• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Thorens to Technics?

It does. Take the Ortofon SH-4 for example. It's designed to level an 18mm tall cart on 70's and 80's Asian TT's that were fitted with headshells to level a 15mm tall cart. And, thus, when a tall cart is mounted to the as issued headshell of such a TT and the TT does not have a tonearm which is adjustable for VTA, the result is a tail low cart. To level the cart the headshell must be replaced with one like the Ortofon SH-4, or the tonearm base must be elevated by shimming. In the case of a non-detachable headshell fitted with a too tall cart of course the tonearm base must be shimmed if the TT does not have an adjustable VTA freature.

How would your headshell work for a cart 21mm tall? How about a table with a straight arm? Give me a break.

Very simple, purchase a cartridge that fits your headshell if your table doesn't have adjustable VTA, easy peasy. Or purchase a table with adjustable VTA if wanting to try different cartridges, no reason to make things difficult.

I have no issue with detachable headshells, many of my tables have them including the KD770D, but they're not any advantage over fixed, and could very easily be a weak point in the playback system, just ask anyone with a broken collet on their AR XA.

Not to mention the many people seeking help here with hum issues etc and the problem is the headshell arm connection.
 
Last edited:
How would your headshell work for a cart 21mm tall? How about a table with a straight arm? Give me a break.

Very simple, purchase a cartridge that fits your headshell if your table doesn't have adjustable VTA, easy peasy. Or purchase a table with adjustable VTA if wanting to try different cartridges, no reason to make things difficult.

I have no issue with detachable headshells, many of my tables have them including the KD770D, but they're not any advantage over fixed, and could very easily be a weak point in the playback system, just ask anyone with a broken collet on their AR XA.

Not to mention the many people seeking help here with hum issues etc and the problem is the headshell arm connection.
Issues with headshell connections are often too thick washer on Chinese headshells so thinner washer or remove is the easy fix.
Chris
 
How would your headshell work for a cart 21mm tall? How about a table with a straight arm? Give me a break.

Very simple, purchase a cartridge that fits your headshell if your table doesn't have adjustable VTA, easy peasy. Or purchase a table with adjustable VTA if wanting to try different cartridges, no reason to make things difficult.

I have no issue with detachable headshells, many of my tables have them including the KD770D, but they're not any advantage over fixed, and could very easily be a weak point in the playback system, just ask anyone with a broken collet on their AR XA.

Not to mention the many people seeking help here with hum issues etc and the problem is the headshell arm connection.
This thread is comparing and contrasting the feature set of two specific turntables and you've just made my case, thanks,"purchase a cartridge that fits your headshell if your table doesn't have adjustable VTA". Well, that limits your choice of carts. Buying the Technics does not limit choice.
 
No!

Not better. Different? Yes!

The Techie will be slightly tighter & 'punchier' at midbass (though short of an idler in that regard) but the Thorens will be more detailed and nuanced. So 'better' depends on which attributes mean more to you. From personal experience, I know that no amount of advice can substitute for personal experience, so I'd suggest you get that Techie and satisfy your curiosity. After a few months using/comparing them, you may want to sell one or keep both. But at least you'll know exactly why you made your choice. Again; no advice can substitute for your own personal experience in such regards.

Enjoy the music!

Me too i agree!!

Without discounting what others have said that is excellent advice. Much preferable to have a reasoned and well thought out comment like this rather than seemingly endless heated debate and disagreement over which table is best..
 
Me too i agree!!

Without discounting what others have said that is excellent advice. Much preferable to have a reasoned and well thought out comment like this rather than seemingly endless heated debate and disagreement over which table is best..
You may well or it may end up like me. 5 turntables connected one other waiting for an arm. Oh the Sl1210mk2 is playing now which it does 90 percent of the time.. what is best? Probably the sp10mk2 sonically, but sl1210 gets most use and difference sonically is very small.
Chris
 
For sure, the 1200 is better when user wants to accommodate multiple cartridges. The 1200 adapts to universal SME type headshells, and changing one headshell/cart for another, the just connected headshell can be adjusted for VTA and/or azimuth very quickly.

Just for the pun; the "universal" headshell to tonearm connector used by most cartridge and tonearm manufacturers today is an Ortofon original design that was used on the first SME3012 tonearms and the rest of the wrong word spread is history... ;) And it's not even a connector most consider of the best kind but it works not so bad hopefully.

Beside other functionality like speed pitch and instant start and stop, the Thorens still could be improved seriously (but to a cost that's true) with an external PSU and tachometer combo. There you will keep all those sonic characteristics of the Thorens and Rega tonearm while improving the speed accuracy and constancy for tighter bass as well.
 
This thread is comparing and contrasting the feature set of two specific turntables and you've just made my case, thanks,"purchase a cartridge that fits your headshell if your table doesn't have adjustable VTA". Well, that limits your choice of carts. Buying the Technics does not limit choice.

Sure it does, it limits you to a mid-fi table with an "S" arm. I have 6 tables here, including a Technics SL1200MKII (actually this table has been moved along, it just didn't make the cut), all the others spank it. Well to be perfectly honest it's about on par with the Mitsubishi DP-EC8, which is actually a compliment, but doesn't even come close to the AR XA, Thorens TD166MKII, or either Kenwood. If you're more into cartridge swapping than SQ then go for the Technics, otherwise.....

You neglected to mention how that headshell will help with a straight arm, you also forgot to mention how that headshell will help with an even taller cartridge. And neglected to comment on the collet being a possible issue as it is on many AR XA tables, along with all the new members having issues with the collet connection. Which would only be exacerbated by repeatedly disconnecting and reconnecting the headshell over and over again by cartridge swapping like changing underwear.

So no, thank you for making "my" point by ignoring these points and only concentrating on ease of cartridge swapping.

For any noobs looking in reading this thread, it's not a difficult exercise to change cartridges on a fixed headshell. Don't let the type of "headshell" determine what table you purchase, now "that" would be putting a limitation on choice. Just remember, there's a reason most high end arms "don't" have removable headshells.
 
Last edited:
For any noobs reading this post it is more difficult to mount a cart to a fixed headshell tonearm ( difficult to adjust azimuth other than shimming). It's more difficult to align a cart on a straight tonearm (requires a protractor). And, when the fixed headshell TT has no VTA adjustment feature, the TT is limited to carts that are at X height for correct SRA unless the cart or tonearm base can be shimmed. Oh, and better not break a wire on the fixed tonearm, they're not easy to replace. These are facts, facts which make the SL-1200 series TT's very attractive, especially for any enthusiast who enjoys cart substitution. Oh, and don't take any advise from someone who alludes to the SL-1200 series as being a mediocre TT.
 
Last edited:
My td 125 is pushing 45 years if not more and it runs like new with a new belt and a lube job every year. I guarantee there are very few Technics out there that old that have survived. Plus you change arms when ever you like etc etc. But I will say with the right cartridge playing solo LP's of Piano a good Direct drive TT is hard to beat. But I wouldn't choose an early SL 1200. SL 1200 G maybe. SL 1000 for sure. I loved SL 1000 MK II and the MK III was even better. But who can afford a SL 1000R with a SME V tone arm A big Dynavector MC with a pre-preamp. we are talking some money now. Stick with your Thorens.
 
Sure it does, it limits you to a mediocre table with an "S" arm. I have 6 tables here, including a Technics SL1200MKII (actually this table has been moved along, it just didn't make the cut), all the others spank it. Well to be perfectly honest it's about on par with the Mitsubishi DP-EC8, but doesn't even come close to the AR XA, Thorens TD166MKII, or either Kenwood. If you're more into cartridge swapping than SQ then go for the Technics, otherwise.....

You neglected to mention how that headshell will help with a straight arm, you also forgot to mention how that headshell will help with an even taller cartridge. And neglected to comment on the collet being a possible issue as it is on many AR XA tables, along with all the new members having issues with the collet connection. Which would only be exacerbated by repeatedly disconnecting and reconnecting the headshell over and over again by cartridge swapping like changing underwear.

So no, thank you for making "my" point by ignoring these points and only concentrating on ease of cartridge swapping.

For any noobs looking in reading this thread, it's not a difficult exercise to change cartridges on a fixed headshell. Don't let the type of "headshell" determine what table you purchase, now "that" would be putting a limitation on choice. Just remember, there's a reason most high end arms "don't" have removable headshells.
Good lord this is useless information but I’m sure others have cataloged it that way.
 
Back
Top Bottom