• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Cleaning the Capstan Rubber Rollers

I've always had good results from plain old IPA for cleaning and I use MG Chemicals Rubber Renew periodically on the pinch roller (every 12 months or so).
No slippage, no problems.
 
I haven't seen good platen cleaner in at least a decade. I think it had trichloroethylene in it and was outlawed. Over time I think it would still harden the rubber on the platen and feed rollers, but we also made money selling parts so it was of little consequence to us.
Denatured Alcohol work pretty good to, But a couple of cans of RRR will last a (my) lifetime.

I believe you are correct in saying platen cleaner had trichlorethylene and was removed from the market.
I was an IBM office machine repair tech back in the day. The company called is "Customer Engineers". My territory was half the Empire State Building....can you imagine?
Platen cleaner was one of the supplies I carried ALL THE TIME.
IBM selectric II was the best typewriter ever made :)

Sure could use some of that stuff now. I have a pinch roller that can use a little help
 
AF Platenclene is excellent for cleaning and rejuvenating pinch rollers. It seems to contain naphtha or a similar type of material but it doesn't evaporate too quickly in use. It was a Xerox engineer who introduced this stuff to me 25 odd years ago, saying he used it on his TEAC X1000, although it wasn’t made by AF at the time, it was a white can product.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nag
The Rubber cleaner was suppose to be blue and the pink was the head cleaner. The Rubber cleaner was made by a company called Rawn in Spooner, Wisconsin. The blue color is photoreactive and if left in the sun will turn a dark green. Color does not affect it's function.

I stand corrected. Cheers!
 
Which of these can those of us who have a Low end deck use? Or maybe a Mid end deck? Maybe we don't perform maintenance.
 
At this late date, just use Naphtha to recondition rubber. If the surface is shiny and this can be corrected with a spacer and a screw in a electric drill and some 200 grit sandpaper- the sandpaper is used to take off the dead layer much as the Naphtha would with hours of cleaning. I then treat or clean the sandpapered roller with Naphtha that smooths out the scratches. There are cases when a roller is either too small or too hard to deal with then they go to Terry and get today's rubber put on. This is probably the best course of action unless you want to limp along until you have to send it to Terry. As a Professional I can not put out a sloppy product so if the roller does not satisfy my quality tests then I exchange it for a re-rubbered Terry roller I have in stock. I have used Naphtha for several years now as I learned from the MSDS sheets that it was the most product in the RC-1 cleaner. Using water on rubber works about as well as water does on a melted belt- friction is the only thing you are working with.
 
I have used cig lighter fluid ( Naphtha) directly from the can and a Q tip for many yrs on all of my decks. I like the results
 
tonight I did the usual Green Scotch-brite w/DAWN dish detergent and running HOT water. Finished up w/ 1/10 of a drop of MOBILE 1 5W-30
on two from X2000 and 1 on the A-4300SX. All good now!
 
AF Platenclene is made of C11-C15 Alkanes and may be like 3,5,7 Trimethyldecane.
The more complex a molecular chain is the more concern for safety I would say although it is not suppose to be toxic, they say to use in well ventilated area.
 
At this late date, just use Naphtha to recondition rubber. If the surface is shiny and this can be corrected with a spacer and a screw in a electric drill and some 200 grit sandpaper- the sandpaper is used to take off the dead layer much as the Naphtha would with hours of cleaning. I then treat or clean the sandpapered roller with Naphtha that smooths out the scratches. There are cases when a roller is either too small or too hard to deal with then they go to Terry and get today's rubber put on. This is probably the best course of action unless you want to limp along until you have to send it to Terry. As a Professional I can not put out a sloppy product so if the roller does not satisfy my quality tests then I exchange it for a re-rubbered Terry roller I have in stock. I have used Naphtha for several years now as I learned from the MSDS sheets that it was the most product in the RC-1 cleaner. Using water on rubber works about as well as water does on a melted belt- friction is the only thing you are working with.

9E0F4A2F-C5A9-45B0-9F0D-60931D40627D.jpeg 674EB2F5-C946-4737-8C25-521BCE621F17.jpeg 4C57212A-BBB9-40A7-8746-AEFDD6BF69EA.jpeg 0326BA96-3746-43A9-96D8-183243FDA9B6.jpeg

a good 3-5min soak in 408A Rubber Renue works well on rubbers that have hardened. After that they get scrubbed with Q-tips and more 408A. Scrub until you get a clean swab. Takes a few but once the rubber is actually clean it will be like new. Let air dry to let the 408A evaporate off.
 
I'm gonna be doing a cleaning tonight. I'm not very used to doing it yet. I use 91% Iso Alcohol. Is it ok to use on the rollers? I'll be using a foam swab. I know that something like rubber renew would probably be best, but....Also, is it best to go over all with a dry swab after? Thanks
 
Last edited:
Hi, sorry for the late reply. Yes, IPA is perfectly ok to use on pinch rollers. It is a widespread misconception that alcohol is harmful to rubber, but in reality it is safe as shown in the chemical compatibility charts (see the links given earlier in this thread). The only exception is those green rollers which are made of polyurethane, a material that gets damaged by practically any cleaning substance, except maybe soapy water. If your pinch roller is green, pay attention and leave it alone as much as you can.

I assume that your goal is to clean the pinch roller, ie. remove the grit that has deposited on it. "Rubber Renue", "Platenclene", naphta and other substances that have been advertised here serve a very different purpose, which is to rejuvenate rubber that has gone hard or shiny and has lost its grip. They act by stripping the outer layers to expose the fresh rubber underneath, which means that they are harmful to rubber (as said in the compatibility charts) and are not for frequent cleaning, at the risk of damaging your pinch roller. Rubber Renue, in particular, is described by its manufacturer as a curative solution to restore tackiness, and contains substances that are harmful to your health. I don't really see its use as a preventative solution or in everyday maintenance, let alone at home. Alcohol is perfect for this - soapy water works well too, it just requires a little more elbow grease.

Alcohol, including IPA, dries quickly, so you don't need to wipe the roller with a dry swab.
 
Last edited:
Nakamichi Dragon Pinch Rollers.JPG
1. Check the accompanying photo of the Pinch Rollers on my Dragon which show very little to deterioration.

2. I realise others will differ with this approach but I clean the Heads and Pinch Rollers on my Dragon with CRC Contact Cleaner saturated on a small piece of chamois.

These Pinch rollers on my Dragon are still in good order coming up to 40 years. and that does say something for the quality Nakamichi adhered to.
 
Rubber can not be "reconditioned", it is a myth. All studios around the world cleaned rollers with IPA. For general cleaning, when you get machine with very dirty roller - acetone.
If rubber is gone, it is gone. So Terry's "soap and water" will not help :)
 
Rubber can not be "reconditioned", it is a myth. All studios around the world cleaned rollers with IPA. For general cleaning, when you get machine with very dirty roller - acetone.
If rubber is gone, it is gone. So Terry's "soap and water" will not help :)
"Reconditioned" is probably a misnomer. The purpose is not to bring dead rubber back to life, but to remove it in order to expose the rubber underneath, which still has its resilience.

Of course this does not work forever, as rubber can degrade in ways that cause loss of resilience in the depth of the pinch roller. You are correct, when this happens it's gone and then all you can do is change the roller. But rejuvenating does work for a while, I do it myself.

"Soap and water" does actually help, of course not for rejuvenating but as a mild cleaner for day to day cleaning. Not as effective as IPA, but less harmful to polyurethane rollers. OTOH I would definitely avoid acetone for general cleaning if there is plastic in the transport - and that includes the heads which are partly made of plastic. Nagra, for instance, specifically advises against it. It is also a no-no on polyurethane rollers.
 
Last edited:
"Reconditioned" is probably a misnomer. The purpose is not to bring dead rubber back to life, but to remove it in order to expose the rubber underneath, which still has its resilience.

Of course this does not work forever, as rubber can degrade in ways that cause loss of resilience in the depth of the pinch roller. You are correct, when this happens it's gone and then all you can do is change the roller. But rejuvenating does work for a while, I do it myself.

"Soap and water" does actually help, of course not for rejuvenating but as a mild cleaner for day to day cleaning. Not as effective as IPA, but less harmful to polyurethane rollers. OTOH I would definitely avoid acetone for general cleaning if there is plastic in the transport - and that includes the heads which are partly made of plastic. Nagra, for instance, specifically advises against it. It is also a no-no on polyurethane rollers.

If with polyurethane rollers you mean those made by Athan, they are crap from the beginning. I have very bad experience with them on my A80s. There is nothing wrong to clean green original Studer rollers with IPA (well, there is no one left alive I believe, few years ago I replaced last series green roller what started to became a bit soft). I believe rejuvenating is just illusion. They need to be replaced or rerubbered on original core (what I prefer). The best service I know is Gianni at https://www.sofh.it/. If you are in US, you may prefer Terry Witt, but Gianni quality is outstanding, at least for R2R decks. I have no experience with Gianni rollers for cassette decks. And - acetone is safe for all heads. Never heard about Nagra advise not to use it. Of course not as everyday cleaner. Yes, with plastic parts you should be careful. Soap and water is near impossible to use in cassette decks. Because you should clean remains with something, so IPA again :)
 
For rubber rollers:

First - soapy water until no black appears on the long-stemmed cotton buds
Second - IPA
Never - acetone (its cleaning benefits are outweighed by its aggressiveness to most rubbers & surrounding plastics)

Once the crosslinking has started to deteriorate, whether it's a rubber or a polyurethane, then there's no going back.
 
If with polyurethane rollers you mean those made by Athan, they are crap from the beginning.
I've never seen an Athan roller, I mean those made by Revox/Studer (which are still sold today btw) and the one that Gianni sold me last year. He makes both green PU and black EPDM rubber, told me that PU had upsides but did not last as long as the black rubber ones. But he only had PU in stock at that time, so that's what I bought. I agree with you, Gianni is a great person to deal with.

There is nothing wrong to clean green original Studer rollers with IPA (well, there is no one left alive I believe, few years ago I replaced last series green roller what started to became a bit soft).
They all end up this way, Usually it's the metal/rubber interface that starts turning into goo and then it propagates outwards. Nothing to do with cleaning, I've even seen it in a NOS roller that had never been mounted in a deck. As for IPA, it is rated "bad for PU" in all the the rubber compatibility charts - see for instance https://mykin.com/rubber-chemical-resistance-chart-3, so I cannot advise it.

I believe rejuvenating is just illusion. They need to be replaced or rerubbered on original core (what I prefer).
I have just "rejuvenated" 3 decks I have here, including a Studer A710 which had very clean rollers but a very high W&F, and achieved dramatic W&F decreases - like 0.18% down to 0.06% DIN on the A710. I don't think it is possible to delude a reference cassette and a W&F meter, so I don't agree that it is an illusion. We do agree that at some point the roller will need replacement, as I said in my previous post, but you can substantially increase its lifetime by proper maintenance (including "rejuvenation", which is is a misleading term I agree).

And - acetone is safe for all heads. Never heard about Nagra advise not to use it. Of course not as everyday cleaner.
The Nagra user manuals have evolved through time. They all advise water and alcohol for cleaning heads (some versions say that saliva works too) and the later versions advise against strong solvents, especially chlorinated solvents like trichlorethylene (obviously), which "can cause the epoxy resins used in the manufacturing of the heads to expand" (see for instance the Nagra E manual on Nagra's website). A 1982 manual that I have at home quotes acetone as well. Indeed, acetone is rated "not recommended" in the epoxy compatibility charts (easy to find on the 'net). So no, it is not safe for all heads. If you still don't believe me, you can find the same advice from Tandberg in the TD20A user manual there: https://www.manualslib.com/manual/1014056/Tandberg-Td-20-A.html?page=21#manual. This said, I'm sure that not all heads are epoxy potted, that there are many epoxy formulations with different incompatibilities, and that damage may not come suddenly. Still, why not just use what the manufacturers recommend as being both safe and effective in all cases? I may be wrong, but I believe that they are not bozos.
 
Last edited:
jlb2
I believe after some decades in studio I have learned something, including how to study technical bulletins.
Yes, I am familiar with Nagra 4.2L (have 2) Nagra 6 (digital, so another story), 8x Studer etc.
Studios around the world used only IPA or ethyl alcohol to clean rollers. When they are gone, they was replaced (now - re-rubbered). For normal polyurethane IPA is OK.
Di- and Tri-chloroethane is another story. This we use to glue some types of plastic. Acetone is safe for all heads/plastics used in heads. BUT - as I wrote, not for everyday use.
If you regulary clean your machine, you never need acetone (what is basic ingredient in 90% so called "rubber rejuvenators") :)
P.S. If you have that Nagra bulletin, maybe you can post it here?
 
Back
Top Bottom