• The move to the new server is done. There are some software and database maintenance updates in process. This has us passing the hat around to help out. We appreciate any donations. Seriously, even a dollar helps. The payment page may be found here - https://www.audiokarma.org/support.html

Getting Discouraged and Could Use Some Advice

rothwellaudio said:
Yes, I thought all Planar 2s had glass platters. How does a glass platter warp? I think there's something very wrong with the OP's analysis of the problem.
Click to expand...
Platter wobble is probably a better way to put it. It's similar to what is shown in this video:

OBMG74 said:
Sub-platter warp, as suggested by others?
Click to expand...
This could be likely, but I couldn't perceive any wobble in the sub-platter while it was spinning. Might be too small to notice, though, until the variance transfers to the larger glass platter.
 
The Rega is a keeper but you might consider contacting the retailer and/or Sound Organization (the US distributor for Rega) and have the turntable replaced. The odds of a replacement exhibiting wobble are astronomically low. The Rega will sound great and serve you for many years to come.
 
Four new tables with defects, did someone put a curse on you? Looking at the list at least two of the mfgs have had a long history of issues that buyers have complained about that appear to be from design and poor quality control. Much like the cars built in Japan the Technics will have a higher score for build quality than the four you tried. Instead of putting money into advertising Technics appears to spend it on quality control.
 
Stop looking at cheap tables, start looking at vintage tables. Mid tier Japanese tables from the mid 70's to early 80's offer a lot more value and cost about the same or just a bit more. Look for direct drive with a removable headshell, should work with most cartridges made today. Have a question about one, lots of folks on here to help you.

BillWojo
 
Wobblefoot said:
Platter wobble is probably a better way to put it. It's similar to what is shown in this video:


This could be likely, but I couldn't perceive any wobble in the sub-platter while it was spinning. Might be too small to notice, though, until the variance transfers to the larger glass platter.
Click to expand...
That's terrible.
What's hitting and making that noise every revolution?
Is the spindle bent or not seated properly?
 
Yes, definitely go to a store- even if it takes some travel time. Quality experiences usually require a little effort. You can have them set it up for you before you take it home and they can address any issues you see. And if you're just getting into this thing, maybe you'll meet some cool folks who can offer advice on something later.
:music:

May Jeff Bezos's yacht hit an iceberg.
 
Last edited:
Wobblefoot said:
Platter wobble is probably a better way to put it. It's similar to what is shown in this video:


This could be likely, but I couldn't perceive any wobble in the sub-platter while it was spinning. Might be too small to notice, though, until the variance transfers to the larger glass platter.
Click to expand...

Did you the video of the Pro-ject wobble? Pretty pronounced. :(

 
Kit Carson said:
Four new tables with defects, did someone put a curse on you? Looking at the list at least two of the mfgs have had a long history of issues that buyers have complained about that appear to be from design and poor quality control. Much like the cars built in Japan the Technics will have a higher score for build quality than the four you tried. Instead of putting money into advertising Technics appears to spend it on quality control.
Click to expand...
I was beginning to wonder if I have a curse, too.

I'll see if I can find any Technics TT's that are available. Otherwise, I'll try the Planar 2 one more time and see how it goes. Maybe 5tth time is the charm :banana:
 
Wooblefoot might help in making a decision re trying another attempt with the Rega if you would do some research on AK to see how many other members have also experienced problems. When you see waiting lists for the Technics it should be an indication that they are in high demand for a good reason, excellent performance, very reliable with a long track record of millions sold, in comparison the other mfgs you chose are a cottage industry. Even the lower end Technics tables I would classify as the Toyota Camray and Honda Accord of turntables. If you don't know anything about cars you probably don't know anything about turntables.
 
Kit Carson said:
Wooblefoot might help in making a decision re trying another attempt with the Rega if you would do some research on AK to see how many other members have also experienced problems. When you see waiting lists for the Technics it should be an indication that they are in high demand for a good reason, excellent performance, very reliable with a long track record of millions sold, in comparison the other mfgs you chose are a cottage industry. Even the lower end Technics tables I would classify as the Toyota Camray and Honda Accord of turntables. If you don't know anything about cars you probably don't know anything about turntables.
Click to expand...

Seeing the high demand for Technics tables is definitely a good sign. The issue I'm seeing with their tables is a matter of availability on top of what I'm looking for in a turntable. I don't need pitch control, built in pre-amp, or a number of other features I'm seeing on what's currently available. I'm worried I'll be paying more for those unwanted/unneeded items.

EDIT: Hmm... I guess the SL-1500c is more up my alley. Now to try and find one...
 
You might want to check out a VPI turntable. Used Aries models or prime or Scout models. I prefer a gimbaled arm myself. If I had the cash I would want a SME 15, or a Smaller Clearaudio Ovation with a TT5 arm. If money were no object I'd want the top of the line Bergmann vacuum operated linear tracking turn table.
 
Wonnlefoot - If you buy cheaper T/T's like the ones mentioned, you are always in danger of buying a dud, but 4 of the trot is difficult to achieve, but as you found out not beyond the realms of possibility. The manufacturers work with cheaper components and cut cost due to economics, however if the company does not have a established Statistical quality engineering set up, they will not have the knowledge & techniques to reduce variation in the components. No company can inspect quality into their products, the car industry found that out in the late 70's when superior build Japanese cars arrived on the market.

I would like other people have suggested look to get a Technic's, as they have been going with a lineage of T/T like the SL1200 for quite a while now. Companies with a proven track record are always a better bet.

Cheers
 
Fluance is just Ya-Horng OEM like Teac. Teac may put some fancier parts on the higher end models, but you'll get the same upsides and downsides.

Sorry OP you had bad luck. Personally I am not surprised with your issues. I would move onto something else and stop messing with Pro-Ject, Rega, and Ya Horng stuff.

FWIW supply chain issues, workers getting sick, and unprecedented demand have caused QC/QA problems with all sorts of hi-fi gear and records as well. Even better TT manufacturers and record pressing plants have been affected by all this.
 
The odds of it happening to all of those tables is super low, I wonder if your having power issues from the plug. Maybe you have a fridge on the same circuit or something similar, the noise makes me think you do.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom