• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Muffsy phono stage hum problem

Connect a wire from your turntable internal ground to your phono amplifier case and another to the case of your amplifier, then show us a picture. Please. BTW, don't use rca grounds instead of case grounds. Drill a hole in the case if you must to put in a self tapping screw to make these connections. The only time this did not work for me was when I had a bad connection between a wire and the crimp on connector.
there is no ground wire in thorens td160, the ground scheme is internally done.
this is how the phono stage is connected, shown in the diagram.
 

Attachments

  • muffsy phono drawing.png
    muffsy phono drawing.png
    191.8 KB · Views: 16
Last edited:
The word "ground" is ambiguous. It is sometimes used to refer to refer to the ground/earth third pin of the mains electricity supply which is indeed connected to the ground of the planet we walk on. Often it is used to refer to the signal reference 0 volts, but the two aren't the same and may or may not be tied to each other. You need to be clear what you're talking about and what you're doing. To avoid ambiguity I'll refer to the mains' third pin as ground and the negative side of the RCA connectors as 0V.

A metal case which contains mains electricity should be grounded for safety unless it is double insulated. Your case isn't double insulated so it should be grounded by having a secure connection between the case and the incoming mains cable.

The RCA sockets should be isolated from the case. The left and right input RCA 0V tags should be connected to the relevant blue connector on the edge of the board. The left and right output RCA 0V tags should be connected to the relevant blue connector on the edge of the board. They should not be connected to each other.

How and where should the case be connected to 0V, if at all? That depends to some extent on how the rest of the system is wired. I would recommend that the case is not connected directly to 0V but instead connected via a 100 ohm resistor. A capacitor of about 100nF can be wired in parallel with the resistor to suppress RF noise if necessary. If everything is wired correctly you can test it for noise independently of the turntable by inserting shorting plugs into the input sockets and listening. The hum you hear will be as low as it's going to get. Any extra noise you hear with the turntable connected is due to a problem within the turntable.

You still haven't explained how the turntable is wired, but I suspect an issue there. Ideally the left and right negative sides of the cartridge should go back to the turntable via independent wires without coming into contact with each other and the turntable/arm's metalwork should have another wire which is independent of the first two wires. This third wire is often called the "ground" wire, but that's another ambiguous term. Does it have to be connected to ground as defined earlier? No, and it's best if it isn't. A less ambiguous term for that wire would be "shield". I suspect your setup doesn't have a separate shield wire and the turntable's metalwork is connected to one of the cartridge's negative pins. That can cause problems with some phonostages even though it works perfectly well with others.
 
Since the noise is coming from the muffsy itself, the fault is within the muffsy. Looking at the schematic of the power supply, it shows a "ground". That "ground" must take place *before* the preamp. As it is now, the "ground" for the power supply has to travel (loop) through the preamp, and the RCA connectors, then finally to chassis where it can amplify any noise that is leftover from the rectifier sections, and end up coming through the output to the amplifier. Plugging in the turntable changes it because it is drawing some of the hum to ground. That noise must be quenched before it enters the preamp by a ground to chassis directly from the power supply. I suggest running a wire from the ground point on the power supply to the ground stud on the chassis and see if that helps. You can just use a piece of wire with alligator clips to test it out. If nothing changes, then I would suggest checking all your solder connections on both boards. There may simply be a "dry" solder joint somewhere.
 
there is no ground wire in thorens td160, the ground scheme is internally done.
this is how the phono stage is connected, shown in the diagram.

Yes, and that in itself can cause it's own set of issues on some systems. But in this case I think the independent turntable ground is actually helping since when it is connected to the muffsy, the hum reduces. That points to the muffsy itself.
 
No surprise there. It's a "kit" made in China.. Some of the solder joints look "dry", meaning it looks like they may not be making the best contact. Try shorting the inputs + to - (center to ground on the RCA connectors) with about a 1k-3k resistor in the muffsy and see if the hum gets better. You can buy "shorting plugs" for RCA inputs. I use them on unused inputs to eliminate stray hum. Don't short the outputs though. :D

Skrodahl is in Sweden and ships from there. He's normally quite responsive, I've got a 74 email long chain going with him.

The Muffsy is a riff on the AK CNC phono stage. There's some drama there I'd rather not get into, but long story short it functions identically from an electrical perspective.

Typically these are run with the AC transformer in a wall wart to keep mains voltages and their associated noise as far from the audio bits as possible. Looking at OP's pics, it looks like there's a transformer inside the box with the pre. This kind of screws with the chassis ability to reject noise-cant reject something that's inside the case.

@OP - I'd like you to try a few things:

1. Float the chassis (remove all grounds to chassis) - does the problem get better or worse?

2. Make some shorting plugs - get a set of cheap RCA's, cut the ends off, and on each cut off plug solder the shield and pin wires together. Plug these into the Muffsy inputs. Does the hum go away?

3. Get some aluminum foil and make a 'wall" in your box between the transformer and the audio bits. Does the hum diminish?

4.You've got really long wires going to your power supply from the transformer. These are great antennas for noise to get in/out of the power supply side of the system. Try wrapping them in aluminum foil (don't short anything out). Any improvement?

Cheers,
Nathan
 
Typically these are run with the AC transformer in a wall wart to keep mains voltages and their associated noise as far from the audio bits as possible. Looking at OP's pics, it looks like there's a transformer inside the box with the pre. This kind of screws with the chassis ability to reject noise-cant reject something that's inside the case.
I agree.
1. Float the chassis (remove all grounds to chassis) - does the problem get better or worse?
You could do this as an experiment but long term the case should be grounded for safety reasons.
2. Make some shorting plugs - get a set of cheap RCA's, cut the ends off, and on each cut off plug solder the shield and pin wires together. Plug these into the Muffsy inputs. Does the hum go away?
I already suggested that and I think the OP has done it, claiming the noise is reduced but not eliminated.
3. Get some aluminum foil and make a 'wall" in your box between the transformer and the audio bits. Does the hum diminish?
If the problem is the transformer's magnetic field (which it could be) this will have no effect because aluminium isn't ferromagnetic and has no effect on magnetic fields.
 
Agree on all points. Missed the post about the shorting plugs.

I was thinking more stray RF from the Xformer and leads. Hard even with a ferrous material to get enough thickness to fully block stray magnetism from something that close.
 
no effect because aluminium isn't ferromagnetic and has no effect on magnetic fields.

Not quite true, but the effect is negligible in this case. Drop a flat aluminum length (a meter stick or something) through a gap between 2 magnets, and the rate of speed which it passes will be noticeably affected by the magnetic field.
A transformer shield should be steel, and the AC secondary leads twisted the entire length. Though I think the effect is minimal in this case, it could still be introducing some noise.
 
Skrodahl is in Sweden and ships from there. He's normally quite responsive, I've got a 74 email long chain going with him.

The Muffsy is a riff on the AK CNC phono stage. There's some drama there I'd rather not get into, but long story short it functions identically from an electrical perspective.

Typically these are run with the AC transformer in a wall wart to keep mains voltages and their associated noise as far from the audio bits as possible. Looking at OP's pics, it looks like there's a transformer inside the box with the pre. This kind of screws with the chassis ability to reject noise-cant reject something that's inside the case.

@OP - I'd like you to try a few things:

1. Float the chassis (remove all grounds to chassis) - does the problem get better or worse?

2. Make some shorting plugs - get a set of cheap RCA's, cut the ends off, and on each cut off plug solder the shield and pin wires together. Plug these into the Muffsy inputs. Does the hum go away?

3. Get some aluminum foil and make a 'wall" in your box between the transformer and the audio bits. Does the hum diminish?

4.You've got really long wires going to your power supply from the transformer. These are great antennas for noise to get in/out of the power supply side of the system. Try wrapping them in aluminum foil (don't short anything out). Any improvement?

Cheers,
Nathan
Yes, from Sweden, but I am sure he doesn't manufacture his own components. :p
OK I agree using a remote wall wart does indeed eliminate any (normal) noise as long as it is of good quality.
The shorting of the inputs has been covered to no avail.
Aluminum foil will do nothing. A shield should be steel or tin (easy to bend into shape)
I would suggest moving the power supply board to the rear of the chassis and use twisted wires to connect it to the main board running them along the chassis, not suspended in the air. Then install a barrier shield all the way across to shield both the transformer and PS board. I really don't know why it was designed to have the Xformer secondary AC come in through the preamp section, then to the PS board, and loop back through as rectified DC.. It seems counter intuitive to me.:dunno:
 
Thank you so much for all the valuable suggestions. I hope this will work and eliminate hum and buz. I will implement and test those suggestions in this weekend. Regards
 
Yes, from Sweden, but I am sure he doesn't manufacture his own components. :p
OK I agree using a remote wall wart does indeed eliminate any (normal) noise as long as it is of good quality.
The shorting of the inputs has been covered to no avail.
Aluminum foil will do nothing. A shield should be steel or tin (easy to bend into shape)
I would suggest moving the power supply board to the rear of the chassis and use twisted wires to connect it to the main board running them along the chassis, not suspended in the air. Then install a barrier shield all the way across to shield both the transformer and PS board. I really don't know why it was designed to have the Xformer secondary AC come in through the preamp section, then to the PS board, and loop back through as rectified DC.. It seems counter intuitive to me.:dunno:

My point was that the support isn't coming from some unknown factory in China. ;)

The board layout was a consequence of the enclosure the boards were designed to utilize.

2018-06-28T05%3A40%3A50.445Z-pp4-complete.png

2018-06-28T05%3A40%3A50.445Z-pp-4-complete02.png


The preamp is at the back with the PSU in front to prevent the signal from having to cross over the PSU board. Running the power in a couple of traces on the preamp board keeps the internal wiring a bit neater in this case.

In the OP's layout I don't see a good reason to do this either, he should probably just run the AC directly to the PSU board.

When I was troubleshooting my build for a similar hum issue I found the problem area by slipping foil between the power leads and the preamp. I ended up wrapping the power leads in foil tape. Mine was a previous revision that didn't have the traces on the preamp board to route power past it to the PSU.
 
My point was that the support isn't coming from some unknown factory in China. ;)

The board layout was a consequence of the enclosure the boards were designed to utilize.

2018-06-28T05%3A40%3A50.445Z-pp4-complete.png

2018-06-28T05%3A40%3A50.445Z-pp-4-complete02.png


The preamp is at the back with the PSU in front to prevent the signal from having to cross over the PSU board. Running the power in a couple of traces on the preamp board keeps the internal wiring a bit neater in this case.

In the OP's layout I don't see a good reason to do this either, he should probably just run the AC directly to the PSU board.

When I was troubleshooting my build for a similar hum issue I found the problem area by slipping foil between the power leads and the preamp. I ended up wrapping the power leads in foil tape. Mine was a previous revision that didn't have the traces on the preamp board to route power past it to the PSU.

I saw it on the website, and yes, that neat little enclosure would be the way to go, and use the wall wart. That's how I would do it anyways. I believe the OP's intent was to use an enclosure to match his existing equipment. There's nothing wrong with that at all. Customizing is my way of thinking. lol! I am sure the hum issue can be sorted out, it's just a matter of finding the cause and correcting it. There is no reason it can't be made to work. I am wondering though, how are the boards mounted in the "made for it" enclosure? Do any of the boards utilize mounting screws/studs for directly grounding them to the chassis? The OP has the boards isolated, and "grounded" through the cables at the end of the chain. I am thinking that may be at least part of the issue, and not so much the proximity of the transformer.
 
IIRC there's a ground strap, but the boards are mounted via sliding into little channels in the extruded aluminum enclosure. Friction fit, no screws.
 
Thank you so much for all the valuable suggestions. I hope this will work and eliminate hum and buz. I will implement and test those suggestions in this weekend. Regards

We want to see this unit up and working just as much as you do. I think it's a pretty nifty piece of equipment. :thumbsup:
 
He may be on vacation or something, though his tindie store normally indicates when that's the case.

We all need a "vacation" from time to time. Mine is coming in a little over a week from now. I just hope him not being active isn't a sign of any trouble.
 
Back
Top Bottom