What I would do is find her "hot" button(s) and push them repeatedly until she does something really stupid and make sure you have a witness or a camera on hand.
For example find out when she sleeps and play Barry Manilow or whatever as loud as you can. Put the speakers up to the shared bedroom wall facing the wall and crank it up to 11.
While retaliating with loud music MIGHT work, more likely it would rile her and invite further retaliation and escalation. You don't want to find out what the woman might do, if she got really angry. She's already cut your garden hose and shown that she has no respect for you. Tit-for-tat retaliation also removes you from the moral high ground, which could cost you later on with police, courts, etc...
Try a tone higher than 12kHz, the dogs will hear it, she won't - but she will hear the dogs.
Now this is something that would be harder to prove/detect, and which might work. I'd go a lot higher than 12kHz, though; that is too easily audible. Start closer to 20 hKz, which few people can hear, and slowly drop the frequency each day, until either she shows signs of altered behavior (staying away from home, being even more irritable than usual, etc..). Make sure the sound isn't audible outside your front door, though: if she complains to the police, and they come and hear the sound (while you are away and not able to turn the sound down the way she does), YOU will be seen to be guilty of exactly what she has been doing! Be VERY CAREFUL about engaging in any of this kind of behavior, tempting though it might be.
KingBubba has Arkay proof read your post?
Huh?

What was wrong with his post, that it needed proofreading?
(That was my first reaction to this post.)
Arkay wasn't available, so I had to go it alone. Did I do a good job writing my book?
:lmao: Figured it out! You got an "A" on that book, KingBubba. It was very well written! :thmbsp:
Xlax in hamburger meat works great on the dogs makes them explode before they can get out of the house. &, put powdered cayanne pepper on the bushes and around your area in your yard. Burns the hell otta their nostrils. And it's natural, goes away eventually. I put the crap from my lawn in my neighbors mail box, coarse I warned them first that I would do it. They called the cops and I just said "wasn't me".
Good luck man, I have a stereo baster across the street from me. So I feel your pain.
John
I wouldn't do something like that... but I wonder if you bagged it up in a baggie, put a nice note on it saying something like, "I think this belongs to you; it was left on my property, so I'm just returning it." and left it right in front of her door, she'd get the message? Then again, it might invite retaliation, which could be much worse for you. I'd hate to find sh$t smeared on my doorknobs, etc...
Try all the legal remedies suggested. I'll endorse the idea of keeping a nice, grateful and "innocent harmed victim" attitude when dealing with the police. I had a similar (but perhaps less extreme) problem here with a restaurant/bar that opened on my street, and had people sitting outside talking and laughing loudly late at night, keeping my wife and myself from sleeping.
I complained REPEATEDLY to the police, who eventually realized that there was a problem. They got the Environmental Protection branch of the government involved... who were promptly lied to and ignored by the restaurant owner, who two days after telling them he hadn't been aware of the problem and would be quiet thereafter, put a live saxophonist in the doorway, blaring tunes out into the street! The guy was a connected thug type from a wealthy background, his staff were low-life scums with attitudes like that of the neighbor in this thread, and they weren't going to be easily intimidated.
I considered doing things like secreting stink bombs near their entrance so no one would sit outside and be noisy, but realized that could backfire and get me in trouble, so I took the legal "high road" instead. Besides, although it was the customers making the noise and annoying me, I realized that it wasn't intentional on their part. It was the management's fault for not making them aware that the buildings surrounding them were residential, and people would be sleeping, etc... Most people, if they are aware they are creating a nuisance, will stop. It was the couldn't-care-less landlord and management staff that were the problem. So any actions taken against the customers (I briefly thought about "cooking" them and their table with beamed microwaves...

) wouldn't have been fair. But the owner/managers weren't being helpful, and the noise problem persisted.
About the sixth or tenth time that I went IN PERSON to the police station to politely complain and ask what they could do to help me, one police officer gave me a detailed lesson on how a lot of the system here works. It seems the police have weekly briefings/meetings with the local "town councilor" (rough equivalent term), who is listened to by other government branches. He outlined a strategy for me to get the councilor to lean on the liquor licensing people to not renew the place's liquor license when it came up for renewal, and told me how to ensure that the license people had a chance to see how many complaints had been made, etc... He also told me how to search out technical license violations and lease violations that they might have committed (there was an illegal structure involved, and a couple minor lease violations). It took about two years, but about two months ago, the place finally closed down. It is being re-decorated and will re-open this week under a different owner, as a completely different style of place. This new owner is French (not another local triad thug) and seems reasonable; there were two previous restaurant businesses there, and they always kept their customers quiet. It looks like this guy will, too. He already knows that if he doesn't, I'll make darned sure his license isn't renewed, and his business will be relatively short-lived. Sometimes, the nice, polite velvet club CAN work.