Huh ...
Man there are a lot of AT bashers here

You love their cartridges, mic's and headphones, and hate their TT's :scratch2: Seems to be a bit of the anti-AK here - all attitude and no audio :thumbsdn: I detect a LOT of attitude.
I've been driving an AT PL120 (pre-USB) for about 4 years now. About a 200 headshell changes (cartridge swapper) and arm adjustments and never a whimper. Dead on speed and decent to good sounds.
If the OP has a bad one (and I think we can all agree that he does?) - he needs to make the seller take it back and send him another or refund his money. As long as it's all at their expense, what's the deal? My guess is that number two will be OK - let's see :scratch2:
I'll put my 120 up against all sorts of "vintage" decks that can have all sorts of issues. Is it the best table ever built

of course not. Is it a good workhorse and 78 spinner - mine is. Maybe the OP will get a decent one also? Let's wait and see.
There's a lot of steam right now, time to cool off?