
Here's the best summary I have found on the various Deoxits:
DESCRIPTION OF VARIOUS DEOXIT
http://store.caig.com/s.nl/it.I/id.66/.f
A) Standard Spray: Provides flushing action
Products:
DeoxIT® D5 Spray (D5S-6) & DeoxIT® D5 Mini-Spray (D5MS-15)
DeoxIT® GOLD G5 Spray (G5S-6) & DeoxIT® GOLD G5 Mini-Spray (G5MS-15)
DeoxIT® SHIELD S5 Spray (S5S-6) & DeoxIT® SHIELD S5 Mini-Spray (S5MS-15)
Formulation: 5% DeoxIT® (active ingredient), 75% odorless mineral spirits (carrier solvent), 20% propellant
Formulation contains petroleum naphtha (odorless mineral spirits) solvent, and is briefly flammable (until solvent evaporates within 2-3 minutes). It's slower to evaporate, providing flushing action to remove surfaces dirt, grease and other contaminants. Is ideal for connectors and components removed from equipment or those that are easily accessible. It is safe on plastics. When in doubt, always test for compatibility, especially vintage equipment with aging ABS plastic(s).
B) Non drip - Quick Dry Spray: Nonflammable, fast evaporating carrier solvent formula
Products:
DeoxIT® DN5 Spray (DN5S-6) & DeoxIT® DN5 Mini-Spray (DN5MS-15)
DeoxIT® GOLD GN5 Spray (GN5S-6N) & DeoxIT® GOLD GN5 Mini-Spray (GN5MS-15)
DeoxIT® GOLD GX5 Spray (GX5S-6N)
DeoxIT® SHIELD SN5 Spray (SN5S-6N) & DeoxIT® SHIELD SN5 Mini-Spray (SN5MS-15)
Formulation: 5% DeoxIT® (active ingredient), 75% 1,1,1,3,3-PENTAFLUOROPROPANE (carrier solvent), 1-5% isopropyl alcohol, 20% propellant
May be used where fast evaporation and/or non-flammability is required, and no dripping is preferred. It is also safe on plastics.
C) 100% Spray: No solvents, metered one-shot valve
Products:
DeoxIT® D100 Spray (D100S-2)
DeoxIT® GOLD G100 Spray (G100S-2)
Formulation: 20% DeoxIT® (active ingredient), 80% propellant
May be used where maximum lubrication is needed, but solvents are not desired. For example, where cleaning and lubrication is required or over-spray might adversely affect sensitive plastics. DeoxIT® utilizes a metered valve which sprays short bursts of 100% liquid.
and to maybe add more confusion ...
gold v deoxit ....
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showpost.php?p=3693359&postcount=117 Gold is recommended as preservative for longer term maintenance. Part of a complete pots regimen consisting of Deoxit D5, Faderlube F5, and Gold G5. You often just see D5 and F5 recommended and it works well. That's because it's a bit of stretch of the budget to add a 3rd additional can of Gold G5 for some. Some just use D5 and G5.