Thanks! That might be the point that it's time to take it to a shop for me.
The plot thickens though! I just turned it on again and this time it was working kinda.
Phono 1 and the FM tuner were both providing output, and AUX was creating a LOUD hum (but no signal output).
The big issue now is that phono 1 and the tuner both sound very reedy, the signal is attenuated somehow (and yes I played with the filter switch, it wasn't that--the filter switch attenuated the attenuation ).
Lots of scratchy sounds when I would play with the volume control, especially on the louder end. When I pushed it in as I was playing with it sometimes it would sound a little thicker, but with some weird harmonics.
When I was cleaning the inside I did not clean the volume pot because it was locked away in a case. Maybe I need to try to clean it a little somehow? Maybe it's something else? But it is giving me output now...at least for the time being. It also didn't overheat and shut down after 10 minutes...so who knows.