• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Poll: Preferred TT Mechanism

Preferred TT Mechanism

  • Manual

    Votes: 36 41.4%
  • Semi-automatic

    Votes: 14 16.1%
  • Automatic

    Votes: 24 27.6%
  • Programmable

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No Preference

    Votes: 13 14.9%

  • Total voters
    87

riksors

Active Member
What is your preferred turntable mechanism?

Manual
Semi-automatic
Automatic
Programmable
No preference
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I have some of each, except for a programmable. I haven't based a purchase decision on this criteria, nor would I, except that I have no interest in a programmable. I grew up listening to complete sides on AOR radio for a couple of years before I got my first stereo at 16. I've always been an album guy. Getting through the chaff to get to the wheat is deeply engrained. Besides given time and additional opportunity, much of that chaff becomes much more like wheat. ;)
 
I prefer manuals for their simplicity--I know it can be a PITA to have to do everything yourself when there are units available that have semi or fully automatic functions, but manuals are in general (and this is a big "generalization") more reliable and easier to maintain/service/modify. I guess part of my "vinyl experience" is sitting down and actually listening to an album, and not letting myself get "distracted" by doing other things, because I know that I have to be there and attend to the deck--if I want long-playing "backround music", that is what digital and R2R is for.
 
I have some of each, except for a programmable. I haven't based a purchase decision on this criteria, nor would I, except that I have no interest in a programmable. I grew up listening to complete sides on AOR radio for a couple of years before I got my first stereo at 16. I've always been an album guy. Getting through the chaff to get to the wheat is deeply engrained. Besides given time and additional opportunity, much of that chaff becomes much more like wheat. ;)

I 100% agree with you on the "chaffe becoming more like the wheat"--I often find "hidden gems" that were B-sides or never really received any popularity in terms of air-play--in fact, I often find those tracks far more enjoyable than the "hit single" that was jammed down your throat in heavy rotation on the radio.
 
All my tables are belt drive manuals.
Regards,
Jim
 
I have nothing against automation, but it so happens that all of the best-sounding turntables I've heard or owned have been fully manual.
 
My best sounding tables are manuals but I use semi auto and auto as well.

Auto is good for late night listening when combined with wine, scotch, etc. o_O
 
I like fully automatic with the ability to stack records. For me, nothing better than putting 3 or 4 of some of my many favorite albums on for an hour or more of great music.
 

*lol* Good one!


Anyway, I think semi-automatic should have been at least split up between auto-stop & -lift and auto-stop, -lift and -return - because the -return requires automated horizontal tonearm motion, which makes it quite a good bit more complex, so it's not that far away from fully automatic anymore. And that's why I prefer either auto-stop & -lift only semi-automatic (for a reasonable degree of comfort without that much extra complexity) or fully automatic (full complexity, but due to that also full comfort).

Greetings from Munich!

Manfred / lini
 
My most favorite TT is the Revox B-791, which I classify under Semi-auto. Next most favorite is the SL-1200MkII, which is manual and then comes the SL-1300MkII which is fully auto.
All function and sound great - actually they sound as good as the cart on them.
I hate changers. They break down and when they work correctly they just drop the LPs which can't be good. And what about careful VTA adjustment and changers?
 
Back
Top Bottom