• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Best midrange ever? Worst?!

Wow, I am surprised that ADS hasn't gotten more attention in this thread. I have found all the ADS speakers I've heard to have beautiful mid-range response - the L400 (both versions), L-710, L500. I honestly don't think it can be beat at the price point.

I also give a vote to my AV123 LS6 line source speakers that each have eight 6.5" cone woofers and six modified Graebner Neo-8 mid/tweeters. These sound fantastic to me, at all ranges.

Great info on this thread BTW. I appreciate the technical discussions, even if I can't always follow them. I'm working my way through the Master Handbook of Acoustics, so eventually I'll understand it all! muahahaha

Not very-familiar with their home speakers, but I was a huge fan of their car-stereo component-speakers. I think they were around $500 a pair, give or take. They had extremely-smooth, yet vibrant and transparent mids. Best-sounding car-separates you could buy at the local Tweeter chain. IMO, better-sounding and more-transparent that the Boston Pro series.
 
Mids in the Symphonies are to die for. May have to do with proper integration with the woofers, which are special and unique. Also had better luck with Warfedales than B & W, based on SQ...B & W are great looking though.

:yes::D


'Great-looking'..... That's funny.

Yeah, I haven't heard a pair of Symphonies in a long, long time, but they were awesome. I used to go to this hi-end place in Hartford, CT that carried the big boys, and I loved auditioning the Symphonies and Concert Grands (I think they actually used the CG's in one of the big auditoriums in the area - Can't remember if it was the Bushnell or somewhere else, but you can look at them and imagine them pumping out that big sound in a huge auditorium somewhere - Those things had some serious beef for such a refined speaker). I love the huge bottom-end that you get from speakers like the Symphs and C.G.'s. It's BIG bass. LIFELIKE bass. Not boomy, unnatural. That's the kind of bottom-end response I'm ultimately-looking to get.

BTW, I was referring to NEW B&W's and ones from the early to mid '90's, just to be clear (driven by modern amps, which may have a lot to do with it as well - I wonder how they would have sounded with an early '70's Sansui amp/receiver). Not sure how a pair of vintage ones would stack up. But the B&W's I've heard from the last 15 years just didn't do it for me - not enough to bump the Wharfedales.
 
Last edited:
best I ever heard was from a pair of Wolverine LT12. They were mounted in a huge enclosures, still had no bass but the mids were pretty nice.
 
As mentioned a few times in this thread, Quad Electrostats.

And you can get high SPLs and bass....if you sit them on Gradient bipolar subwoofers.
 
The Accuton that they use in the Avalon Eidelon speakers. I'd bet both testicles you could fool a blind man with those things.
 
The Accuton that they use in the Avalon Eidelon speakers. I'd bet both testicles you could fool a blind man with those things.

The Accuton is pretty good, I've heard several speakers that use them, but I like the Radio Shack 1.5 inch close-outs from about 15 years ago even better.

Here's a picture of a line array which uses them just to the right of the kneeling Sir Byrd (red/orange shirt):
DSC_0024-6.jpg


Best Regards,
TerryO
 
Last edited:
I've heard some decent 3 way speakers but in many instances for average home use I'm preferring a 2-way. If you havent heard an original Energy 22, you need to, they may change your mind about 2-way systems.
 
Multi-way speakers create room related problems and they tend not to sound integrated or cohesive - nothing really beats a single driver. Quad electrostats, Teresonic Ingenium and Zu Audio Essence come to mind. But they also have problems with frequency extremes and dynamics and layering because it seems to me they have some compression entering into the equation and they lose important impact. 2 ways help but few integrate well enough at the listening position. The best midrange speaker never really makes sense - for me it comes to down to the speaker that makes instruments sound like the real thing and are not sounding "hi-fi" in the sense of gutting musiality for hyper-detail. So a speaker may push a voice back or bring it forward and that doesn't bother me as much as a speaker that doesn't allow the body of the instrument to be present. (which is why I am not a fan of Magenepan or the apogees I've heard in the sense that while I like some Magnepans for what they do well - they don't make instruments sound like the real thing and the ribbon sound is always present).

The best speakers regardless of amount of drivers shape and cover enough frequency spectrum to be believable are at various price points

Audio Note E/J/K/AX Two
Silbatone Aporia Full Range
Acapella High Violoncello II
Usher Be 10
Trenner and Freidl RA Box
Gallo 3.5
Reference 3a Grand Veena
Harbeth 40, SHL5
Teresonic Ingenium
ATC SCM 150
Studio Electric T3
Sony SS-AR1
Acoustic Zen Crescendo
Roksan Kandy TR-5
King Sound Prince II (Electrostats)
Quad 2905
Linn Majik 140
Zu Audio Essence

From the list above it covers a big range of design types - I could live with the above.

Though I prefer speakers that can be run from 300B SETs so unfortunately that hacks off a large portion of the above.
 
Best midrange and all around speaker I've owned is the Carver Amazing Loudspeaker. Magnepan SMG a very close second ((sounds slightly better through the midrange until you really listen to them a long time) kind of colored and forward in comparison).
 
Last edited:
Best: Quad ESL 57, JBL 1400 Array, Martin Logan Cinema, Sonus Faber Cremona, B&W 801, IMF TLS 80
Worst: Klipsh KLF20
 
Last edited:
I've heard some decent 3 way speakers but in many instances for average home use I'm preferring a 2-way. If you havent heard an original Energy 22, you need to, they may change your mind about 2-way systems.

I've been enjoying my Pro-22's since I bought them new in 1982. I couldn't agree more. When you get it right, these speakers disapear and all that's left is the music. It wasn't untill I connected them up to a New Bryson Amp and much better sources 27 years later did I have a clue as to the potential of The Pro-22's.

In a simple A/B comparison with my 27 year newer Energy RC-30 Towers using my very good sounding (as in toss up with my NAD Preamp/Tuner) Onkyo AVR, aside from more bass extension of the Pro-22's they sounded pretty close. Switching the two speakers on the Bryson Set-up however makes it clear the Pro-22's are in a different leauge. Imaging/Soundstage, inner detail, bass definition are all improve quite dramatically. The RC-30's too improved a lot, especially the bass, but not to near the same extent. I would love to hear a pair with new X-over parts, and a fresh charge of Ferrofluid in the tweeter.
 
Last edited:
The 22's are well known for revealing upstream faults. I tried mine on a lightweight surround amp and they sounded horrible! But feed them with quality and do they sing nice.

I have no idea what stage of life my tweeters are in, whether the fluid is gone, or not but I trust my ears and dont believe these need a rebuild. There must be some telltale signs if the tweeters are not working proper. Until I hear funny sounds from them or they quit I'll be keeping them as is.

I find so many 3 way systems too bright in the middle but a well designed 2 way seems more balanced.
 
Lately, I've been wondering if good midrange-response on my main speakers (below) is a product of the midwoofer itself, a product of ALL drivers, or a combination of both. The 5" midwoofs on my speakers sound great, but I get the feeling that the great mids are a result of the 12.5" woofer, 5" midwoofer, and the mylar dome-tweeter all interacting with each other to create an image with a great mid-band. Don't know. I like 'em though.
 
a well designed 2 way speaker seems more balanced.
.....a well designed 2-way speaker with the type of crossover that has steep slopes, allows the two elements of the enclosure to speak as "one voice" that is audibly seamless....but, since the woofers in 2-ways are usually limited in size to six or eight inches, maybe even a couple of fives, high-bass is usually all you get....drive a pair of quality subs under 2-way speakers in the front soundstage, and you can be VERY pleased with the results, imo.....
 
The 904TI in my JBL PT800's. 4" titanium, rubber surround, inverted dome, pistonic drive with cast aluminum frame.

96875.jpg


Back side.

attachment.php
 
Back
Top Bottom