• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Speaker fuse suggestions please

waggs098

Super Member
I have a few receiver that don't have speaker relays or speaker protection fuses. They have transistor protection but I don't think that's enough. Im wondering if someone can suggest a fuse rating based on watts. If I have a 45 watt receiver what size of fuse should I use or if I have a 20 watt or a 65 watt what size of fuse.

Thanks,
Justin
 
Register to hide this ad
Acoustic Research suggested fuse sizes:

0.6 amp - AR-2, AR-2a, AR-2x, AR-2ax, AR-4, AR-4x, AR-6
0.8 amp - AR-1, AR-3, AR-3t, AR-3st, AR-5
1.25 amp - AR-3a
2 amp - AR/LST

Additional info regarding the AR-3a:

This is a 4 ohm system, will sustain 11 watts rms continuous at any frequency indefinitely, 23 watts for at least 20 seconds, and overloads of 400 watts for 2 seconds.
 
Can you tell us something about your loudspeakers (watts,ohms)?

I run 2 sets of speakers that are really nothing special. One set are the fishers in my signature. The other are heathkit speakers. Can't find a watt rating for the fishers but I would guess they might be rated around 80 to 120 watt. The heathkits are rated for 10 to 200 watts.

What I'm more concerned about is amplifier protection in case something happens with the speakers. I also run a powered sub so there's a possibility of the amp in the sub shorting out and causing problems.

I don't listen at a high enough volume to really do damage to the speakers. I have a small listening space.
 
What are you trying to protect? speakers or receiver?

did you see the link to the nomograph in the thread I linked? It is THE answer to your question when YOU put in your operating characteristics.

You have not told us enough for us to answer the question you still have and yet you just bump without any more information for us to more accurately answer your question.

If you are not going to use the nomograph and you want to do what some manufacturers do, roll over to HFE and look at the information on the SA-200, 300, 400... receivers. These had speaker protection fuses on them that have different values based on the output power. They are designed to protect the speakers in case of a problem, not protect the speaker from being driven with an amplifier being over driven.
 
The odds damage to a receiver/amp from a failure in a speaker that's not being driven hard are exceedingly small. Bordering on non-existent, IMO.
 
What are you trying to protect? speakers or receiver?

did you see the link to the nomograph in the thread I linked? It is THE answer to your question when YOU put in your operating characteristics.

You have not told us enough for us to answer the question you still have and yet you just bump without any more information for us to more accurately answer your question.

If you are not going to use the nomograph and you want to do what some manufacturers do, roll over to HFE and look at the information on the SA-200, 300, 400... receivers. These had speaker protection fuses on them that have different values based on the output power. They are designed to protect the speakers in case of a problem, not protect the speaker from being driven with an amplifier being over driven.

This is what I stated before:


"What I'm more concerned about is amplifier protection in case something happens with the speakers. I also run a powered sub so there's a possibility of the amp in the sub shorting out and causing problems.*

I don't listen at a high enough volume to really do damage to the speakers. I have a small listening space."



also I guess I didn't go far enough in the link you refered to see the correct link you were referring to. But it still sounds like that is for speaker protection not amp protection.

ill.check out the fuse sizes on those receivers and see what I come up with.

The reason this became a concern to me is because I was refoaming some 10 inch woofers and there were four total. I was using a 30 hz tone to center the coil and it worked great on the the first 3 I did l. On the fourth one there apparently was something wrong with the coil. Luckily there was fuse protection. On the unit I was using for the tone generation It blew the fuse in it. I originally tested them all with an ohm meter and they all tested fine. What I found doing further tests is when I moved the cone in and out it only once in a while would short down to one ohm. Really it wasn't an easy issue do find with the driver.

I really don't know what other info I can give.
 
Last edited:
The correct fuse rating depends on what the speaker can handle, not what the amp can put out, even under a fault condition. No exceptions.

If you are worried about distortion from the fuse, just put a 3,300 uF bipolar across it, remember, you are really only protecting against DC.
 
When I was in my teens, I pushed my 1st MCS 3233 HARD, often for hours on end. It was rated at 33 wpc (think it's a little conservative) and could peak around 65 wpc. I listened to a lot of bass-heavy early 90's rap at the time which really stressed gear like this. Two issues I ran into were HEAT, and the occasional 3 amp speaker fuse blowing. It incorporated 3 fuses total. One main 3 amp fuse (it never blew), then another 3 amp for left channel and another for 3 amp for right channel. I never pushed the unit into clipping, but rather had it going with loudness ON and bass at 10+(loudness on this amp appears to be powered, vs.more common passive and doesn't slope off as volume increases, meaning it'll scale with volume nomater how loud. This particular unit was very heavy in the low-end department. I originally ran two 3-way boxes which consisted of factory 77' MCS 683-8226 which had 12" drivers with a tweeter and mid, and 2 adjustment knobs that allowed for a +3 to -3db slope for tweeter and mids. I got them from my dad and by that time they had already had a woofer replaced with the remaining factory woofer exhibiting foam rot. I opted for Radio Shack's circa 92' Realistic 12" polypropylene woofers http://support.radioshack.com/support_audio/doc15/15876.htm as replacements as they matched the factory 8 ohm and were capable of 50 watt rms, though I seem to remember them being 93 db @ 1w so the link might be a later redesign. They were excellent sounding woofers on a budget and complimented that stereo perfectly, and produced deep, rich bass regardless of how loud they were pushed. Under certain conditions, the factory 3 amp fuse would occasionally let go under heavy, extended usage. I figured the amp was designed when rock and roll was about the most punishment the engineers could have foreseen with rap still being nearly a decade away before heavy sinewave bass mixing into the beat became the norm. At some point, I added a secondary set of woofers which were mid 90's Pioneer 3-ways with 12" woofers. They didn't sound as "good", so I rewired the MCS cabs to be strictly running the Realistic woofers for the extra, harder-hitting bass while delegating the Pioneer to the front stage with mids, highs, and the paper 12" woofers and also added a ton of sound damping internally to the boxes as it sounded cleaner and tighter to my ears without the annoying drone that occurs w/o it, plus it gave it a much deeper sound stage. I did however use the factory MCS voice choke (it was huge) on the Realistic woofers to cut highs from the signal.

Running all 4 cabinets in the A+B configuration, taxed the hell out the stereo when pushed hard enough. On heavy notes it'd dim the panel lights so it was clearly pulling every bit of it's 290 watt draw rating. Anyways, being naive and literally the only person I knew that was even remotely interested in making home stereos sound louder/better than intended, I remember talking to the Radio Shack guy (remember, this was around 1993 when they were still a shadow of their former glory and I think they still stold the Mach series in 15") and he suggested stepping up a fuse size or two. Factory called for 3 amp fast blow, which if I understood it correctly acted like premature power limiters. I know the 3N3055 were typically rated at 40-50w, and the unit was rated at 33 wpc. The 4 amp fuses didn't work, so I upped them to 5 amp slow blow. At the same time, my buddy's dad was a ham radio guy and was throwing away a box of old parts. In that box was an AC powered PC style fan. I asked him for it and he gave it to me. I fashioned a short AC cord that was connected directly to an AC power switch that fed into the back "switched" AC receptacle which worked perfectly as it'd shut off with the unit. I removed a section of the restrictive top faux vent to make room for the new PC fan, and hot glued it into place (I thought it looked cool at the time :D and was proud of coming up with the idea myself as I had no input from anyone and had no clue nicer stereos/amps had built in fans :smoke:), and had it pulling heat out. It worked great as it sat immediately above the amp board with it's super basic heat sink and was close to the power supply caps. The amount of heat it pulled out was remarkable, especially when the amp was being run at a moderate level for hours on end.

Anyways, I got many more years out of it in that configuration and those couple mods made it possible. I also noticed a slight improvement in sound quality over the headphones. No idea WHY, but it definitely altered the signal slightly. Around 2000, a drug addicted dickhead roommate that was running a rental scam on me cleaned me out one afternoon while at work and somehow sabotaged it, so it died after he tampered with it.

Sorry for long post, and I'm sure the electronic engineer types are waiting to snipe at me for this, but it did work and lasted a while thereafter. The Pioneer 3-ways were actually rated at 6 ohms, which it tolerated after the mods w/o issues as the amp was only rated at 8 ohm or 16 ohm with A+B. I doubt I'd do the same today, given I can bi-amp or even tri-amp if needed for rock solid low-end or complimentary mids/highs if ever needed, but adding another smaller fan under the vent cover this time (or even 2 fans in pull configuration to keep it running cooler) would still make sense.


Dunno if that helps you out at all, but in my case stepping up the fuse rating on the speakers ONLY helped. Most newer gear has heat sensors that'll shut it down, along with other built-in features for protection, so it might not even be possible. BUT, at the very least adding a fan or 2 to PULL heat from the stereo/amp cabinet can do wonders as well as extend the overall lifespan of solid state equipment. Most manufactures don't add the expense of a fan unless they start getting into high current low ohm scenarios or run high wattage Class A/B, etc. as they aren't cheap when you figure they might make 150k units and at $5 a fan the overall price of the amp to develop would jump by $750k just from that $5 part, plus money into running a DC header and stepping down voltage, plus a resistor for different speeds, extra on/off temp sensors, added audible noise outside case, etc. etc. But for the hobbyist getting the most from the unit over a 20+ year life span, it's 100% worth incorporating and adding several small fans will cut noise down. Running AC fans allows for using the onboard AC outlets ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom