• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Bohlander-Graebner Planars

The post I gave previously directs to another thread. Here is the text:

#25
opc is offline opc Canada
diyAudio Member

opc's Avatar

Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Default BG notch filter
Hey Guys,

I was just playing around with a pair of NEO8 drivers tonight and discovered a few things about the published notch filter in the BG datasheet.

I mounted the NEO8 in a 9"x 12" baffle and took some raw measurements. After that I connected the suggested notch filter and took another measurement. From what I can see the notch filter is nowhere near the frequency it needs to be at. It had a mild effect between about 5-10kHz, but did nothing for the 12K bump.

I started from scratch and designed a parallel notch for 12kHz with a passband of 5kHz. The values I came up with are as follows:

R = 15 ohm
C = 2.4 uF (two 4.7uF in series)
L = 0.06mH (used 0.56)

I took a third measurement with the new filter and it was spot on. The 12kHz bump is gone completely, and the rising output starting at 2kHz was also tamed somewhat. I'll attach the three measurements for reference. All measurements were gated and were made in SW with and ECM8000 microphone and M-audio sound card. No smoothing was applied.

Has anyone else noticed this about the published notch? To be honest, I have no idea how they came up with the values listed in the whitepaper. If anyone has used the BG notch successfully and taken measurements, I'd love to see them to compare. The ribbon sounds about 10 times better with the proper notch on it, the aggressive top end is much more relaxed now, and the ssss hissing on females vocals is gone too. There might be hope for these things yet!

All the best,
Owen
Attached Thumbnails
Bohlender Graebener Ribbons-plots.jpg
 
I received the drivers today... they are beauties! Only had time to hang them in my no-baffle frames (had to leave for night shift). Components for the notch filter are due tomorrow or Thursday.
 
I have a pair of line source speakers, each with six Graebner Neo8s, plus eight 6" woofers. They sound amazing. 8 ohms and 91db efficient so can be driven with just about any amp. I haven't heard really good ribbon or electrostatics, but I think that planars might have the benefits without the drawbacks.
 
I have a pair of line source speakers, each with six Graebner Neo8s, plus eight 6" woofers. They sound amazing. 8 ohms and 91db efficient so can be driven with just about any amp. I haven't heard really good ribbon or electrostatics, but I think that planars might have the benefits without the drawbacks.

LS6's?
 
They're up and running... OUTSTANDING!!! I'm using the 12k notch as described by the DIY poster and another broader notch throughout the mid-range, with a variable resistor (L-pad terminals 1 & 2) so I can tweak the overall signature of the Neo8.

Think I'm done building speakers **for a while**


WHEN AMPZILLA SPEAKS, PEOPLE LISTEN
 
Them's the ones!

As an owner of Infinity QLS-1's those Ls6's are of great interest to me. I don't want to hijack the OP's thread because he has a very cool thing going on here with the BG's, but I'd love to hear about those. Maybe start a thread about them here in speakers or in the modern forum.

- Michael
 
They're up and running... OUTSTANDING!!! I'm using the 12k notch as described by the DIY poster and another broader notch throughout the mid-range, with a variable resistor (L-pad terminals 1 & 2) so I can tweak the overall signature of the Neo8.

Think I'm done building speakers **for a while**


WHEN AMPZILLA SPEAKS, PEOPLE LISTEN

Please tell us what you're hearing after you've spent a little time with them. Comparisons to other designs would be great.

- Michael
 
Well, for starters I'm not hearing Full-range shoutiness anymore. I fought that battle and lost. The waterfall plot for the Neo8's is AMAZING; nothing past .5 millisecs. and what little is there is way down in level. These things are on par with electrostats.

Highly recommended.
 
They lack the tiniest bit of air at the very top. I have some EMITS I've used as dog whistles in the past with good results; I think I'll mount them and cap 'em in at 18k or so.

Woof.
 
So, reviving an old thread, 4 years later... BG products still available at Parts Express. Are these now readily available or does anyone know if this is just old stock and when its gone, its gone for good?
 
BG was bought by Christie Digital. It took them a couple of years before they began releasing NEO planar drivers to the DIY community again. So, what Parts Express is now selling, is supposed to be newly manufactured. Testing at DIY Audio seems to confirm at least, that the new stock tests the same as old stock. As such, I would think it would be safe to buy the drivers again.
 
The back covers of the B&G Neo 3's are removable so they will work in open baffles. Really nice sounding tweeters and the new ones are the same as the originals.

P2060001.JPG
 
Poultrygeist, you seem to have a wonderful range and variety of OB speakers. I'd love to read a break-down of which speakers you currently use, and their drivers. Plus, I'm curious if they have passive or active crossovers? OB speakers are definitely a design that I'm interested in trying. OB and line array speakers keep calling me, and I think I need to address that soon! :idea: :agree:
 
Back
Top Bottom