:First off, let me thank all of you guys for all of the fabulous advice! :thmbsp: I recently picked up a Denon DP-55K turntable that was in some slightly rougher cosmetic condition here and there, but I kept reading great reviews about what a solid table it was. I had seen this thread, and figured I would try out your suggestions (after first practicing a bit on the corner of an old Pioneer lid out in the garage...). With a little elbow grease, this came out looking sharp! I used some fine steel wool to get out the big scratches, some 1500 grit paper, followed by some 2500 grit paper followed by some Meguiar's M105 polish, and then finished it up with some Meguiar's M205. I can still see some VERY light scratches here and there, but only at an angle under a bright light. I could probably get those out, but after all that work I am thinking that it is good enough. Besides, if I spent all of the time making it perfect, I would seriously kick myself for even the slightest little swirl or faint scratch that I am sure to give it somewhere down the line. I would like to finish it out with one final buffing using the combination of Pledge and Windex that was recommended as well in this thread.
As for the plinth, I used Howard's Restore-A-Finish, then Howard's Polishing and Burnishing products on the finish, and then gave it some Wax and Feed. Man, that stuff works awesome as well (yes, I do know this is the the dust cover repair thread, but I thought I would mention it anyways...). There were some heat rings near the headshell where someone had left hot drink cups (??) and they came right out. I think the only way to get it better would be to do a complete refinish on it.
The only bummer? I forgot to take photos of the "before" state. The place I got the table couldn't move it, despite the low price, apparently because of the cosmetics. I am friends with one of the guys who works there, so I can't wait for him to come over and check out the finished product.
As for the sonics of this thing, it has a Magnepan Unitrac tonearm, and I just scored a killer deal on a slightly used Sumiko Blackbird (less than 30 hours). I can't wait to get this sucker up and running--hopefully it will sound as good as it looks! :yes: