It's not a bulletin, it's a user manual. I'll try to upload a scan of the page when I have a chance, but I think you misunderstood me: I did not mention it to discuss the merits of the Nagras, nor to start a "my recorder is better than yours" discussion, but to answer your claim that acetone is safe for all heads. More specifically, I also provided a readily accessible link to the page of the original TD20 user manual that says exactly the opposite - the other Tandberg manuals have the same warning too. Just one exception would be enough to disprove the "all" in your sentence, and Tandberg as a whole is more than just one exception. Given that acetone is also harmful to other plastics that may be present in a recorder (cf. the chemical compatibility charts I linked to above) and is not necessary for cleaning, my point is to say this: it's best not to use acetone at all if you don't know exactly what you are doing. This said, of course you do what you want.jlb2
I believe after some decades in studio I have learned something, including how to study technical bulletins.
Yes, I am familiar with Nagra 4.2L (have 2) Nagra 6 (digital, so another story), 8x Studer etc.
Studios around the world used only IPA or ethyl alcohol to clean rollers. When they are gone, they was replaced (now - re-rubbered). For normal polyurethane IPA is OK.
Di- and Tri-chloroethane is another story. This we use to glue some types of plastic. Acetone is safe for all heads/plastics used in heads. BUT - as I wrote, not for everyday use.
If you regulary clean your machine, you never need acetone (what is basic ingredient in 90% so called "rubber rejuvenators")
P.S. If you have that Nagra bulletin, maybe you can post it here?
As for acetone being the basic ingredient in 90% of the rejuvenators, you managed to make me doubt for a second, so I rechecked the formulas I have here. I didn't find acetone in any of them. For example Rubber Renue is about 3/4 IPA - 1/4 methyl salicylate, and Platenclene contains iso-alkanes and 3-butoxypropan-2-ol but no acetone. What acetone-based rejuvenator do you have in mind?
"Studios around the world used only IPA or ethyl alcohol to clean rollers. When they are gone, they was replaced (now - re-rubbered).". I'm sure it was true when new machines were still made and new pinch rollers were widely available. Around 2000 I used to buy Platenclene from a company that also supplied it to studios. I guess you just don't know all the studios in the world (nor do I).
"For normal polyurethane IPA is OK." Not according to the PU manufacturers, cf. the rubber compatibility chart in my previous post. But it might possibly act as a rejuvenator by removing the outer layer, I don't know.
Last edited:
