• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Best midrange ever? Worst?!

Could be some form of spacial isolation is a key to Mid performance?

Similar pics.
Showing a side-view of the unique(?) Dahlquist baffle-mounted ported midrange on the DQ-12 and DQ-20i, which contain Vifa C13MH-08 mids.

The Magnat-rebranded DQM-9 and 9c look like this cylinder-enclosed mid, but are all internal to the cab--and no ported hole in the back of the mid enclosure.

Course the Bozak Symphonies have the Bozak 6" coated Aluminum mid in a separate, sealed hemisphere chamber.

My Infinity 2000A E-stat hybrid has a Phillips paper mid with a whizzer cone.
Strange looking, but how do you keep up with E-stat tweeters?
Internal isolation cylinder in there too!

Polk Monitor 7's seem to have a 6" ultralight poly dome, the butyl surround probably outweighs it...
Instead of isolating mids (like my DQs and Bozaks), these are linked to a larger passive radiator. Very different approach than my Advent 3002's to achieve good imaging. The Polks midrange is superior, don't know about the lows.


Susurus
 
i have a custom built pair using emminence 15" woofs, t-35 tweets, and a pair of audax pr17hr70 mids. the surrounds are gone and one cone is damaged, yet these still deliver outstanding midrange. i have been told that this is the perfect midrange. it's response is essentially flat from 80 to 5000 hz. even with no surrounds and cone damage, the audax mids keep going after the woofers start to complain.
 
Linkwitz Pluto and Rogers LS3/5a's. Haven't updated my Linkwitz Orions to the 3.2.1 version yet but reports on it are quite good.
 
I kinda favor my ML CLSZ2:D...but one of these days I am going to build a 3-way with the new BG Neo 10. (with Fountek CD2 ribbon on top and woofers TBD). I have used the Seas W18e series and have heard the Seas w22 and IMHO they are as good as any Accuton I have heard.
 
Curious, the review I posted said that -60db is .1%, were they wrong?
Nope, it's correct. That's Amplitude Ratio as a percentage, the standard in loudspeaker measuring. Many people accidentally use Power ratio which gives seemingly more impressive numbers, which is never used in loudspeaker design. Reminds me of when people used to plot the phase component of a speaker's impedance upside down with capacitive on top and inductive below. It's been standardized and inductance must always be on top.
I'm going to have to read up on how Zaph is testing for comparison, but @ ~90 dB/1M yesterday, JBL 2452H-SL was down 60 dB (0.0001% THD) and BMS 4555 down 50 dB (0.001%) uncompensated on PT-D95HF in KLH-6.

From 1.2 kHz upward, they're both down at least 40 dB (0.01% THD).

THD raised +30 dB:

I don't know if that sucks by comparison or not, but Geddes says I can't hear it anyway.

I should crank 'em up, maybe.... ;)

Representing THD percentage as a measurement by calculation of Power ratio cannot be compared to other loudspeaker measurement's percentages. This should not be confused with the preferred and long -time industry standard of Amplitude Ratio as used in loudspeaker design. Both are valid ways of expressing THD as a percent but in audio transducer related engineering we use Amplitude ratio. -40dB is actually 1.0% THD, -50dB is 0.316, -60dB is 0.1%, -65dB is 0.0562, -70dB is 0.0316. So, when we hear of a manufacturer that has a new speaker averaging 0.1%, we know the distortion is down -60dB.
This can be confirmed by any speaker manufacturer or designer, Duntech, Event's Opal, Quad, and others are all Amplitude ratios converted to percentages, Bowers & Wilkins Diamond 800 for example has 2nd and 3rd harmonics less than 1% in the range of 45Hz to 100kHz, and less than 0.5% from 80Hz to 100kHz as stated on their website. That translates into -40dB and -46dB, right on target with the actual measurements. I use the dB when I post graphs elseware rather than a percent value to help reduce chances of ambiguous interpretation.
 
Last edited:
Very interesting read, this thread. Lots of favorites to be sure with many listed that do indeed have excellent midrange qualities. This is a very personal thing of course so with that in mind I will say that I would put my double set of PL Andromeda III's into the mix here. With a total of eight 4" mid and eight 8" mid bass drivers, when it comes to an acoustic guitar, piano or the human voice, they will blow you away and then bring you back again. And they ain't too shabby on other instrumentation either..............

Whomever doubts this is welcome to stop by for a listen. You pay for gas of course............Ha!

Happy Holidays to everyone.........Terry:music::thmbsp:
 
Since Yours Truly started this thread 2.5 years ago, I've heard a lot of mids. Some great some well :no:.

So I have a different list.

Anybody else change opinions in that time?

.
 
Agree that electrostatic or 2 way designs or {woofer assisted} fullranges can do it pretty well too, but if I limit myself to 'midrange drivers' and my actual experience;

Best
18sound 6nd430
lores.jpg

Sounded gorgeous in a big 'studio monitor' style enclosure, I've also seen some great 4 way (and one 5 way) horndesigns with these.

Worst
Beyma 8AG/N (actually a FR driver, but it can't do bass or real high frequencies)
BEY-1112456.jpg

But.. It still has it's use.
 
Perception of music is a biological/neurological process. Our ears and cochleas are not ideal flatline freq analizers. Test yours.

Speech has vowels - often 400-1000Hz, plus consonants, often 2000-5000.

The Fletcher-Munson curves appear to mirror this speech/highest hearing range theory; two peaks. Most critical xover point? In between those.

But how about the other animals in your house?
Infrasonic sub for Pidgeons, plasma tweeter for bats?

----

Hearing ranges:

Atlantic bottlenose dolphin
(Tursiops truncatus)
75-150 000 Hz

Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
30-28 000 Hz

Human (Homo sapiens)
20-20 000 Hz

Domestic cat (Felis catus)
45-64 000 Hz

Eastern grey kangaroo (Macropus giganteus)
2500-30 000 Hz

Pigeon (Columba livia)
0.05 -10 000 Hz

Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
30-8000 Hz

Greater horseshoe bat
(Rhinolophus ferrumequinum)
2000-110 000 Hz

Asian elephant (Elephas maximus)
16-1000 Hz

Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
40-40 000 Hz


Susurus

Well if this test is accurate I can BARELY hear 12khz. I would assume I can't hear anything above that at all. I can however hear all the way to 30hz. I guess super tweeters aren't required in my system but a subwoofer is.

By the way, the LaScala midrange is the best that I have heard. Piano and wind instruments are amazing on these.
 
One caveat on that test...if you play it on an average sound card through tiny single-driver plastic computer speakers that only hint above 12K or below 60, you'll get false readings. Better to burn freq. selections to a CD and go through a 'real stereo' at your normal music listening levels. :yes:

No, I don't believe advertised frequency response of these computer speakers...even ones with subs. Garbage test equipment in, garbage data out.
 
Last edited:
Worst midrange, toss up between Dylan and Tom Waits. Big fan of both. I'm sure there others. :D

A good fullranger, like Fostex. The Polk SDA series gets my vote.
 
Wow- talk about a thread that keeps on going. I'll jump in - my BA A70's have some pretty smooth and sweet mids. KLH Model 20's are no slouch either.
 
Agree that electrostatic or 2 way designs or {woofer assisted} fullranges can do it pretty well too, but if I limit myself to 'midrange drivers' and my actual experience;

Best
18sound 6nd430
lores.jpg

Sounded gorgeous in a big 'studio monitor' style enclosure, I've also seen some great 4 way (and one 5 way) horndesigns with these.

Worst
Beyma 8AG/N (actually a FR driver, but it can't do bass or real high frequencies)
BEY-1112456.jpg

But.. It still has it's use.

I once used that Beyma driver in a full-range design - my choice for "worst ever" too.
 
Well if this test is accurate I can BARELY hear 12khz. I would assume I can't hear anything above that at all. I can however hear all the way to 30hz.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~snip~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Evidently my hearing is just about perfect.
I can hear most of the music, and according to a local authority, nothing my wife says!
:music:

Best Regards,
TerryO
 
Best I've heard? Well I haven't heard as many as most of you guys but from my experience:
Dayton DC50F-8 2" Dome Midrange

Worst:
Technics SB8 midrange.

sb-8.jpg


It's the only midrange I've heard that manages to make my favorite songs hurt my ears. I actually have a to do list, and one of the items on it is to figure out why they sound so bad.
 
Back
Top Bottom