…I have never lost a Maxell tape with a Nakamichi cassette machine. I still have 20 brand new unwrapped XL II cassettes. UD xl used with Dolby S on A Nakamchi yields some fantastic results.
I mostly preferred Maxwell as well. I believe I still have XLII-180s which I mostly got for live recordings but have dipped into for some time shift tapes when the piece on the radio on log for even a 120m cassette.
That said I will note as a fellow Nakamichi user, I have numerous bad experiences with the MS-S 90 and 100mminute lengths in the iterations that’s cam3 in blue and gold wrappers. This is on a 1000zxl limited after (and maybe even worse, although that may be a too small sample space before issue) the de1ck was overhauled recently by ESL and works great on everything else. I have analyzed this failure and believe I know the cause.
The symptom is that rewinding to the beginning of tape causes the tape to fall off the pancake and get wrapped around the hub, crinkling the tape at its beginning. I believe it is worse after rebuild because the idler tire is much “grippier” so the torque is just a tad higher when the tape rewinds to the beginning.
In theory it could happen fast forwarding to the end s well, but I probably don’t do that very much at all, whereas the rewiaooens at the end of the autocal process for the tape quite frequently. It’s quite annoying; like dropping the dishes on the floor and breaking them after they’ve been cleaned.
I believe the reason the cassette is a contributing factor is that these tapes have somewhat shorter leaders. When fully rewind, the leader wraps around the supply pancake only about 3/4 of the way. Most tapes, including other Maxells, have at least one term and usually more. This means the brunt of the torque change on stopping usually falls on the stronger and thicker leader. This is even better with a textured leader.
The short leaders in these tapes put a lot more strain on the slippery and thinner tape itself causing the failure at the end of wind stop.
Other versions of the MX-S 90s and 100s have longer leaders and I have not had them fail yet.
I have also had a lot of XL-II 100 cassettes that Are sticky and need the rap technique. Some are a lo worse than othe. It usually fails in rewind and not FG. I suspect the case may have been in a hot warehouse sometime in its life.