• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Cleaning the Capstan Rubber Rollers

jlb2
I believe after some decades in studio I have learned something, including how to study technical bulletins.
Yes, I am familiar with Nagra 4.2L (have 2) Nagra 6 (digital, so another story), 8x Studer etc.
Studios around the world used only IPA or ethyl alcohol to clean rollers. When they are gone, they was replaced (now - re-rubbered). For normal polyurethane IPA is OK.
Di- and Tri-chloroethane is another story. This we use to glue some types of plastic. Acetone is safe for all heads/plastics used in heads. BUT - as I wrote, not for everyday use.
If you regulary clean your machine, you never need acetone (what is basic ingredient in 90% so called "rubber rejuvenators") :)
P.S. If you have that Nagra bulletin, maybe you can post it here?
It's not a bulletin, it's a user manual. I'll try to upload a scan of the page when I have a chance, but I think you misunderstood me: I did not mention it to discuss the merits of the Nagras, nor to start a "my recorder is better than yours" discussion, but to answer your claim that acetone is safe for all heads. More specifically, I also provided a readily accessible link to the page of the original TD20 user manual that says exactly the opposite - the other Tandberg manuals have the same warning too. Just one exception would be enough to disprove the "all" in your sentence, and Tandberg as a whole is more than just one exception. Given that acetone is also harmful to other plastics that may be present in a recorder (cf. the chemical compatibility charts I linked to above) and is not necessary for cleaning, my point is to say this: it's best not to use acetone at all if you don't know exactly what you are doing. This said, of course you do what you want.

As for acetone being the basic ingredient in 90% of the rejuvenators, you managed to make me doubt for a second, so I rechecked the formulas I have here. I didn't find acetone in any of them. For example Rubber Renue is about 3/4 IPA - 1/4 methyl salicylate, and Platenclene contains iso-alkanes and 3-butoxypropan-2-ol but no acetone. What acetone-based rejuvenator do you have in mind?

"Studios around the world used only IPA or ethyl alcohol to clean rollers. When they are gone, they was replaced (now - re-rubbered).". I'm sure it was true when new machines were still made and new pinch rollers were widely available. Around 2000 I used to buy Platenclene from a company that also supplied it to studios. I guess you just don't know all the studios in the world (nor do I).

"For normal polyurethane IPA is OK." Not according to the PU manufacturers, cf. the rubber compatibility chart in my previous post. But it might possibly act as a rejuvenator by removing the outer layer, I don't know.
 
Last edited:
For each his own. Do not do if you are not sure what you are doing. So, if you worry acetone is not safe for heads, do not use it. And if you are not able to clean heads without touching vulnerable plastics - do not do it again, or bring your machine to someone who can. I do not want to continue polemize about IPA or acetone is safe/not safe. Only, if with polyurethane rollers you mean Athan rollers, there is nothing what is safe for them. They are self destructive. But if we talking about "rubber rejuvenators", it is something religious - if you believe in them and they work for you you can use them (I believe in FSM for example). But do not ask chemists from rubber industry, they will brake your religion :)

P.S. And, if you make feedback on manufacturers recommendations, it would be nice to provide exact information where we can read it (not Athan of course).

P.P.S. And if you quote manufacturer (Nagra for example) do it exactly, please. For example (4.2. latest manual) " Chlorinated solvents, such as trichlorethylene, should be used with care, as it is possible they may lightly attack the resins used in the construction of the heads." So there is big difference between "against solvents" and "use with care".
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I hadn't understood that radiokom was one of those guys who just disregard whatever information doesn't go along with them and call sectarians those who don't share their opinions. Needless to say, this is definitely not my idea of what a forum is supposed to be, and I will not reply to him any more. While I was still trying to provide him with manufacturer information, however, I had found more data in my documentation drawer, that I thought might be of be interest to others, so I'll summarize it one last time before we move on.

In Tandberg's TD20A owner's manuals, the section on cleaning (page 21 of the link I gave in a previous post) has a box saying:

"NOTE! Do not use solvents, such as acetone or trichlorethylene, as they may damage the heads. Do not use any sharp objects."​

I found that this is not specific to the TD20A, the same warning is in the manuals of the 10-X, 1200, 3000-X and others. Interestingly, later Tandberg manuals like the TCD3014 and TCD3034 go a step further:

"IMPORTANT! Do not use acetone, carbon tetrachloride, trichlorethylene or similar strong solvents. They will damage the heads. Do not use sharp or hard objects."​

Note the switch from "may" to "will". I don't know if it's because the heads of the TCD30x4 use different potting from the TD20A, or if it's because feedback showed that the problem was worse than initially expected, but Tandberg clearly do not want you to touch their tape paths with acetone. Otari have similar warnings, and use exactly the same terms in the manuals of the MX-5050 and of the MTR series at least (I did not check the other models). For instance, in the MTR-15 operation & maintenance manual (2nd edition), section 6.2.2:

"CAUTION: [...] Never use spirits, lacquer thinner, acetone or other solvents on the tape heads. [...]"​

I note the use of "never", which specifically precludes occasional or accidental use. So does this mean that acetone is bad to any recorder regardless of its manufacturer? Not necessarily, as compatibility is material-dependent. At least in the case of Tandberg and Otari, we know with certainty that acetone is not OK, but in other manufacturers I haven't been able to find a single owner or service manual saying that it is OK. Knowing that acetone is not recommended by any manufacturer, and is even precluded by several of them, It is probably best to keep clear from it. That being said, the matter is definitively closed as far as I am concerned.
 
Last edited:
Well, looks like someone managed to ruin the Otari head if Otari added it (and other solvents) to MTR-15 manual 5th edition. :)
Nothing is absolutely foolproof. I have read manual how to disassemble a baby stroller. It started with "Remove baby from stroller ..."
Still can not imagine who was reason for that instruction.
But anyway - there is still noted to clean pinch roller with alcohol :)

P.S. My MTR-15 head block does not need solvents anyway :)

Otari_MTR15_2track_headblock.jpg
 
Last edited:
The best head cleaner I ever used Ampex made, Xylene with Trichloroethylene . But you couldn't use with heads or guides with plastic parts. I used methanol to clean the rubber parts, but that would eventually dry out natural rubber over a long period. Fortunately high output back coated tapes developed in the Middle 60's stopped most of the issues we had with conventional Acetate and Mylar tapes. The lubricated cart tapes for cart machines for ads, announcements, and top 10 recordings caused the most grief because of the lubricants. There I used methanol and the Ampex cleaner. . I just used methanol on the Nakamichi's and the Revox Reel to reel, too. I always used what ever the Video machines service manuals recommended. Same for the DAT machines. The problem with the Ampex cleaner is the off gassing that can be a health issue both in manufacturing and use.

If some spray paints your car the Ampex head cleaner will take it off instantly if you don't let spray paint set up for a day or two. I know the ratio was 10:1 but I don't remember which combination. Which ever one has the sweeter smell is the predominate one.
 
Hello, good morning everyone,

A message for those who use Athan pressure rollers. I was very annoyed by this news. I admit that.
Error for me: Tape sticks to the pressure roller during playback. In addition, it makes noises when playing. Triple game tapes no longer work at all. Double play tape creates noise on the pressure roller and capstan shaft during play.
Cleaned with warm water, a little dish soap and a household sponge, soft side.
Problems on the Akai GX 747 and Pioneer RT 707.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20240612_082724_WhatsApp-web.jpg
    Screenshot_20240612_082724_WhatsApp-web.jpg
    54.2 KB · Views: 24
Hello, good morning everyone,

A message for those who use Athan pressure rollers. I was very annoyed by this news. I admit that.
Error for me: Tape sticks to the pressure roller during playback. In addition, it makes noises when playing. Triple game tapes no longer work at all. Double play tape creates noise on the pressure roller and capstan shaft during play.
Cleaned with warm water, a little dish soap and a household sponge, soft side.
Problems on the Akai GX 747 and Pioneer RT 707.
Athan rollers are crap. And always was. They are sticky when new. I have experience with those cheaters. And that Greek lie in answer in your picture. New tapes, made by RTM, for example, are the same quality as original BASF and DO NOT shed. If you want good roller, buy from sofh.it, not from those morons.
 
This is more out of an antiquarian interest than a solution in this dated thread. I'm sure the product is no longer sold. I bought two 'cases' of this stuff many years ago. I predicted that it would be all gone as the cassette era was dying out. I've misplaced one case; I opened this one just last week. Even if I can't find the other, I'm thinking this supply alone will service my two machines for as long I have left on the planet, or when the machines finally die — whichever comes first.

This stuff came from Audio-Technica (product # AT6037) and listed at ¥800. Bottle-1 is marked "Head Cleaning Fluid"; bottle-2 is marked as Pinch Roller Cleaning Fluid. Each bottle contains 100 cc. The roller fluid seems soapy. Both seem to work well, and I've used this stuff only for many years.

Cleaning Fluids cassettte.jpg
 
AF PlatenClene works very well on pinch rollers. It does remove the shiny surface and magnetic residue too. It’s also pretty cheap, so win-win!
 
The best head cleaner I ever used Ampex made, Xylene with Trichloroethylene . But you couldn't use with heads or guides with plastic parts. I used methanol to clean the rubber parts, but that would eventually dry out natural rubber over a long period. Fortunately high output back coated tapes developed in the Middle 60's stopped most of the issues we had with conventional Acetate and Mylar tapes. The lubricated cart tapes for cart machines for ads, announcements, and top 10 recordings caused the most grief because of the lubricants. There I used methanol and the Ampex cleaner. . I just used methanol on the Nakamichi's and the Revox Reel to reel, too. I always used what ever the Video machines service manuals recommended. Same for the DAT machines. The problem with the Ampex cleaner is the off gassing that can be a health issue both in manufacturing and use.

If some spray paints your car the Ampex head cleaner will take it off instantly if you don't let spray paint set up for a day or two. I know the ratio was 10:1 but I don't remember which combination. Which ever one has the sweeter smell is the predominate one.
TrichloroETHANE. Which works GREAT. I'm looking for some right NOW and can't find it any anywhere. Apparently, it was replaced in the marketplace with Trichloroethylene. I haven't tried that, but my initial suspicion is that it will work poorly in comparison to the original. But I don't know that. I have about two-thirds of a bottle of Realistic Non-Slip Fluid that brought a slipping idler in my Elite CT-93 to like new when nothing else would. 190 proof (95%) Wood Grain Alcohol worked for about 15 seconds, but no longer. Acetone worked for about the same length of time. This stuff (Isopropyl, Trichloroethane 71-55-6, and Diethylene Dioxide 123-91-1) worked and left everything else I've tried (including the new orange-ey smelling Rawn Rubber Renew) in the dust. Now I have to put this stuff in my LW&T, followed by keeping it in a safety deposit box. (Eyeroll...) I have a bottle of Hexane that I might try on a machine that's sacrificable. Annoying.
 
Last edited:
Well. I just brought out from several years storage my Pioneer CT-W770R Cassette recorder. Pinch rollers need cleaning, so I came here to see what the word is now on cleaning them. I had to look to see if had gotten on the "How to clean Vinyl" by mistake!! LOL So we STILL have not come to an agreement on this!
Several manufacturers of recording equipment I have used recommended Isopropyl Alcohol. I have 91%. So I am staying with that. The rollers still FEEL like rubber, so I think it will be ok.
The whole transport area on both bays look like dirt roads so I don't know how I am going to clean those. Wish I could turn the water hose on them!!
 
Well, looks like someone managed to ruin the Otari head if Otari added it (and other solvents) to MTR-15 manual 5th edition. :)
Nothing is absolutely foolproof. I have read manual how to disassemble a baby stroller. It started with "Remove baby from stroller ..."
Still can not imagine who was reason for that instruction.
But anyway - there is still noted to clean pinch roller with alcohol :)

P.S. My MTR-15 head block does not need solvents anyway :)

View attachment 2384839
LOL!! Before disassembly "remove baby from stroller"! That is a classic.
 
I think Denatured alcohol should be fine for cleaning tape heads and capstans, or a product like Intraclean S-721H though it not the most affordable product to keep buying if you have a collection of tape decks/machines to maintain on a regular basis. I dont know what the ingredients are in 721H, seems to be similar to denatured alcohol, but the company says it can be used on rubber as well.

If the capstan needs more thorough cleaning, I imagine Naptha would be fine, just as it is to clean the metal bridge of an electric guitar.

If the rubber pinch roller is basically in good condition and its being cleaned often, I would think just a little bit of distilled water applied to it with a q tip and some not too hard rubbing, and then drying off should be fine. Distilled would have no minerals in it, and just using that removes any concern on whatever ingredients might be in dish soap that might not be ideal on rubber.

Lets put it this way, if we can hose down a set of tires on our vehicles (car, suv, etc) when cleaning them, then water should be ok on rubber. Just use distilled water to dab onto the pinch roller. Its easier to clean on an open reel machine, whereas its harder to do that in the more confined space of a cassette deck, I am still trying to improve my technique on putting the Q tip to the roller and spin it around so I can clean the entire 360 degree area of the roller.
 
Back
Top Bottom