• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Basic External Hard Drive Library Questions

It’s a 2017 Legacy. I’d be using an old iphone (no service) or an even older ipod.
Google tells me that inside the centre console/armrest of your car there should be a USB input / AUX input. From USB your car's media player should support MP3, FLAC, and WAV. It does not support Apple CarPlay.
Yes, you could potentially connect an iPhone's analogue output to the AUX input ... but why? Wouldn't it be more straightforward to plug in a USB flash drive?
 
.
Yes, you could potentially connect an iPhone's analogue output to the AUX input ... but why? Wouldn't it be more straightforward to plug in a USB flash drive?
Apple hasn’t had analog outs in its last 7 model cycles, but a portable Bluetooth module that plugs into the AUX input and is powered by usb drive is a common solution in older cars without Bluetooth for audio.
 
Yeah, I was really referring to the lightning-to-headphone adapter and USB-C-to-headphone adapter, but no matter - there's no need to use an iPhone at all.
j_loop's Subaru Liberty has a direct USB input. Plug in a USB flash drive and you will have full in-dash control.
Here in Australia the police are clamping down on the use of iPhones in cars - they can only legally be used when attached to an on-dash cradle.
 
Out of curiosity why FLAC as opposed to ALAC if you're using a MBP?
Because FLAC is an open standard and ALAC is proprietary to Apple. I use both Windows and MacOS and I hate proprietary formats. Google AI Overview summarizes it well:

"ALAC (Apple Lossless Audio Codec) and FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) both provide identical, high-fidelity, lossless audio quality that compresses files to roughly 50-60% of their original size without losing data. FLAC is the industry standard with superior compatibility and smaller file sizes, while ALAC is proprietary to Apple, making it ideal for the Apple ecosystem."
 
This always causes a stink when I say it, but RAID alone is not synonymous with having a backup.

Nothing against RAID, myself I use a QNAP NAS with two drives, but the NAS backs up to the external WD HDD in the middle.

Ideally, the NAS would back up to something offsite but I have not set up a cloud thing nor offsite backup.
I work in IT so believe me I understand that. I'm also a photographer and music producer on the side and I have years of work backed up to multiple optical disks, SSD external drives, and copies in a climate controlled storage space (although I've fallen behind on the offsite backups) and the music collection specifically is also backed up to a 512 GB SD card and an SSD USB drive. For a drive that is going to be "on" and accessible at all times some form of RAID is essential.
 
The only issue I see is do you plan/need to share your music library with any Mac gear? Mac gear doesn't recognize FLAC, so without conversion to ALAC, you can't share the files to iPhones, iPads, etc. That may not be a problem if your only use is to manage a library for playback to your home audio gear. I can move our iPhones between the 3 cars for music on the move ... lightning to USB cables makes it easy. (2012 Honda Fit, 2000 Honda Civic SI, 1980 Triumph TR8 with a modern radio)

You may not need a RAID, but be sure to do periodic backups. every 3 to 6 months. I do a complete copy of my library to an external drive that is then disconnected.
Usually runs overnight (iTunes folder is currently 1.46TB - a 2TB drive is a good fit).

I keep the most recent 2 backups, just in case an error of some kind appears. I can always copy files directly from the backups to the library if needed. Storage has been relatively cheap these days, but it takes quite a while to rip a large stack of disks to digital/drive form.
Speaking for myself, FLAC files play just fine with multiple different third-party players on MacOS so I don't see an issue there. A quick google search seems to indicate that there are players for iPhone that will play your FLAC library from the cloud (Flacbox is one), but in my case if I'm listening on my iPhone then Spotify is more than good enough so there's no need for FLAC. Hardly anything in my library isn't available on Spotify. If an iPhone is being used as the main player for an audiophile system then it's more of an issue, but I don't see much reason to do that while at home.
 
Because FLAC is an open standard and ALAC is proprietary to Apple. I use both Windows and MacOS and I hate proprietary formats. Google AI Overview summarizes it well:

"ALAC (Apple Lossless Audio Codec) and FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) both provide identical, high-fidelity, lossless audio quality that compresses files to roughly 50-60% of their original size without losing data. FLAC is the industry standard with superior compatibility and smaller file sizes, while ALAC is proprietary to Apple, making it ideal for the Apple ecosystem."
ALAC has broader playability across platforms and the OP has already stated that he's in the Apple ecosystem, where FLAC files don't play natively, except with 3rd party software, whereas, because of the ubiquity of iOS devices, ALAC doesn't have those issues.
 
...Apple has its own proprietary Lossless Codec called ALAC. If one is going to primarily use the Apple ecosystem them just rip straight to ALAC as opposed to FLAC first and then converting to ALAC
As I understand it to play FLAC files on a MAC a user would need a 3rd party app/player such as Audiovarna etc, both FLAC & ALAC are Lossless Audio Codec's" one being Free/open source the other Apple (proprietary)

Not trying to argumentative or anything like that just trying to understand better why your trying to steer the OP in that direction
Because FLAC is an open standard and ALAC is proprietary to Apple. I use both Windows and MacOS and I hate proprietary formats. Google AI Overview summarizes it well:

"ALAC (Apple Lossless Audio Codec) and FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) both provide identical, high-fidelity, lossless audio quality that compresses files to roughly 50-60% of their original size without losing data. FLAC is the industry standard with superior compatibility and smaller file sizes, while ALAC is proprietary to Apple, making it ideal for the Apple ecosystem."
See my previous posts, I'm well aware of what the acronyms stand for as well as open/proprietary

This isn't directed at you personally but the "AI Overview" part you highlighted is contradictory with regards to file sizes.
 
Last edited:
I was a systems engineer for data centers for 20 years.

RAID is not a backup. Full Stop.

RAID is primarily used for ensuring data availability (no down time) in the event of a disk failure. But it is not a backup.

A backup needs to be a separate storage device. RAID 1, also known as disk mirroring, is the constant/continuous syncing and updating a second disk to the primary. Whatever happens to the primary happens to the secondary disk. If the primary disk fails, the secondary takes over. But if there is file system corruption, or user error (accidental deletions is just one example), then that happens to secondary. It is not a backup.
 
Last edited:
I was a systems engineer for data centers for 20 years.

RAID is no a backup. Full Stop.

RAID is primarily used for ensuring data availability (no down time) in the event of a disk failure. But it is not a backup.

A backup needs to be a separate storage device. RAID 1, also known as disk mirroring, is the constant/continuous syncing and updating a second disk to the primary. Whatever happens to the primary happens to the secondary disk. If the primary disk fails, the secondary takes over. But if there is file system corruption, or user error (accidental deletions is just one example), then that happens to secondary. It is not a backup.
No one said that RAID is a backup. Did you see my post above where I referred to backing my original work up to multiple optical discs, SD cards, and SSD drives, and having a copy in an offsite storage space? I said that RAID is essential if a drive is always "on." In a home environment, the other critical reason to use RAID is that mechanical drives fail, so if one drive in the array fails you don't lose your data. In that sense (with a NAS running at home), it's similar to a backup because your data is mirrored to two drives. I use an 8-bay Synology DiskStation that presents as 4 drives. Less critical files are at least protected if one drive mechanically fails.
 
Last edited:
the other critical reason to use RAID is that mechanical drives fail, so if one drive in the array fails you don't lose your data. In that sense (a NAS running at home), it's similar to a backup because your data is mirrored to two drives.
This is not intended as personal critique more as a "why I said something". The quoted part in bold is type of thing that, IMO, trips up folks less familar with such things.

You know exactly what you mean, but others interpret "similar to a backup" as being like a backup in a more literal sense. Yup, their problem not yours, but is why I and a couple others are usually quick to try differentiating RAID from backup when it comes up. :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
This is not intended as personal critique more as a "why I said something". The quoted part in bold is type of thing that, IMO, trips up folks less familar with such things.

You know exactly what you mean, but others interpret "similar to a backup" as being like a backup in a more literal sense. Yup, their problem not yours, but is why I and a couple others are usually quick to try differentiating RAID from backup when it comes up. :thumbsup:
I guess I can see how someone could misunderstand that.
 
My tentative plan unless there’s a good reason why not:

Buy an external hard drive. Format it to exFat. Load a few albums on it (xld or itunes or both?). Try different software for playback. Using iTunes or anything on the mini (relying on free trials) seems straight forward more or less (I hope), but getting the raspberry running requires a whole new skill set for me. FYI it’s a raspberry 400 which is a keyboard with the guts within and a few USB and mini hdmi ports.

My hope is that different playback software will recognize the albums and I can test them on the mini. Hopefully I can get Lyrian running on the raspberry, but with my work schedule it might be a while and I might need some hand-holding.
 
My tentative plan unless there’s a good reason why not:

Buy an external hard drive. Format it to exFat. Load a few albums on it (xld or itunes or both?). Try different software for playback. Using iTunes or anything on the mini (relying on free trials) seems straight forward more or less (I hope), but getting the raspberry running requires a whole new skill set for me. FYI it’s a raspberry 400 which is a keyboard with the guts within and a few USB and mini hdmi ports.

My hope is that different playback software will recognize the albums and I can test them on the mini. Hopefully I can get Lyrian running on the raspberry, but with my work schedule it might be a while and I might need some hand-holding.
Re: getting the Raspberry running - if you haven't been using ChatGPT or one of the other AI platforms, just prompting them with exactly what you want to do will return exact step by step instructions including code and scripts.
 
Yes, don't take on a rPi build unless you have good existing knowledge of command line configuration, or are a determined learner prepared to spend considerable time and effort.
piCorePlayer has a remote configuration GUI which makes the setup of Lyrion/Squeezelite easier, but still not easy.
Yes, using your Mac Mini is a good idea, at least for now.

Try different software for playback. Using iTunes or anything on the mini
iTunes is a bit clunky, and I understand it may do some audio resampling, which is not good for hifi purposes. As I mentioned in post #10 foobar2000,VLC, or JustPlay would be better, IMO.
All of these are controlled directly from the Mac Mini's keyboard, mouse, & monitor. If you later wish to progress to full remote client control on your iPad, then it's time to install Lyrion and Squeezelite on the Mac Mini.

Buy an external hard drive. Format it to exFat
Does your Mac Mini have a good sized internal drive, say, 1TB or more? Then use that as primary library storage. You can copy music files back and forth between your various computers via network file access.
Now the only need for an external drive is for your car ... and be careful, I believe only the top model car media players support exFAT. The basic models, which I believe you have, support only FAT32. Next problem - FAT32 is only officially supported on drives up to 64GB capacity. There are various tricks and third-party applications which will format larger drives with FAT32, but for now I suggest you just test playback in your car with a cheap, small-capacity USB flash drive.
 
Thinking (once more) about putting my cds on an external hard drive

...Does your Mac Mini have a good sized internal drive, say, 1TB or more? Then use that as primary library storage.
Great question and hopefully helpful going forward, I would add how many CD's are you considering adding?

To give you an idea

My 2011 MacMini which is primarily used for Music storage and playback has 500GB of storage and I'm only at about 208GB currently.

Hopefully the more knowledgeable can share how much the avg CD takes up space wise if ripped in either LAC
 
Last edited:
OK, if we assume an average album duration of 45 minutes, losslessly compressed with FLAC or ALAC at a conservative 40% file-size saving, that would result in 290 MB per album.
Thus you could fit around 1700 albums on a 500GB drive.
 
I just got mine set up. After spending the better part of a week trimming a lot of fat, throwing out duplicate files and recordings I'll never listen to, I've got a solid 40k songs, about half of them ripped between 2001-2006 in MP3, another 25% in lossy MP4 and 25% or about 250 discs in Alac on 500mb removable drives, ice SSD I'm using and 2 additional 2.5" ATA optical drives for backup. my partner got a new MacBook Pro M4 last summer, then had compatibility issues with her office server and VPN, so had to get a windows laptop for work, so I've got that set up as a server. It didn't take too long to set Plex up, although the software wasn't entirely intuitive, requiring Plex Server software, as well as Plex Amp to control it remotely on my personal laptop, iPhone and iPad and it needed a $6.99 per month paid subscription, (or $69.99 per year and $250, outright) to unlock the features like streaming to multiple devices, like my WiiM Pro that's in my secondary system or my car, as well as playlist creation tools. It's worth it not to give money to Tim Apple... and it works really well. my next step will be to replace all of the MP3 files, which will be time consuming and costly, but they sound like dog doo, so it will be worth it.

Did I mention it works really well? The algorithms don't know me yet, so I'll have to depend on friends and YouTube for new music discovery, but that's fine. I'm really pleased with how it's working.
 
I rip using windows media player in lossless. I store all of my audio & movie rips on a Synology server. All of the media players I’ve owned can connect. I also have plex running that serves up everything.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1640.jpeg
    IMG_1640.jpeg
    147.9 KB · Views: 7
Back
Top Bottom