• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Noisy Tube Rectifiers :(

vincei

aka MasterControlMedia
It's driving me nuts, are there rectifiers that don't have the "high voltage" high frequency mechanical noise? It comes and goes and it's in the tube itself (5U4GB). It can get annoying in soft passages as the amp is close to my ear. I do have the correct input impedance for the tube and it does not seem to be working too hard. Any recommendations? NOS perhaps? Right now I am using a TAD. It's so annoying that I may switch to SS rectifiers! :no:
 
Register to hide this ad
hey-Hey!!!,
There's lots ov ways a tube can go bad. I haven't seen the particular sort you're speaking of though. 5U4 are plentiful and inexpensive.
cheers,
Douglas
 
Last edited by a moderator:
hey-Hey!!!,
There's lots ov ways a tube can go bad. I haven't seen the particular sort you're speaking of though.

Thanks for the reply. I have tried a few new production tubes and was disapointed with them. A while back I did have a RCA that seemed to work very well, but it's long gone. I guess it's time to tube roll! :yes:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You might even luck out with used ones. I've probably got a dozen of those in various boxes, and all of them seem to be OK. The good thing about the 5U4 is that its so doggone common.
 
I have ran a few of the RCA 5u4's with great results. I am running one now in my Latino ST120 and it has been rock solid.(much better than the newer gz34's)

I also have a CBS 5u4 that I got from Jim McShane. Another very good 5u4!!

I could not think that you would have any problems finding a good 5u4.


-Vic
 
As others have said, 5U4 is common, and you should be able to find something that works via a "shotgun" approach, if nothing else.

I have heard of tubes coming loose from their bases. This is not uncommon. I have heard several fixes for this condition, the one that I've heard a bunch of guys swear by is to use clear nail polish as an adhesive between the glass and base. I have not personally tired it, but if I had a tube of glass-to-plastic-base construction, one way I'd try to damp the physical vibration would be to ensure a good mechanical connection between the base and the glass.

If you'd like to experiment with solid state diodes, you need not have to mod your amp: mod a dead octal tube, instead. If you can get a bad octal tube, remove the base & pins from the glass. I think the pins often have solder in them, and you can remove it or soften it and re-use it for your own purposes. Put a pair of solid state diodes in the octal base with the same pinout as the vacuum ones, and you'll have a drop-in SS rectifier to play around with.

Good luck with the project!
 
Always check the socket and pins to make sure they are shiny clean too. It diesn't take much insulating to make high voltage fussy.
 
Thanks all for the tips. It a real strange noise that seems to come from the plates like a filament vibrating or something. I have also heard this noise with an EH 5U4GB too on my previous build, so maybe it's just a quality issue with new stock. The amp in question is the one in my avatar that I just built, so sockets are new, tube is new. I made sure I had the correct input impedance, so I guess I will just try another one and see what happens.
 
I know that sound you are talking about :yes:, but sinse I don't listen to soft music (classical never turned me on if that's your thing), it never bothered me personally.

Try DC on the filaments. Just something to think about. :scratch2:

Move your amplifier. :D
 
Last edited:
I'd like to see you try DC heat for the filaments of a directly heated rectifier.

hey-Hey!!!,
It can be done, but I've seen no point to doing it...:) It is similar to heating a cathode biased 845 filament; the DC supply will ride around 190V above ground, completely isolated( or at least that is often the goal ).
cheers,
Douglas
 
It's so annoying that I may switch to SS rectifiers! :no:
I designed with SS rectifier and never looked back. Providing my amp with power is done much simpler and reliably with a bridge rectifier. I have a very quiet power supply. As I recall Vincei, I sent you the schematic for it.
 
I go SS 80% of the time, 100% on amps that use a lot of current (like ST70s).:yes: As I saw Douglas mention somewhere, diodes are very nearly perfect nowadays.:yes:
 
I designed with SS rectifier and never looked back. Providing my amp with power is done much simpler and reliably with a bridge rectifier. I have a very quiet power supply. As I recall Vincei, I sent you the schematic for it.

I believe you did, I have to find it....I did design my amp with all possible configurations in mind, so it would be very simple to do SS....maybe I should give it a try and see what happens and keep the tube rectifier for show. :D I'll keep everyone abreast of the situation....:music:
 
Oh you're hearing the filaments vibrate. I thought the noise you were getting was coming through the power supply and out the speakers. Try swapping it for a 5AR4. Its an indirectly heated rectifier that should be a direct swap. It uses less heater current too, which is generally helps lower power transformer temps a smidge. I want to say the voltage drop is a bit less with a 5AR4 though, so you may have to alter resistors in the supply to get the voltage correct.
 
Oh you're hearing the filaments vibrate. I thought the noise you were getting was coming through the power supply and out the speakers. Try swapping it for a 5AR4. Its an indirectly heated rectifier that should be a direct swap. It uses less heater current too, which is generally helps lower power transformer temps a smidge. I want to say the voltage drop is a bit less with a 5AR4 though, so you may have to alter resistors in the supply to get the voltage correct.

Thanks for the suggestion, I may have to try it. :music:
 
It's driving me nuts, are there rectifiers that don't have the "high voltage" high frequency mechanical noise? It comes and goes and it's in the tube itself (5U4GB). It can get annoying in soft passages as the amp is close to my ear. I do have the correct input impedance for the tube and it does not seem to be working too hard. Any recommendations? NOS perhaps? Right now I am using a TAD. It's so annoying that I may switch to SS rectifiers! :no:

5U4's are direct heated dual rectifiers that will make a little noise, but the vintage "GB" variants are quiet. Still, with your amp near your ear, you will probably hear either the power transformer or something. You can get good used and new old stock ones from Radio Electric Supply, Antique Electronic Supply, and Tube Depot. just do a google search for them. All are reputable tube dealers I have bought from and they all stand behind what they sell.
Try a vintage 5U4GB from GE or RCA. They are usually $20.00 or under for new vintage tubes. That's what I use in a lot of my amps I build and they work great and last a long time. It is important that each rectifier section is tested by it's self. Rectifiers with sections that are more then 15% different can cause an amp to hum more then normal.
 
Questions:

Is your amp situated in a way or place where it could be vibrated by speakers, or movement on your part? How exactly did you narrow this down to the rectifier, as opposed to a pre amp tube? Is it literally coming from the tube? Are you you sure you're not just senstive to high frequencies? I'm 24, and can still here many CRT tv sets whine.
 
Questions:

Is your amp situated in a way or place where it could be vibrated by speakers, or movement on your part? How exactly did you narrow this down to the rectifier, as opposed to a pre amp tube? Is it literally coming from the tube? Are you you sure you're not just senstive to high frequencies? I'm 24, and can still here many CRT tv sets whine.

It's the tube itself, the speaker outputs are silent. I listen to music fairly soft, so nothing is vibrating, the transformer is also quite silent as it's potted. I'm going to be 41 in a couple weeks and feel I may have some hearing loss in the higher frequencies, but yet I could hear the tube rattling, go figure. :sigh: I going to try a few things including different rectifiers and SS and see which I like better. I guess that's part of the fun with this hobby, tweaking and more tweaking!
 
Back
Top Bottom