• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What is with the variable impedance?

opusarlo

Active Member
Coming from a long history of car audio, I am used to dealing with either 4 or 2-ohm drivers with single or dual voice coils. Through various techniques such as bridging or strapping, you could come up with almost any final impedance, but there was one thing that was never done...we never went with 8 ohm or higher voice coils. Getting into the home stereo scene I see all sorts of impedance numbers from 4 to 20 ohms. How is this reconciled, and what are some 'typical' final impedances? In car audio, lower impedance was correlative with increased SPL, and higher impedance with increased sound quality. Is this still true in home audio, and do people really have 20ohm setups?
 
Register to hide this ad
Car audio: lower impedance means more available amplifier power - based on the limitations of a 12 volt system. IMO impedance has little to do with sound quality. There are good systems with low impedance, and bad with high, and most people should worry about impedance if it affects amplifier compatibility. My 2 cents....
 
Most speakers designed for home use are rated at 4, 6 or 8 Ohms (some older speakers are rated for 16 Ohms). However, the actual impedance of most any speaker varies with the frequency it's reproducing. There are some exceptions to this. Magneplanars have a relatively constant impedance regardless of the frequency.

Lower or higher impedance has absolutely nothing to do with SPL's or sound quality.
 
...

Lower or higher impedance has absolutely nothing to do with SPL's or sound quality.

I agree with not sound quality.

That said, indirectly it does affect SPL moreso in car audio because lower nominal impedance makes it easier to get higher power thus higher SPL with the low voltage automotive electrical system.

Just for a simple example, 8 ohm load with 14V could theoretically muster only about 25W. If the load is dropped to 1 ohm one could theoretically get nearly 200W.

Now, there are all sorts of other things done to increase power in automotive systems like BTL/bridged amps to increase output voltage swing, and amps with DC to DC step-up converters to increase rail voltages. But what was said before about lower impedance for the lower voltage electrical system is the basic reason car systems went that way.
 
Last edited:
I agree with not sound quality.

That said, indirectly it does affect SPL moreso in car audio because lower nominal impedance makes it easier to get higher power thus higher SPL with the low voltage automotive electrical system.

Just for a simple example, 8 ohm load with 14V could theoretically muster only about 25W. If the load is dropped to 1 ohm one could theoretically get nearly 200W.
Yes - pretty much spot on there. Notice I used the word "correlative" and not "causative" in my original post. This is why I am seeking information on this topic. I know impedance does not directly affect either category, but I know nothing else about it.
 
For most home gear and speakers, impedance is a non-issue. There are some exceptions such as some Apogee ribbons. Some of them have a load of 1 to 2 Ohms. A load this low has a tendency to cause many amplifiers to emit magic smoke or go into protect mode. This is also evident with many receivers which have problems driving Magneplanars. Many Maggies are 4 Ohm and decidedly not receiver friendly. Some receivers have a switch on the back panel that limits the available current for 4 Ohm loads to protect the amplifier stage.
 
The typical nominal impedances have already been said. But, within those, there are swings.of impedance relative to frequency.

If you Google speaker impedance plot you should find any number of examples. Some showing big swings, some with less variance.

These swings in impedance can affect the sound of the system by affecting the linearity of the amp's frequency response, particularly where the amplifier has low damping factor (high output impedance).
 
However, the actual impedance of most any speaker varies with the frequency it's reproducing.

Here there is a picture taken from Wikipedia. The "nominal Z" corresponds to the specified impedance of the loudspeaker.

1224px-Speaker_impedance.svg.png
 
ok...I am beginning to see the picture here and how ohms play a role. I did not know that impedance varies that much at all. So,
The typical nominal impedances have already been said. But, within those, there are swings.of impedance relative to frequency.

If you Google speaker impedance plot you should find any number of examples. Some showing big swings, some with less variance.

These swings in impedance can affect the sound of the system by affecting the linearity of the amp's frequency response, particularly where the amplifier has low damping factor (high output impedance).
I think there is an opportunity for me to learn some more based on that last part of your post where you infer a relationship between impedance and damping factor.
 
The damping factor of an amplifier can vary depending on the load it's working into. In practice it's not really an issue.
 
I politely disagree. the impetus behind this thread was information to aid me in the construction of a large folded horn enclosure for a 12" subwoofer. The weight of the cone, volume, linearity of excursion, and damping become critical since these factors control the potential for the woofer to overshoot. I know that the length and diameter (impedance) of speaker wire plays a massive role in damping. This is the whole reason to use the largest and lowest impedance speaker wire as well as to mount your amp to the speaker box or at least have it very close by. Damping is, actually, critical especially with large drivers. Damping rating offered by manufacturers matters much less. Now that I reread what I wrote, I think we might be actually saying the same thing.
 
8 times output impedance for headphones and your golden. Probably true for speakers too?

My speakers are 6 Ohm
 
I think headphones can have a universal formula because they are relatively universal in wire gauge as well as length. Home stereo not so much because you could have 75' of 14 gauge speaker wire or even 1 foot of 10 gauge. These variabilities will dramatically affect the damping factor. Years ago I purchase a brand new Mitsu tower system that had 120 wpc. I hooked it up with the included wire, and it would cut out at 3/4 volume - I am assuming a protection mode. I purchased better wire and was able to crank it.
 
I politely disagree. the impetus behind this thread was information to aid me in the construction of a large folded horn enclosure for a 12" subwoofer. The weight of the cone, volume, linearity of excursion, and damping become critical since these factors control the potential for the woofer to overshoot. I know that the length and diameter (impedance) of speaker wire plays a massive role in damping. This is the whole reason to use the largest and lowest impedance speaker wire as well as to mount your amp to the speaker box or at least have it very close by. Damping is, actually, critical especially with large drivers. Damping rating offered by manufacturers matters much less. Now that I reread what I wrote, I think we might be actually saying the same thing.

Now calculate the voice coil into your equation. See?

Now you come up with a damping factor of something like 5 that is relevant.

Suddenly the wires take a back seat in the equation.

While electrical damping matters, it is largely the mechanical (air, surround) damping which is the actual factor.

I learned this here just a bit ago, I always thought it reaally matters. (thinking about it, I did hear that in car audio and subwoofers)
 
Last edited:
Bingo.

It is pretty amazing actually how thoroughly we as an industry managed to brainwash 12V guys over the years. Especially on damping factor, which was so rarely a relevant issue in a business where even though load impedances were uniformly on the low side, simply because most high powered 12V amplifiers tend to have incredibly low output impedances due to all of the paralleled devices in their output stages. The calculations will show you that it's very difficult to get to the point where the system damping factor gets low enough to become an audible problem, yet the "if the number is bigger it must be better" dumbed-down marketing pitch has stuck like aging peanut butter to the roofs of our collective mouths.

Here's a fun site to play with the calculations, if you're interested: http://www.bcae1.com/dampfact.htm

BTW, the general consensus is that system factors > 30 are fine, and you have to actually get a fair amount lower than that before it's a real problem.

John
 
Bingo.

It is pretty amazing actually how thoroughly we as an industry managed to brainwash 12V guys over the years. Especially on damping factor, which was so rarely a relevant issue in a business where even though load impedances were uniformly on the low side, simply because most high powered 12V amplifiers tend to have incredibly low output impedances due to all of the paralleled devices in their output stages. The calculations will show you that it's very difficult to get to the point where the system damping factor gets low enough to become an audible problem, yet the "if the number is bigger it must be better" dumbed-down marketing pitch has stuck like aging peanut butter to the roofs of our collective mouths.

Here's a fun site to play with the calculations, if you're interested: http://www.bcae1.com/dampfact.htm

BTW, the general consensus is that system factors > 30 are fine, and you have to actually get a fair amount lower than that before it's a real problem.

John
QFT John.
 
I am afraid the poison of car audio will haunt me for quite some time...I have much to learn.
Different objectives, generally speaking. Personally I favor full range loudspeakers that can play flat into the 20s for home audio therefore I've not used a subwoofer to augment that since about 1992. [Not so for my Home Theater and multi-ch audio set-ups where a subwoofer is a necessity.]. Before then, I erroneously looked at 2-ch home audio like a car system in a larger space.

In car, it simply isn't possible to have left and right speakers that can play flat to 20 Hz so we augment that with a well integrated subwoofer system. The trick has always been to have the front mid bass drivers play down to at least 60 Hz and then play with the phase of the subwoofer system so that the integration was seamless.
 
Back
Top Bottom