• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

HD Tuners anyone?

slowpat

Slowly but surely....
I'm beginning to hear more advertising from a couple of my fav local stations about their HD broadcasts, CD quality, etc. I was wondering if anyone has used an HD radio or tuner, and how would it sound hooked up to a home system?
 
Register to hide this ad
Read any thread about the Sony XDR-F1HD tuner. At $99 it's a big bargain and offers excellent performance for the price.
 
Sony XDR-F1HD

I have this tuner as many do here and its just great. You cannot go wrong for 99 dollars. 99 bucks buys almost nothing these days.

The sound is very clear and with an improvement in dynamic range over analog. You may really like it. :yes:
 
I saw some talk about this unit on here and elsewhere, and I ordered one off of Amazon as a result ($82 w/free shipping). I've heard the stock antennae that comes with it is good. Do any of you have any experience with the stock one, or are you using something better?
 
Thanks all. I'll read up on it, and at that price, it's worth a shot. If it is THAT GOOD, wouldn't it put the classic analog tuners (the likes of MR78, TX-9500II, etc.) out of business? How's the dynamic range compared to analog tuners? Does it sound thinner, or still full bodied?
 
Stock sound has been described as not great by some vintage fans. Some folks are quite harsh, calling it unlistenable or headache inducing. No comment, I have not heard it stock. I had two modded by Mike at Radio X. One with the basic audio mod and I still found it quite bland compared to even average vintage tuners that can be had for less than the Sony. The higher end mod makes it sound very good. The vintage tuners win in the highs and mids, the Sony kills in the low end, dynamics, quieting and reception. No longer a cheapie tuner with the big mod, but I think it offers excellent value when considering sound, reception, features and the fact it is not filled with 20 to 30 years old components.

I have noticed it is a lot harder to sell vintage tuners of late unless they are the iconic ones like a TU-717 ot TU-9900. I blame the Sony for that, at least partly.
 
I'm using a Sony XDR-F1HD tuner as well with good results. I don't use FM for critical listening, and the reception this tuner gets makes it really work for me.
Regards,
Jim
 
I saw some talk about this unit on here and elsewhere, and I ordered one off of Amazon as a result ($82 w/free shipping). I've heard the stock antennae that comes with it is good. Do any of you have any experience with the stock one, or are you using something better?

I am using the stock antenna through a two way splitter for two of my receivers. It is very good really! I wih I could buy a few more.

The Sony is on my outdoor dipole I never tried the supplied antenna with it but I can say that it performs better where I have it now than similar ones I had previous.
 
I got a minty used Rotel RT-1084 HD tuner from Audiogon a couple months ago and the sound quality is really quite good. No more hiss, nice accurate bass, fewer commercials, alternative formats. Most of my listening time is spent on the all blues HD2 multicast, but there's jazz, classical, soft rock, and other alternative multicasts available in my local area...
 
I got a minty used Rotel RT-1084 HD tuner from Audiogon a couple months ago and the sound quality is really quite good. No more hiss, nice accurate bass, fewer commercials, alternative formats. Most of my listening time is spent on the all blues HD2 multicast, but there's jazz, classical, soft rock, and other alternative multicasts available in my local area...

Is the Rotel good enough that the MR85's are being listened to less? :music: I'm quite interested in how the new generation of tuners will impact vintage tuners. Even McIntosh seems to have embraced HD with the MR88.
 
The Rotel HD tuner sounds plenty good and is definitely getting more listening time than my MR85's are right now. Not because the Rotel HD sounds better, I'm just hooked on that all blues HD2 multicast :yes:
 
The best HD Radio tuner is still not as good sounding as the best analogue but HD does expand your listening options. McIntosh has by far the best HD tuner of anything current even broadcast grade Modulation Monitors. I engineer for a radio group which has some HD stations. We use Day-Sequerra modulation monitors and our reference HD listening monitors are the current McIntosh. It is that good. Worth the investment for those who seek the best HD Radio sound quality and it's analog FM is also among the very best.
 
Bump, thinking of picking up a RT 1084 rather than getting a matching McIntosh tuner. Remotes and channel scanning can be fun. Does it have variable level out? (i'll try to answer that after I hit post) Does not have variable out from what i can see.
 
Last edited:
The best HD Radio tuner is still not as good sounding as the best analogue but HD does expand your listening options.

I have owned both the Sangean and Day-Sequerra HD tuners. In my location, with a strong signal, neither sounded as good as the best analog tuners (Rotel RHT-10, Mitsubishi DA-F20). Ironically HD is terrific for AM but there's nothing on that band for me in Phoenix. The "CD quality" claim is bogus, MP3 is more like it.
 
Bump, thinking of picking up a RT 1084 rather than getting a matching McIntosh tuner.
I had an RT-1084, it was fun to play with, at least initially. It was nice to get the clean digital signal, but the sound quality on all stations, including our local classical station, was sterile and compressed compared to the analog output. I ended up selling it.

In retrospect, perhaps there are some updates I could have done to improve the digital sound quality, but I don't regret going back to analog.
 
I got one and another going on the bench soon. I think they sound better than a modified Sony. You can disable the HD and it does sound better in most cases. The Rotel used some really crappy caps in this tuner. Replacing them seems to be the cure.
 
Are we discussing the hybrid digital tuners? Are there any stations still putting the extra signals out with their regular broadcasts? I got one of these tuners some time ago, nothing extra to pick up in this area. Does have a pretty fair standard tuner in it though. Pretty cheap these days too.
 
Back
Top Bottom