• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Amplifier Opinion Poll

Two amplifiers with the same wpc output and comparably low distortion will sound alike.

  • Yes, watts are watts.

  • No, not unless they are identical.

  • Need more information.

  • All amplifiers of decent quality sound alike.

  • All amps should sound alike, but don't.


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
That the majority of the population can't distinguish one good amplifier from another?

That borders on self-evident, doesn't it?

Aren't you agreeing with 62caddy, here?

Subtle differences, in the ears of the apathetic, could easily be no perceived difference at all.
I'm saying there's no science behind it, that our apocryphal opinions are as good as it gets. Self-evident indeed, no need for bogus graphs, etc.
 
It is like a Wine Sommlier. An expert one can discern where the wine was made (country, area, and year) as well as varietal of grape. Same with 'golden ears', it is training that takes time to go through.

Found it. Yeah, I agree. I'm not sure anyone can identify specific makes and models of amps just by listening. They would be able to pick their preference consistently, in a blind test. No one has ever done that, because the result would be a subjective preference. Even if they picked it every time. That would be interesting, but the scientific people aren't interested in subjective classification. They strive to prove the null. They shouldn't start with that presumption.
 
Found it. Yeah, I agree. I'm not sure anyone can identify specific makes and models of amps just by listening. They would be able to pick their preference consistently, in a blind test. No one has ever done that, because the result would be a subjective preference. Even if they picked it every time. That would be interesting, but the scientific people aren't interested in subjective classification. They strive to prove the null. They shouldn't start with that presumption.
If the ability to identify specific makes and models of amps just by listening exists, it doesn't matter whether it's reflective of subjective preference or not. To be able to do it at all would be a significant indication of the ability to discriminate amps by sound.
 
...They strive to prove the null. They shouldn't start with that presumption.

Not necessarily. While I know it did not meet scientific/statistical rigor, in my personal blind testing experiments with some DACs the point was to prove the affirmative...but I failed. I was convinced I could hear the difference but the tests suggested I could not.
 
Not necessarily. While I know it did not meet scientific/statistical rigor, in my personal blind testing experiments with some DACs the point was to prove the affirmative...but I failed. I was convinced I could hear the difference but the tests suggested I could not.
Interesting. Which DACs did you test ?

I swear I would pick my $700 DAC over my Schitt Modi every time. I don't have anyone to switch the input, though.
 
They strive to prove the null. They shouldn't start with that presumption.

On the strength of what source(s) do you make this assertion?


IMHO, this is a myth. The conclusions derived/contrive from these attempts can't be generalized in any objective manner. The subjects were not drawn at random, yada, yada. Show me a break down on the methodology of any one these tests, and I'll explain why it's not valid.

An awful lot of these tests had been conducted throughout the last several decades by manufacturers, trade publications, listening clinics and so forth using test subjects from experienced listeners to the indifferent using every reasonable precaution and safeguard under the scientific method in order to obtain the most objective & reliable data attainable.

There can be little motivation from sources within the industry to prove something that can hardly be in its best interests to do so - yet this is what has been found, and with startling consistency. If anything here is a "myth" it is the argument that has not been proven - unless one is content to believe (in your own words) "apocryphal opinions are as good as it gets".

In my book "apocryphal opinions" are not as good as it gets by a longshot nor are they a substitute for evidence that is demonstrable, replicable and provable.
 
Interesting. Which DACs did you test ?

A Benchmark DAC 1 vs. the internal DACs of a Denon DCD 1560, a Denon DV 2900, some "sleeper" Toshiba universal player, and Music Hall something or another. We may also have had an Analog Devices AD1955 DAC eval board in the mix too...but I don't recall for sure. I did a bit of a writeup over at AVS but I believe it was lost in a big server crash some years back.

In the end, both my brother and I expressed a preference for the Music Hall when we knew what was playing, but in the tests we were no better than guessing with any of them. Does that expose the test as flawed, or does it support some sort of predisposition in sighted tests? Some of both, maybe.

By the way, this was all done towards the end of my 30-day trial of the Benchmark. Based on the tests, and subsequent listening thereafter, I returned it for a refund.
 
A Benchmark DAC 1 vs. the internal DACs of a Denon DCD 1560, a Denon DV 2900, some "sleeper" Toshiba universal player, and Music Hall something or another. In the end, both my brother and I expressed a preference for the Music Hall when we knew what was playing, but in the tests we were no better than guessing with any of them. Does that expose the test as flawed, or does it support some sort of predisposition in sighted tests? Some of both, maybe.

people dont realize how much sight plays a role in our audio experiences
 
I don't necessarily dispute that but I have to admit I've owned pieces that I wanted to love, bought with an open mind (because I really wanted them and sold shortly thereafter because they didn't impress. Doesn't flaw the whole theory/ observation but it does cast some doubt about its actual effect:idea:
 
Last edited:
On the strength of what source(s) do you make this assertion.
Okay, I retract the assertion. I should have said; they strive to prove the existence of an objective reality. IMHO, no human can experience objective reality.

I'm all in favor of pure science. I'm suggesting the studies aren't measuring what they try to measure. They're studying more about how the human mind works, rather than the inherent qualities of one amp vs. another. They're seeing something they have no intention of measuring, and disregarding it.

Maybe some people like the musical passage the first time they've heard in X number of years. Maybe they're tired of hearing it after the third time in row, even if the amps progressively get better. Can someone remember what it sounded like, 2 minutes ago, while they're listening to it again? Can you bring one song to mind, while listening to another one ? Probably not. Can the same be said for amps, probably so. There are just too many factors to control for, that nothing objective can be said, IMHO. The 'no difference' stand is not proven by science. Just my O 2.
 
Last edited:
This is so true, in my opinion. Yet in the end, does, does it really matter if one cannot tell the difference between "lossy" and "lossless" as the whole point of our hobby is actually, in many ways, self-gratification (music pleasing to the listener).
It does not matter to me so long as I don't have to listen to lossy! :bigok:

You have the "analogers with their expensive cartridges" versus other folks, finally down to a spectrum (like many of my students) who have MP3s on their phones and hideous sounding "Beats" headphones at best. And yet, members of all three groups, I am absolutely certain, would agree that a given piece of music sounds different on each of the respective systems (being powered by a $20,000 tube amplifier and pre-amp combination, a quality integrated amplifier, or the headphone amplifier of a multipurpose cellphone).

Now let us be honest and open here: Who is to say, with ordained finality, which system more faithfully reproduced the piece of music as we are asking for subjective opinion?
Faithfully reproduced is one thing, but the poll asks do all amps with same specs on paper sound identical, not are they more faithful to the source.

Even if we would time-warp ourselves back to the recording studio and listen to the master tapes directly after they were recorded with the with the artists themselves in the room, each individual (including the performance artist and sound engineer) would hear the recording differently. The assumption that is made, is that the higher end systems more faithfully reproduce the given music. Is that really true due to the subjective nature argument?
Well again, knowing and agreeing with you that everyone hears music differently, will for each one of us, amplifiers with the same specs sound the same? They may sound differently to what you are hearing than it does to me but forget about that. Will all amps sound the same to you? I know they don't to me.

Then again, over the short runs that I use, I might just be imagining a difference when none exists and all is just really down to subjective preference, just as it is with the performance of our various individual systems.
Yes there is that imagination thing, and it at times that has me questioning myself too. But when I am listening critically , to my own system, say after some change I have made to it, or to another system, I prefer to play certain tracks that I am very familiar with, and preferably ones that were done well by the musicians and engineers on down to the media itself.
 
I don't necessarily dispute that bu:idea:t I have to admit I've owned pieces that I wanted to love, bought with an open mind (because I really wanted them and sold shortly thereafter because they didn't impress. Doesn't flaw the whole theory/ observation but it does casthat some doubt about its actual effect

someone here a while ago (may have been @4-2-7) posted a lecture by a longtime HK engineer (i believe) that dove into building a loudspeaker and how they tested them. he said he didnt even want to hear an opinion on a comparison if the person could see the speakers. they found quite a difference when someone could see vs when they couldnt.

i really wish i could find the video. it was over an hour long and i watched the whole thing. it was an excellent lecture and the gentleman received a standing ovation
 
Okay, I retract the assertion. I should have said; they strive to prove the existence of an objective reality. IMHO, no human can experience objective reality.

I'm all in favor of pure science. I'm suggesting the studies aren't measuring what they try to measure. They're studying more about how the human mind works, rather than the inherent qualities of one amp vs. another.

Maybe some people like the musical passage the first they've heard in X number of years. Maybe they're tired of hearing after the third time in row, even if the amps progressively get better. There are just too many factors to control for, that nothing objective can be said, IMHO. The 'no difference' stand is not proven by science. Just my O 2.

Nobody has every ruled out all possibility of any sonically perceptible differences whatsoever (in fact I believe some studies used some equipment that had been purposely modified to be underperform to ensure sure the listeners were on their toes) but that human auditory perception is not nearly as acute as we would like to suppose.
 
someone here a while ago (may have been @4-2-7) posted a lecture by a longtime HK engineer (i believe) that dove into building a loudspeaker and how they tested them. he said he didnt even want to hear an opinion on a comparison if the person could see the speakers. they found quite a difference when someone could see vs when they couldnt.

i really wish i could find the video. it was over an hour long and i watched the whole thing. it was an excellent lecture and the gentleman received a standing ovation

I'm sceptical of an HK engineer regarding loudspeakers. Now, if he were ADS man, we'd be onto something. (joke)
 
Vision has a distracting effect on critical listening, for me anyway. I like the lights dimmed, nothing on a TV, and probably my eyes closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom