I would guess, and that's all it is, a guess, that the Toshiba might have a better phono stage simply because in 1976 everybody had a record player and phono was a key input. That was not so much the case in 1991 when the VSX-95 came out, even though it looks to be part of the Elite line.
That being said, give them both extended listens and see which one you enjoy the most; that's your keeper...