You have a stage in there with a gain of 1 - the cathode follower. It made sense to have a low impedance source to drive the power amp at at the end of a long cable - but not really needed when its in the same chassis. Connect the existing gain stage to the phase inverter, take the cathode follower stage and change it to a gain stage at the input.
Right now, the feedback gives an overall gain of about 10. Assuming an 8 Ohm speaker, that's 1.2V in for 12V out (18W). Adding half a 6SN7 will make that less than 0.1V - you WILL need an input pot.
Right now, the feedback gives an overall gain of about 10. Assuming an 8 Ohm speaker, that's 1.2V in for 12V out (18W). Adding half a 6SN7 will make that less than 0.1V - you WILL need an input pot.