malden
Lunatic Member
you mentioned the "dozens" you have built, I have not built anyShow me yours and I'll show you mine
you mentioned the "dozens" you have built, I have not built anyShow me yours and I'll show you mine
would love to see themOf the dozens of large speaker cabinets I have built in my life
No, as an electrical engineer, I consider electronics semi conductors, silicon and germanium based devices, as in transistors, op amps, integrated circuits, microchips etc. Not wire wound inductors and transformers, polypro, electrolytic capacitorscapacitors, resistors and inductors assembled in a circuit are not electronics?
I am not an electrical engineer, but, are tube amplifiers not electronics?No, as an electrical engineer, I consider electronics semi conductors, silicon and germanium based devices, as in transistors, op amps, integrated circuits, microchips etc. Not wire wound inductors and transformers, polypro, electrolytic capacitors
I don't consider them as suchI am not an electrical engineer, but, are tube amplifiers not electronics?
I don't consider them as such

If it makes people feel better..., neither did Hammond. Hammonds had resistors, caps, tubes, and inductors, but were never considered as "electronic" organs, but rather "electric" organs. Actually, all of the early tube organs were considered as such:
That's good to know. Next time my tube amp needs repair, I'll call my electrician buddy to have a look at it. I'm sure he can repair it with his fish-tape, linesman pliers and pipe bender....If it makes people feel better..., neither did Hammond. Hammonds had resistors, caps, tubes, and inductors, but were never considered as "electronic" organs, but rather "electric" organs. Actually, all of the early tube organs were considered as such:

Seriously we are mis-communicating here. ' Electronics' is shorthand for the crossover network plus all the leads to the drivers and the main terminals. I'm taking about a completed speaker system - you can't have an empty cabinet (the absolute cheapest component here even if you build the entire thing out of black walnut/ mahogany/ or curly maple), and you can't have drivers sitting in space, and the drivers aren't very good unless they are connected via an electronic network- i.e. crossover. So go on eBay or reverb today and get the prices of these JBL components (if you can find them): LE10H, LE5-12, 044, and a crossover network n96 or n112 (for either an L96 or L112) the schematics are identical. price all that out , sum it up if you get significantly under $800 today, send me the the links so I too can experience this cheaper to build it experience.We are comparing cabinets and drivers - why are you including electronics? I don't need to kid myself; I have done it and it is cheaper than either new or used and I have no hesitation stating it. But the used would need to be of equivalent excellent quality, but even then you are comparing a used cabinet to a freshly built higher quality DIY. There are a few exceptions to every rule, but if you are comparing to road rashed and abused cabinets then of course!
I know, I know, I'm done. I swear.
Any photos?I dipped my toes into the vintage JBL speaker rabbit hole after watching this YouTube video where Kevin over at Skylabs Audio mentioned how much he really likes JBL 4311s, that video convinced me to investigate, research and go listen to a set of 4311Bs that popped up for sale in my area. My goal wasn't to buy the 'best' speakers, my goal was to buy fully functional iconic vintage speakers from the 70's.
I spent about 2 hours with the original owner seller listening to the speakers while he detailed how much he used and loved the speakers back in the 1900's. Needless to say, I brought those speakers home with me and I know I got a good deal especially when the price I paid is compared with to current asking prices for the same speakers is on ebay, reverb and FB marketplace.
Any photos?
Thanks!![]()



Very nice! Thanks for posting the photos!View attachment 3167314
I guess they are so expensive because a number of people have paid the asking price, so sellers come to expect more from buyers. I am fairly frugal so I do my research, I try and determine what a real world fair price to pay is and negotiate to reach a fair deal that is good for myself and the seller. The seller was asking $1,000, the grilles are missing, the dust caps on the mid-range speakers are dented, the level knobs need a good internal cleaning and the exterior walnut has some beauty marks as well as a layer of tar from cigarette smoke exposure... I paid $600 and both of us are happy with the deal. One oddity, the serial numbers are not even close to each other.
View attachment 3167482View attachment 3167483
On weather the PC or Wheat used is Non GMOWhy are pretzels and popcorn so expensive?![]()
It's only a "rabbit hole" if you continue to collect them.I dipped my toes into the vintage JBL speaker rabbit hole
I've watched a few of his videos. He is a very good salesman but I have not heard anything of substance from him.after watching this YouTube video where Kevin over at Skylabs Audio mentioned how much he really likes JBL 4311s, that video convinced me to investigate,