• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Aerial Addiction Continues...

CarnahanBB

Super Member
Some of you may remember that my recently acquired Aerial Acoustics 8B loudspeakers finally dethroned my Infinity QLS-1 as my favorite speaker in my home. Well, it appears as if the Aerial 8B's time at the throne will soon be coming to an end. Heavy lies the crown I suppose.

To make a long story short, an exceptionally nice pair of Aerial LR5 standmounts popped up a few short hours away in Kansas City. A short conversation with Michael Kelly (formerly of a/d/s and now president at Aerial Acoustics) confirmed what I had suspected: The LR5 is a substantially improved speaker over the 8B from 40hz on up. I knew I needed to seize the opportunity. The LR5's frequency response is flat to 40hz so I will lose the bottom end of the 8Bs which is fine by be. The 8Bs are flat to just below 30hz so I'm not all that concerned about that last 10hz. My new found experience with quality subwoofers has changed my opinion regarding integration of the last octaves. In any case, there will be substantially more to come I just wanted to get started. I will be picking the LR5s up this Saturday. I can't wait!
 

Attachments

  • 133755-aerial-acoustics-model-lr5-speakers-8062.jpg
    133755-aerial-acoustics-model-lr5-speakers-8062.jpg
    47.4 KB · Views: 157
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Yes, fortunately they come with the matching Sound Anchor stands. I, more than likely, would not have pursued them without the stands. The stands are very pricey and weigh 65 pounds each so buying new and shipping would have added a lot to the cost.
 
Beautiful speakers. I too have come to love the standmount/sub integration. It just takes a quality sub and a little fiddling around with placement.
 
Now if you can only get the LFE below 80hz . . . ....:scratch2:

I run full bandwidth to the side satellites and let the natural LF rolloff of the drivers do their job. But I have different speakers and I don't have a setup where LFE is even an option.
 
Now if you can only get the LFE below 80hz . . . ....:scratch2:

I run full bandwidth to the side satellites and let the natural LF rolloff of the drivers do their job. But I have different speakers and I don't have a setup where LFE is even an option.

Can you elaborate a little bit? I'm not quite tracking!
 
I'm not using an HT receiver or even anything modern. I use old tube amps and British speakers. The type of speakers I use tend to not pretend to do much of anything below 50 or 60hz.
So, in my case, I have a preamp with a pair of output jacks to go to each channel for a total of four preamp outputs, two per channel. I run the preamp to a tube amp and run a separate tap or stereo taps from the preamp to a powered sub. The powered sub's crossover acts as a low-pass filter. Then, I cross into the sub at the speaker manufacturer's recommended frequency, typically 60, 50, or 40hz. The slope of the low pass filter in the sub is a variable, but if it's 18db/octave or greater, there's no, or little, overlap. Then I tune low-pass frequency, amplitude and phase by ear.

When I'm running out of a vintage tube integrated or amp, I run full bandwidth to the side satellite speakers. A lot of these had center channel taps if you wanted to get an amp and run a center channel speaker. These tend to be the sum of the two channels or, depending on the amp, the difference of the two channels. I run that to the sub and use the sub's low pass filter as described above. If they didn't have a center channel, I usually just run separate taps off the speaker connectors to the sub's speaker inputs.

Note that I do not use the crossover in the subs to send signals to the satellites. It could be that a sub of the quality of your JL Fathom has a good enough crossover to do that, but the cheap subs without DSP that I use don't have that capability.

The more time you spend with subs, the more you realize that the greatest mistake is to run the highest frequency the sub can do far too high. LFEs often make the decision for you in HT applications and you have to live with them, but for the applications discussed above, I sometimes cross INTO the sub as low as 50hz. I note directionality (or the sound coming from the sub) starting at about 70hz.

The other thing about a sub is that - when it is right - you shouldn't notice it unless you turn it off and notice its absence.

One more addition: I do have a home theater receiver and use two subs with that. I do use the LFE in that application and the crossover is set to the LFE in the "large" setting, which is 80 or 90 hz I believe. I live just fine with it, but that's mostly for movies. Life is full of trade-offs and this is a minor one.
 
Last edited:
I'm not using an HT receiver or even anything modern. I use old tube amps and British speakers. The type of speakers I use tend to not pretend to do much of anything below 50 or 60hz.
So, in my case, I have a preamp with a pair of output jacks to go to each channel for a total of four preamp outputs, two per channel. I run the preamp to a tube amp and run a separate tap or stereo taps from the preamp to a powered sub. The powered sub's crossover acts as a low-pass filter. Then, I cross into the sub at the speaker manufacturer's recommended frequency, typically 60, 50, or 40hz. The slope of the low pass filter in the sub is a variable, but if it's 18db/octave or greater, there's no, or little, overlap. Then I tune low-pass frequency, amplitude and phase by ear.

When I'm running out of a vintage tube integrated or amp, I run full bandwidth to the side satellite speakers. A lot of these had center channel taps if you wanted to get an amp and run a center channel speaker. These tend to be the sum of the two channels or, depending on the amp, the difference of the two channels. I run that to the sub and use the sub's low pass filter as described above. If they didn't have a center channel, I usually just run separate taps off the speaker connectors to the sub's speaker inputs.

Note that I do not use the crossover in the subs to send signals to the satellites. It could be that a sub of the quality of your JL Fathom has a good enough crossover to do that, but the cheap subs without DSP that I use don't have that capability.

The more time you spend with subs, the more you realize that the greatest mistake is to run the highest frequency the sub can do far too high. LFEs often make the decision for you in HT applications and you have to live with them, but for the applications discussed above, I sometimes cross INTO the sub as low as 50hz. I note directionality (or the sound coming from the sub) starting at about 70hz.

The other thing about a sub is that - when it is right - you shouldn't notice it unless you turn it off and notice its absence.

One more addition: I do have a home theater receiver and use two subs with that. I do use the LFE in that application and the crossover is set to the LFE in the "large" setting, which is 80 or 90 hz I believe. I live just fine with it, but that's mostly for movies. Life is full of trade-offs and this is a minor one.

Now that's what I call 'elaboration'! Very, very much appreciated. I also tend to agree with you what said regarding the localizing of the sub when crossed too high. I started at 80hz which I thought sounded a bit too high but actually seemed to sound really good. I'm at 60hz right now and I'm still tweaking a bit. It's interesting that the THX standard crossover from speakers to subs is 80hz. Although that assumes a one-size-fits-all approach I suppose.
 
The more time you spend with subs, the more you realize that the greatest mistake is to run the highest frequency the sub can do far too high. LFEs often make the decision for you in HT applications and you have to live with them, but for the applications discussed above, I sometimes cross INTO the sub as low as 50hz. I note directionality (or the sound coming from the sub) starting at about 70hz.

The other thing about a sub is that - when it is right - you shouldn't notice it unless you turn it off and notice its absence.


I totally agree with you when it comes to using a sub in a 2-channel setup. You shouldn't notice it until you turn it off. The sub should only be there to give some foundation to the system.
 
He's the one just picked up the JL Audio Fathom. Definitely on my radar once I'm moved. Completely impractical for my space here tho...
 
Very nice speaker, your lucky.

Perhaps you've been asked this, why the Ayrton Senna avatar? I was a huge fan myself.
 
Very nice speaker, your lucky.

Perhaps you've been asked this, why the Ayrton Senna avatar? I was a huge fan myself.

Very much appreciated sir! Regarding the avatar...I'm just a fan of his driving, his passion and his zest for life. That probably sounds corny. One day I was surfing the web and came across a video of him driving F1 in wet (and I mean WET) conditions and I was just blown away. That pretty much kindled by fascination with him.
 
Back
Top Bottom