I think the Sansui G-22000/33000 is as good a design with not a lot of compromises, apart from them having to split it in two because it is too heavy as one unit for a human to possibly even think about lifting......
The power-amp, has two completely independent supplies with their own toroidal transformers, the 33K packs a whopping rail voltage and has as enough output devices to deliver fairly high current.....and an extensive supply design, and some great protection......
Sound quality wise, I have no doubt the Sansui would please the vast majority of owners/listeners, but as I stated in post 57, high current is where even the mightiest receivers stumble.
The Sansui G22000 for example is rated at 330 wpc into 8 ohms and also 330wpc into 4 ohms. It could be an exception, but this normally means it is not going to handle the high loads some speakers are going to throw at it .
So if I happen to be using say a Apogee speaker that goes down to 1 ohm plus has some really nasty phase angles around 120hz (around -47 at 3.3 ohms off the top of my head) - you had better hope the protection circuit is working well in the Sansui or you have a really good chance of frying the output resistors on it.
Here is why I personally like separates - a Sansui G22000 in good condition, not restored is going to set me back $2k plus if I am not mistaken - yet I am limited in my speaker selection. Yes I still have hundreds of speakers I can use, but it seems most of the speakers I am drawn to are very inefficient and either like or demand high current. So unless i wish to risk frying my $2k plus receiver, I would either have to forget about using those type of speakers or get another amp to drive them.
On the other hand, for less then $1k, one for even less then $400(GFA-555), I can get an amp that is high current and I now do not have to limit my speaker selection in any way.
Move up to the same price as the G22000 and I could get a really nice amp and pre that will sound excellent plus drive just about anything I can throw at it (some speakers pretty much require you biamp them no matter what you bring to the table).
If I walked into someone's home and they had a totl receiver hooked up to some nice speakers, I have no doubt I would enjoy the sound and think it was a nice system - but for me and the speakers I am drawn to, while a nice system and better then the vast majority, I would also be thinking it was just not my thing as i couldn't see spending the money and still not being able to have the speakers I want.
Plus while you can do it, I also ended up going thru quite a few preamps finding that perfect synergy that satisfied me. While a case can be made for a preamp in a receiver being matched well to the amp, I had a Pioneer Spec 1 which you would think is perfect for the Spec 2 amp, but it just never satisfied me and gave me what i was looking for.
Receivers can be and are some excellent pieces of gear.
Is just my opinion that separates done right do it better and gives me more options and I could never get by the high current end of the deal.
But, that is just my opinion and what is right for me, and as we all should know by now, what is right for me may not be right for you.
IN a way it is kind of silly to "debate" if it is considered audiophile grade gear as i would guess the vast majority of people using them are extremely satisfied with them and many probably have no desire to go with separates or even think about owning a pair of say Apogee speakers.
I have my own definition of audiophile, different from many, and the vast majority of us don;t have that type of gear whether it is a receiver or separates - so all we can do is put together something we enjoy and is within our financial means and forget what Billy Bob down the street or across the internet thinks of my system.
Not necessarily this one, but it does seem I see posts where basically they are pretty much just fishing for others to tell them how great their system is and how it is probably better then others. I would guess I have done that myself in the past.
Our egos can often be the very thing which keeps us from being perfectly happy with what we do have. It's hard to try and leave it behind, but if we are capable of checking the ego at the door - it turns out we can be a whole lot happier with what we do have - whether it is a receiver, separates of even a Bose lifestyle system.
Point being - all we are doing is trying to enjoy the music no matter which path we take to get there. Said too often and often misunderstood - but it really is only our ears that matter.