• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

damping factor, that important?

I don't suppose there is any vested interest in Crown's promotion of extremely high DF vs. what seems to be an independent assessment?

Note again the article didn't dismiss the possibility of an audible difference between low DF and high DF amps. Just that it's not really the cone motion damping part, it's the higher output impedance of an amp (lower DF) interacting with the impedance swings of the speaker causing changes to the FR of the system.
 
Ok whats mine.....? I THINK I voice my opinion so that some how I can educate myself....because I am not an audio engineer.... and looking for data that I may or may not agree with in the end....

That is my vested interest..... and I am sticking to it.

Not unless you are suggesting that I am comparing the size of my "thing"....in that case I win by a mile and its not even close..... :D

jk
 
But I agree totally with crown's doc....with the addition of how mechanical properties of the speaker may affect the results....

Well, I'm also an EE, but I find the Crown article interesting, but troubling. I find their explanations incomplete.

Now, they do a good job explaining "ringing" and how damping should control this "unwanted" cone motion.

They further talk about back EMF and how it helps control the ringing; that is, by being 180 degrees out of phase and being feed back into the amp.

What's incomplete is they assume the back EMF gets to the amp unattenuated. They completely ignore the LP coil in series with the woofers that is fairly high impedance (at least compared to speaker cables).

Now look, if we have a motor (ringing voice coil) and we want to damp it (slow it down), the way to do that would be to "load it" (i.e. have a very, very low resistance). This is E Science 101.

Well that coil is anything but a low resistance and allows the motor to "ring" and to dissipate energy fairly unencumbered. That coil will also change the phase relationship as the signal that "gets to the amp" will no longer be exactly 180 degrees out of phase.

Only when the coil is removed (as in powered subs or active bi-amp), will the amp ever experience the back EMF. Now, in all fairness to Crown they sold a number of professional amps where speakers are driven strictly in "active" mode. Sooo, maybe for their business their explanation is accurate. I don't know.

Electrical damping, however, is NOT the only way to control cone movement as jk reminds us in his post. "mechanical" methods also come into play. For example, the trapped air in an acoustic suspension system can create enormous drag on a large cone.

Regards,
Jerry
 
Great read! Very interesting, but not convincing, I'm still not convinced it is just hype. High dampening amps have always produced tighter bass, in my experience. I owned a pair of Green Mountain Audio Continuum 1's, and driven by a McIntosh 2100 the bass was fine, but when I switched to a high current amp with a high dampening factor, I could here the bass players fingers pluck the string and the decay of that string. Specs are specs, but music reproduction is my goal.
Regards,
Jim

Regards,
Jim
 
.....the Guy who built/assembled my speakers and made the crossovers from scratch, said to me one time, "a higher damping-factor has more control of the voice-coils"....I don't know, but my MC2105 with a damping-factor of 10, renders tube-like performance from the speakers....is tube-like performance from solid-state equated with a note being allowed to sweetly ring longer?....

Synergy is the key that opens the door. IMHO

Regards,
Jim
 
Yea, maybe I don't totally agree with them to the extent that they take it....

But A tube amp should not be used with set of F's.....and DF of 1000....that might be over kill.....

Funny thing... I know one of the original designers of the OHM Fs, he swears by early Crown Amps from the 70s for the F.... I will have to dig up the specs for vintage Crown amps.....

But I agree they did a good job of putting it into plain English.....which I always gravitate towards... The math and science are always important, but I find it to be useless unless they help me create a mental image or plain English explanation of what is going on....

After all, this is what good engineering is about....taking the pure science and making it real for the rest of us humans.....

Maybe we should talk about DF in ranges.....?

Tube amp 10 to 30....

Low Control SS 30 to 100 ?

Medium Control 100 to 200 ?

High Control 200 to 500 ?

Ultra Control > 500 ?

Hows that for a brain fart.....?

jk



Well, I'm also an EE, but I find the Crown article interesting, but troubling. I find their explanations incomplete.

Now, they do a good job explaining "ringing" and how damping should control this "unwanted" cone motion.

......................................................

Electrical damping, however, is NOT the only way to control cone movement as jk reminds us in his post. "mechanical" methods also come into play. For example, the trapped air in an acoustic suspension system can create enormous drag on a large cone.

Regards,
Jerry
 
.....WhoArU, I don't know why, but I thought Crown had something to do with QSC amps....I know there's a lot of happy QSC owners.....

I am a happy QSC owner, and Crown too.

Behringer's EP2500 is a cheap, but useful, imitation of the QSC RMX 2450. Maybe that's it?
 
syn⋅er⋅gy   /ˈsɪnərdʒi/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [sin-er-jee] Show IPA Pronunciation –noun, plural -gies.

1. combined action or functioning; synergism.

.....Ehoove, do you mean the synergy created by the correct combination of components and speakers is what brings the tube-like/life-like performance?.....

C'mon guys...synergy; n. - the amount of energy generated when one is engaged in sin (or "syn" as the Greeks spell it)...the greater the sin...the greater the synergy.:D
 
Well, I'm also an EE, but I find the Crown article interesting, but troubling. I find their explanations incomplete.

Now, they do a good job explaining "ringing" and how damping should control this "unwanted" cone motion.

They further talk about back EMF and how it helps control the ringing; that is, by being 180 degrees out of phase and being feed back into the amp.

What's incomplete is they assume the back EMF gets to the amp unattenuated. They completely ignore the LP coil in series with the woofers that is fairly high impedance (at least compared to speaker cables).

Now look, if we have a motor (ringing voice coil) and we want to damp it (slow it down), the way to do that would be to "load it" (i.e. have a very, very low resistance). This is E Science 101.

Well that coil is anything but a low resistance and allows the motor to "ring" and to dissipate energy fairly unencumbered. That coil will also change the phase relationship as the signal that "gets to the amp" will no longer be exactly 180 degrees out of phase.

Only when the coil is removed (as in powered subs or active bi-amp), will the amp ever experience the back EMF. Now, in all fairness to Crown they sold a number of professional amps where speakers are driven strictly in "active" mode. Sooo, maybe for their business their explanation is accurate. I don't know.

Electrical damping, however, is NOT the only way to control cone movement as jk reminds us in his post. "mechanical" methods also come into play. For example, the trapped air in an acoustic suspension system can create enormous drag on a large cone.

Regards,
Jerry

I totally agree. Complicating it is that if the woofer inline inductor reactance (XL) at ringing frequency is significantly higher than the nominal DC resistance (R) as determined by the amplifier's DF value, the phase angle of the returned voltage will lead the true error voltage, in greater amounts as the frequency of the energy to be damped goes up. The negative feedback process is working on the net phase angle on the returned voltage, not the voltage waveshape exactly desired.

So there is a balancing act, so to speak, and very low output impedances result in the error correction voltage being shifted a greater amount, as a function of frequency, compared to an amp with mediocre output resistance (R >> XL at the ringing freq). The best way around this is to biamp the woofer, and allow the NFB for the woofer dedicated amp to pick up it's error signal between the inline inductor and the voice coil. Not consumer friendly.
 
Back
Top Bottom