Woofers comparison

[thegoodnick]

I'm looking for a 8-10 inch woofer that will be working in active separate bass module crossed between 200-600 hz depending on swappable mid-high modules and go down to at least f3 40 hz.
The goal is to achieve fast,musical bass that is dynamic at the lowest listening levels. I guess im looking for a driver that has high Qms , low Qts and low Mms ?
So far i've found following drivers for bass reflex enclosure :
SB Acoustics SB23NRXS45-8 ( paper cone)
SB Acoustics SB23NbACS45-8 = SB23NACS45-8 ( alu cone )
SB Acoustics 8” SB20PFCR30-8 = SB20PFC30-8 ( paper cone )
wavecor WF223BD01/02
SEAS PRESTIGE H1252-08 L22RNX/P
SEAS CA22RNY
SEAS CA22RNX
SEAS L22RN4X/P
Seas CD22RN4X
Dayton Audio RS225P-8
Dayton Audio RS225-8
for sealed enclosure :
SEAS CA26RFX
L26RFX/P
SB_Acoustics 12" SB34NRX75-6
SB_Acoustics 12" SB34NRXL75-8
Peerless SLS 10
DAYTON AUDIO RS270-8 10
Could someone that has exerience with these drivers make a brief comparison between them and tell me which one would be the best ? Im especilly interested in SB23 paper vs aluminum. Also will a bigger and heavier
driver in sealed enclosure have better and faster bass at low volume than lightweight driver in BR enclosure provided they have same f3 ?

 

[turboyam]

You should post this question on; DIYAUDIO forums.