• The move to the new server is done. There are some software and database maintenance updates in process. This has us passing the hat around to help out. We appreciate any donations. Seriously, even a dollar helps. The payment page may be found here - https://www.audiokarma.org/support.html

what gin for a great gin and tonic???

Fever Tree is good stuff. They have both a "regular" and a "Mediterranean" tonic, neither of which contain HFCS.

I'm currently using Fever Tree tonics (pricey) with Taaka gin (cheap), key limes instead of regular limes. Works well for me, but then I am of the school that you don't mix premium liquors. It's virtually impossible to enjoy the quality of a premium liquor when it is being overwhelmed by tonic, cola, juice, etc. MPO.

+1 for Fever Tree
The gin gets overwhelmed by the tonic.
 
You can figure out what flavor profile you like and add those ingredients to infuse your own gin. Could turn out to be a fun little project.

Take care,

Rob
 
I use Bendistillery's Crater Lake Gin. It tastes great and they actually use real juniper berries to make it, which I think is fairly rare these days. It isn't particularly pricey either.
 
Fever Tree is good stuff. They have both a "regular" and a "Mediterranean" tonic, neither of which contain HFCS.

I'm currently using Fever Tree tonics (pricey) with Taaka gin (cheap), key limes instead of regular limes. Works well for me, but then I am of the school that you don't mix premium liquors. It's virtually impossible to enjoy the quality of a premium liquor when it is being overwhelmed by tonic, cola, juice, etc. MPO.

My favorite is Blue Sapphire with Tonic. I like Canada Dry Tonic better than Schweppes with no lime. I disagree with mixing lesser gin with tonic. It makes a big difference using Sapphire compared to Beefeater and others. Usually it's about 8-10 bucks more per bottle for the better middle of the road gins like Sapphire & Tanqueray.

I'll search for the Fever Tree tonic. That's a new one for me.

Normally I'm of like mind PM, but with a G&T I tend to agree with Cactus Bob. Lesser gins taste like kerosene (or worse) to me, and I do not enjoy the drink. Have never heard of Fever Tree tonic either. Will definitely be on the lookout for it.
 
Fever Tree is available at most upscale food stores--think Earth Fare, Fresh Market--or better chain groceries. Also on Amazon by the case. Amazon offers free shipping, but you have to order case quantities so you've got a gamble that you'll like it
 
:thmbsp: I use Seagram's Extra Dry Gin for mixes. $9.99/fifth. It tastes pretty good by itself too.

I've read reviews about Barton's gin hitting way above it's $5.49/fifth price but haven't found any on the shelves yet to try it. Have to get my local store to order a bottle for me since the Seagram's bottle is getting low.

A second of the choice of Seagrams's. Makes a fine G&T...plus the bottle has all those weird hieroglyphics to keep you occupied:D
 
A second of the choice of Seagrams's. Makes a fine G&T...plus the bottle has all those weird hieroglyphics to keep you occupied:D

It is a cool bottle. :yes: Non-slip is important when mixing the 3rd round. :D

Went to make a Bloody Sunday Bloody Mary yesterday. Less than an ounce of vodka left. :yikes: Went to use gin instead and found the Seagrams bottle had only slightly more remaining! :tears: Time for a liquor store run. :yes:
 
Sorry guys, I use Kroger diet tonic and just about any gin ( usually Costco brand-Kirkland) and they are just fine for my taste. Problem is I like ‘em too much…
 
Sorry guys, I use Kroger diet tonic and just about any gin ( usually Costco brand-Kirkland) and they are just fine for my taste. Problem is I like ‘em too much…

Just about any bottom shelf gin will work for a G&T, but do not skimp on the Tonic water. Most bargain basement tonic water uses corn syrup as a sweetener. Fever Tree is a good premium brand and if you use concentrated tonic and mix to taste with soda water, that is the best!

My goto tonic is White Rock Tonic. They use sugar and it is no more expensive that CD or schweppes.
 
You gotta be careful with Gin. Many whacky stuff out there, Genever-Dutch Gin, and others aren't London Dry Gin. I found out the hard way a few times, and sad but true, they went down the sink. Stuff like Nolets, no! Or Suntory, no!

"Tanq-Lung" (LOL) is usually the go-to for Gin-Tonic, go with the Ten if it makes you happy.

One time at Sam's Wines-Liquors in the Goose Island area of Chicago, I hit on a London Gin called Bradburns, 94 proof, and $12 a fifth. Best London Gin I ever drank. Went back 3 days later and bought a Case.

And a month later decided again to go back to buy another case, and no more, he couldn't get it.
 
Last edited:
I've had all of them and will say, a bad tonic can ruin a good gin or at the least overwhelm some flavors. If you aren't discerning the differences in the Gin's in your T&T it might be due to the tonic or amount of tonic. Most people swear by Schweppes but there are other good ones out there. A bad tonic can ruin a drink. Regardless of brand taste your tonic first. If it’s too sweet, too medicinal, or too bitter on it's own cut it with club soda until it's not too anything.

FWIW, I like the blue bottle over the green but sometimes go with Hendricks over either. I like the additional flavors in Hendricks and will sometimes forego the lime...and sometimes the tonic ;)
Was going to ask about tonic, which I drink straight for leg cramping.
 
For a G & T, it doesn't really matter as long as it's a decent gin that doesn't taste like shoe polish -- the tonic will obscure a multitude of sins. Only Schweppes will do. Canada Dry is for riff-raff.

The real test for gin is, of course, the martini. I'm a Tanqueray man myself.
 
I’ve tried many, many gins—for G&Ts, martinis (two of my go-to cocktails), and etc. Every gin has a specific flavor and strength. And certain gins remind me of the people I’ve known who love/prefer those brands. So I use different gins for different people/occasions. My wife happens to prefer Tangueray and Schweppes for her G&Ts (what her parents used to drink). I tend to prefer Bombay Sapphire.

However, two weeks ago I was introduced to Botanist gin, with low calorie Fever Tree tonic—which I’ve often used—and it was the best, smoothest G&T I’ve had. Botanist also made a damn fine martini.

P.S. A G&T must be served only with a wedge of lime—not lemon.
 
For a G&T, I use New Amsterdam Stratusphere, with fresh lime juice and a high quality tonic like Q.
 
Back
Top Bottom