The post I gave previously directs to another thread. Here is the text:
#25
opc is offline opc Canada
diyAudio Member
opc's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Default BG notch filter
Hey Guys,
I was just playing around with a pair of NEO8 drivers tonight and discovered a few things about the published notch filter in the BG datasheet.
I mounted the NEO8 in a 9"x 12" baffle and took some raw measurements. After that I connected the suggested notch filter and took another measurement. From what I can see the notch filter is nowhere near the frequency it needs to be at. It had a mild effect between about 5-10kHz, but did nothing for the 12K bump.
I started from scratch and designed a parallel notch for 12kHz with a passband of 5kHz. The values I came up with are as follows:
R = 15 ohm
C = 2.4 uF (two 4.7uF in series)
L = 0.06mH (used 0.56)
I took a third measurement with the new filter and it was spot on. The 12kHz bump is gone completely, and the rising output starting at 2kHz was also tamed somewhat. I'll attach the three measurements for reference. All measurements were gated and were made in SW with and ECM8000 microphone and M-audio sound card. No smoothing was applied.
Has anyone else noticed this about the published notch? To be honest, I have no idea how they came up with the values listed in the whitepaper. If anyone has used the BG notch successfully and taken measurements, I'd love to see them to compare. The ribbon sounds about 10 times better with the proper notch on it, the aggressive top end is much more relaxed now, and the ssss hissing on females vocals is gone too. There might be hope for these things yet!
All the best,
Owen
Attached Thumbnails
Bohlender Graebener Ribbons-plots.jpg