• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Dynaco ST-70: Base Line Testing

6DZ7,
The image I have of the nay-sayers more resembles the flying monkeys in "The Wizard of Oz" gleefully jumping on the parts of poor scaredynacrow's torn apart carcass.

I don't have much ST-70 experience except for repair, but I've been very surprised at how well a stock unit performs. I failed to understand what the sonic limitations are and why the cottage industry of do-overs exists. I thought it was quite good sounding and non-fatiguing.

I'm with you Dave on your intentions here.
<edit added>
Don't get me wrong. I've been as frustrated as anyone with traces lifting when you have to carefully solder or unsolder from the boards, but I've really thought of these units more as lumps of dough that can be molded than as something that has to be totally re-envisioned.
 
Last edited:
Understand and very much appreciate the time and explanations. A GREAT thread, not just on the ST-70 but tube and tube amps in general.

And yes, I an one of those that
rip a 70 to tiny shreds leaving nothing recognizable behind. Maybe the bones if you know what you're looking at. The entrails scattered for us birds to pick through on eBay...

6

Except I sold my entrails here:-)

BUT, in my defense I am new to tubes, and thought that my mods, power supply and driver board, were requirements for the amp to be at it's best. Had I been privy to some of the information posted in this thread, my decision may have been different and much cheaper. Or maybe not:-))
 
I've been repairing my own vehicles for 30+ years and also work on my vintage 1940's to 1960's cars, trucks, and outdoor power equipment. Maybe I have a different perspective of the 'keep it original issue'. While it's great to try to keep things original, if there is an improvement to be had in the 50 years this amp has been around why not try it? (Aren't we all glad there are disc brake kits available for many older cars?) We're not doing anything that butchers the amp, so it can always be returned to original. The way I see it, if these amps were so good from the start, no one would be selling mods for them. And everyone would have a huge stash of 7199's because they were still in production!!

I equate the ST70 to the SB/BB Chev engines: while they were good when new there is always something that can be improved or modified. And due to the design and vast quantities in existence, there is a large upgrade/mod/rebuild market.
 
Its useful to know what you're starting with though. Saying something is better is not terribly useful without defining how it is better. Its also a bit unfair to say that modification X is some magic improvement when you're comparing an amp in stock but malfunctioning condition to it in modified but working condition. Any running engine is better than a non-running engine in terms of 0-60 time, but if you can put a fuel pump on your 327 and make it go, it'll run the pants off a 250 I6 any day of the week.
 
Great thread Dave. I'm happy to say I'm old enough to now understand most of what you're saying. This thread reminds me a lot of the 50's era magazines where many of the pioneers like Keroes and Hafler published their early articles about UL and circuits they developed, and Williamson, et. al. Published rebuttals claiming the status quo was still best. Heh, plenty of ego back then too. Its a hoot to read stuff from Walker, Reckinghausen, Gow and McIntosh, Marantz and Smith and realize they were creating the technology, as were the designers and engineers making the transformers and tubes.
 
The first thing I'm going to do with my ST70 is bias is as per the factory specs.
I've been running it at 1.40v to save the tubes but now I can see all I am doing is creating distortion.
Thanks Dave!

And although I just finished recapping mine, I have enjoyed it and haven't given much thought to installing the new VTA driver board and tubes I bought. I'm still using the Ruby rectifier and new EH EL34's.
But I think I will swap in the 6CA7's and the GZ34.
Great thread.
 
Thanks for the great info Dave!

The tubes4hifi site recommends .40 for 6L6 types and .45 for EL34 types, and probably to compensate for todays high line voltages and new production tubes tubes. He must have found tube failure.

What about the affect of higher line voltage on the sonics with a lower setting? KT-88 or larger tubes may be the answer for really long life at the stock settings if one has the newer upgraded PS trans.

I bet the EFB Dave is developing for this amp will probably help the tubes besides the usual sonics!
 
Speaking of bias, the 7199 has some variability in the characteristics of the pentode section. The operating point of this stage sets the operating point of the triode phase inverter, since they're direct coupled. A person on another board told me that he measured differences between brands of 7199s in distortion measurements. I'd guess that all of them could measure better if the operating point is tweaked by adjusting the screen or cathode resistor on the gain stage.

7199s are becoming rarer - the Russian ones are out of production now too. In a Stromberg amp, I found that two 6GH8s biased to a near-identical operating point vs. 7199s after rewiring the sockets, (and two 6BL8s did not) but that's a pretty small sample.
 
Tom's point is excellent, and is a preview of my own experience with this tube in the (my) ST-70. I will get to that in the driver board post.

Dave
 
The Power Output Stage Pt.3: Configuration Performance

The previous information on internal resistance and output stage configuration is important to have a basis of understanding as to how and why various popular modifications to the output stage affect the sound as they do. The common understanding is that it is tubes themselves that produce a unique sound quality when in reality, it is the interaction of a particular tube's characteristic with the circuit it is installed in that produces a given sonic quality. Therefore, changing the circuit can have just as much impact on sound quality as changing tubes can, if not more. Changing the output stage configuration in the ST-70 then is no different.

FEEDBACK -- Claims are often made how feedback hurts performance, so some modifications result in reduced, or potentially no feedback at all. Feedback primarily affects frequency response, distortion, and internal resistance. It would take having a feedback modified unit on the test bench to determine the impact produced on these areas, but suffice to say, that a stock ST-70, when operating with the NFB loop disabled, will display an internal resistance of 19 ohms on the 8 ohm tap, and a distortion of 1.1% at 1 kHz, at 1 db below 35 watts output.

Since amplifier internal resistance can have a significant effect on the sound produced, it needs to be minimized as much as possible, so that the speaker and amplifier can each be judged on their own merits. After all, when the characteristics of one component affects the operation of the another, the ability to make an accurate assessment of either then is destroyed.

Besides amplifier internal resistance, the other electrical element that influences speaker damping is the DC resistance of the voice coil itself, with a typical 8 ohm speaker often having a DC resistance of about 7 ohms or so. With a quality amplifier then, it is the DC resistance of the speaker itself that primarily determines how effective the electrical damping action is. So what level of internal resistance should a quality amplifier represent?

For the internal resistance of an amplifier to effectively be a non-factor, it should represent no more than 1/10th the DC resistance of the speaker. Applying this back to the UL output stage of the ST-70 then, it can be seen that with an internal resistance of 19 ohms on the 8 ohm tap, some help is needed from a feedback network to reduce this value low enough so as to remove its influences on the effect of speaker operation. Even if the output stage is configured for the lowest possible internal resistance (triode), that value (7.8 ohms on the 8 ohm tap) is still plenty high to influence the bass response of most speakers.

As a result, any modification that does not include SOME reasonable level of feedback is almost certainly going to color the sound produced, either by way of its internal resistance, or distortion produced. Therefore, designs that claim that feedback is not needed due to the use of a UL or triode output stage should be held in question, with regards to accuracy produced. The stock ST-70 displays an internal resistance of .72 ohms on the 8 ohm tap, effectively removing any coloration it might contribute due to the effects of internal resistance.

Internal resistance is only one amplifier characteristic that can influence reproduced sound. Like testing for frequency response, it is typically measured at low power levels. The power response produced over the audio bandwidth is another. But just as important is the quality of power response produced in the face of a varying load impedance, like that of a speaker. The configuration of the output stage can have a significant impact on this issue as well.

ALTERNATE OUTPUT STAGE CONFIGURATIONS

TRIODE OPERATION -- As mentioned, the internal resistance of a triode connected ST-70 output stage is about 7.8 ohms on the 8 ohm tap. Since triodes have the least gain of all output stage configurations, the feedback loop is not as effective in reducing this down to an acceptable level as when operating in UL. But that's OK, because triodes start with a lower internal resistance to begin with. With a triode connected output stage, the nominal 20 db of global NFB employed in the ST-70 is reduced to about 16 db, which is still enough to reduce the overall internal resistance of the amplifier down to about .74 ohm -- low enough to effectively remove it from introducing any coloration of sound.

Against this however, is the poorer HF response that triodes display, causing the stock frequency response at 20 and 30 kHz to go from -.25/-.5 db, to -1.0/-2.25 db respectively. A 10 kHz square wave presentation clearly shows the effects on frequency response, when the output stage is converted to triode operation.

One major benefit of triode mode however, is the power response curve produced with respect to variations in loading impedance. Triode mode will produce a flat power response of about 17 watts RMS within the audio bandwidth. But importantly, as the load impedance swings from 1/2 rated load, to 2X rated load, the available power becomes about 16 watts and 14 watts respectively across the same frequency bandwidth, while still retaining quite reasonable distortion figures in the process (<.4% at 1 kHz).

So while the triode operation presents challenges in the frequency response department, its ability to handle varying loads while still maintaining low distortion performance is excellent.

PENTODE OPERATION -- A pentode output stage has the highest internal resistance. So connected, the ST-70 output stage has a whopping 105.7 ohms of internal resistance on the 8 ohm tap! But pentodes also have the most gain of all output stage configurations, so the feedback loop becomes more effective in reducing this down to an acceptable level, than with any other configuration. With a pentode connected output stage, feedback rises to 23+ db, which is still effective enough to reduce the overall internal resistance of the amplifier down to .82 ohms on the 8 ohm tap, and enough to prevent it from introducing any coloration of sound.

Pentode operation also causes a rise in HF response, showing +.10, +.25, and +.5 db at 10, 20, and 30 kHz respectively. A 10 kHz sqare wave presentation clearly shows the effects on frequency response, when the output stage is converted to pentode operation.

At a constant impedance and normal loading, the power response in pentode mode is flat across the audio bandwidth at 35 watts RMS, although distortion is at least double that of either triode or UL operation. And while power and distortion are acceptably maintained when the load drops to 1/2 of rated value, distortion deteriorates notably at 2X rated load, effectively becoming a 20 watt amplifier under this condition, with distortion climbing yet another three times over normal loading of pentode operation (to ~ 2.4% at 1 kHz). This is as much a product of pentode operation itself, as it is the A-470 output transformer providing marginal loading conditions for pentode operation of EL34s.

So pentode operation produces elevated frequency response, and an acceptable internal resistance level when feedback is applied, but has increased distortion with a rising load impedance.

ULTRA-LINEAR OPERATION -- UL operation displays a low internal resistance as mentioned earlier (.72 ohms on the 8 ohm tap), preventing it from introducing any coloration of sound from this characteristic.

Since the amplifier was designed with this output stage configuration from the ground up, frequency response is as is stated in the Measured Stock Performance Post, failing to meet published specifications, but still being down only .25 db at 20 kHz. A 10 kHz square wave presentation of the stock unit was provided in that post.

With a constant impedance and normal loading, a flat power response at 35 watts RMS across the full audio bandwidth is produced, at the lowest distortion levels of all configurations, as posted in the Stock Performance Post.

When the load impedance varies by 1/2 or 2X rated load impedance with UL, the power response is very similar to that of pentode operation (with maximum power at 2X rated load being ~23 watts). HOWEVER, because of the UL connection, distortion does not climb above .4% at 1 kHz under either condition.

SUMMARY

While UL and pentode operation produce basically the same power response across the audio bandwidth and with respect to loading conditions, UL operation ALSO shows the same INsensitivity to distortion with varying load impedance levels that triode operation does -- while watt for watt, producing the lowest overall distortion of all three output stage configurations. This is the beauty of UL operation, combining the best that the other two modes have to offer in one package.

In the ST-70 then, UL operation of the output stage with feedback would appear to be the best compromise, considering the power, distortion, frequency response, and damping factor targeted for the unit. Triode operation can certainly be a viable alternate configuration, with the advantage of that mode typically producing lower order distortion products, but at a cost to HF response and power. Pentode operation of the ST-70 would not be recommended with EL34 tubes, although may prove acceptable with 6L6 class tubes. This was not investigated for this project.

Pics include:

1. A 10 kHz square wave in triode mode.

2. A 10 kHz square wave in pentode mode.

The last stop will be the driver board.

Dave
 

Attachments

  • ST-70 Alternate Output Stage Configurations 001.jpg
    ST-70 Alternate Output Stage Configurations 001.jpg
    45.2 KB · Views: 109
  • ST-70 Alternate Output Stage Configurations 002.jpg
    ST-70 Alternate Output Stage Configurations 002.jpg
    44.3 KB · Views: 107
Last edited:
Just a measurement question. How does one determine the internal resistance of an amplifier?
 
Gadget -- There are a number of ways, but one easy way is the following:

1. Drive the amplifier to an output of 1.00 vac at 1 kHz, with no load on it.

2. Connect the rated load to the amplifier, and observe what the output has fallen to.

3. Use Ohms Law to determine the internal resistance.

Let's say that the 1.00 vac no load output drops to .80 vac when an 8 ohm load is applied. From Ohm's Law, .80 vac / 8 ohms means there is .1 A flowing through the load resistor.

There was 1.00 vac at the output before the load was attached, and .80 vac after it was attached, so the drop of .20 vac was produced by the internal resistance of the amplifier.

Since we know the voltage drop produced in the amplifier, and we know the current being produced by the amplifier, then we can use Ohm's Law again to determine the internal resistance: .20 vac / .1 A = 2 Ohms. So the internal resistance of the amplifier in this example is 2 Ohms.

I hope this helps!

Dave
 
A voltage divider. Cool, another new tool in my belt. And you don't really even need a scope. I've been wondering how to to do this. Thanks Dave.

This assumes your meter or scope has high internal resistance, which most modern ones do, I expect.
 
I ran out of space in the Configuration Performance post, but wanted to highlight that the important point of 2X loading performance with pentode and UL modes is not the actual power drop-off, as that is principally a function Ohm's Law: The source generator can only develop so much output voltage, so if the load resistance attached to it is doubled in value, then the power developed must fall off. This is true with any amplifier. The notations of the reduced power were simply to show what it fell to.

The takeaway points are that with both pentode and UL operation, power was maintained as the load was reduced to 1/2 rated load, but with pentode mode, the distortion rose notably, and particularly so with the 2X load condition, where as with UL operation (as with triode), the rise in distortion with either 1/2 load or 2X loading was only modest under either of these conditions. That the UL connection can basically perform as well as triodes do in this regard, yet do so while delivering pentode levels of power output, is the real beauty of UL capability.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Gadget -- There are a number of ways, but one easy way is the following:

1. Drive the amplifier to an output of 1.00 vac at 1 kHz, with no load on it.

2. Connect the rated load to the amplifier, and observe what the output has fallen to.

3. Use Ohms Law to determine the internal resistance.

Let's say that the 1.00 vac no load output drops to .80 vac when an 8 ohm load is applied. From Ohm's Law, .80 vac / 8 ohms means there is .1 A flowing through the load resistor.

There was 1.00 vac at the output before the load was attached, and .80 vac after it was attached, so the drop of .20 vac was produced by the internal resistance of the amplifier.

Since we know the voltage drop produced in the amplifier, and we know the current being produced by the amplifier, then we can use Ohm's Law again to determine the internal resistance: .20 vac / .1 A = 2 Ohms. So the internal resistance of the amplifier in this example is 2 Ohms.

I hope this helps!

Dave

awesome, thanks for the info.
 
Dave,

Incredible evaluation of my favorite old amp! Another 'new look' and another 'old friend'!!

If I may, I'd like to digress back to the PS section where the question was asked about the use of two chokes; "How to do a proper job of installing a second one?" Also, the comment about the current limitation of the 5AR4 being the 250ma and that the use of the PIV mod of the diode on the socket 'not' helping with the current capability in the overall supply. I'm not so sure I completely followed what the bottom line of this comment was, but if I did understand you correctly (which I hope I did), the actual point you were making is that with the amp potentially drawing upwards of 400ma through the tube, at a 250ma 'max'.....the tube was still seeing WAY too much current draw for it's intended design, regardless of any 'diodes' in line with the HV from the PT...... yes? So, we're back to the 'Why not use 2 rectifiers?' comment.

Last question (for now): You mentioned a 'buck' transformer....but didn't supply any real detail on your set-up beyond that comment. I read that the PT now saw 117VAC.....but did you do that by adding another transformer of some kind within the ac power line....using a 'variac' or 'auto-transformer'....? My only other experience with this is with the Magnavox amps....and the use of the 'un-used' Filament winding within that transformer....and placing that in series with the primary winding to drop the secondary. That was described as a 'bucking' circuit. I guess I'm trying to figure how you did it to a 'stock' amp without adding another x-former, and if you 'did' add another x-former...what did you use?

I'll just end by saying: I too await the universal truth... I mean 'universal EFB board'!

Thanks Dave!!

Tom D.
 
Hi Tom -- Your understanding of the rectifier issue is correct. The two channels together can draw more current than the rectifier tube is capable of passing. Therefore, it can become a bottleneck to performance that the unit is otherwise capable of delivering.

The diode modification places external diodes in series with the rectifier tube, addressing the problem of poor PIV characteristics in modern versions of it. But this does nothing to aid in the current handling ability of whatever tube is installed in the socket. For that, either adding a second rectifier tube (as no one conventional full-wave tube exists to properly handle the job) or converting to SS rectification presents the only real options -- with adding a second tube really requiring a new power transformer due to the increased current demands of two heaters on the 5 volt winding.

With any piece of equipment, I always like to first approach any potential upgrades with one basic question: What would the manufacturer do today, if they were going to upgrade their product using currently available technology, while still maintaining the basic design integrity of the original unit? In my mind, there's little doubt that Hafler would have converted the ST-70 to conventional full-wave SS rectification, since that's exactly what he used in the later/smaller SCA/ST35 designs. With the approach I used, the initial voltage rise at turn on is not a problem, the ultimate voltage drop (and therefore basic operating voltages) remained largely unchanged from that of using a good NOS GZ34 rectifier tube, the current handling issue is completely eliminated, and power transformer operating temperature is reduced.

A buck transformer can either consist of using an appropriate unused winding within an existing power transformer, or using an external transformer to accomplish the same goal. Because so many of these pieces of this equipment were designed to operate from a 117 volt power source, and the power in my area routinely delivers 122 vac year round, I have a permanent 5 volt 10 amp buck transformer power system installed in both my lab and listening room, to provide a line voltage that is much more in keeping with that which most equipment of the day was designed to operate from. For equipment that doesn't need the adjustment, full line power is available as well of course.

Battradio suggested using the unused 5 volt winding within the original Dynaco power transformer as a buck winding if conversion to SS rectifiers is made. I have used this approach before, and its a very good answer for many folks in this case. In retrospect, I probably should have suggested it as well, but didn't for two reasons:

1. As a minor point, full power current needs of the amplifier exceed the current rating of this winding. While it WILL ably handle the needs of routine use -- and is even a modification that Hafler himself would almost certainly do -- it still represents potentially a new bottleneck for performance, versus that which a proper external buck transformer could provide.

At the time, my frame of mind was not to replace one bottleneck with another one -- although, using this approach with SS rectification is a major improvement over the bottleneck that the original rectifier tube represented.

2. It doesn't address the operating temp concern of the power transformer. Granted, using this winding for buck service (obviously) removes the heat of an actual rectifier tube from the chassis, but it doesn't reduce the internal heat build up within the transformer, since the winding is still being used to the majority of its capacity even under quiescent conditions. Converting to SS rectification and using an external buck transformer system, provides maximum temperature reduction within the power transformer, while completely removing the bottleneck of the original rectifier tube, without introducing any new ones.

Based on your own goals then, you can decide if using the internal 5 volt winding as a buck element serves your needs, or whether an external transformer is more appropriate.

Dave
 
Dave, regarding the Dynaco ST70 in "pentode" mode above. While it is relatively easy to run the ST70 in "triode" vs. "ultralinear", i.e. a few re-connections will suffice -- it is not so easy to implement "pentode" mode as that requires a power supply for the screen grids.

Have you actually implemented and measured the results of a "pentode" ST70 and if so, how did you provide a screen power supply?

-or-

Did you calculate the output resistance and distortion figures for a virtual "pentode" connected ST70?
 
Rust -- Great question. I was running out of post room to elaborate, and as it is, have gone back to maximize clarity as much as possible within the space available in that post. But I was still limited, which required the followup post, which I have also since tweaked for clarity as well. In any event, I just decided to address any remaining questions regarding content -- like yours -- as they might arise.

I produced pentode operation in a manner that those familiar with guitar amp design know: Each screen was tied to the B+ source (the B+ supply to the OPT CT in this case) with a 470 ohm resistor, and then measurements were made.

This is hardly the optimal way to power the screens for pentode operation with the load that the A-470 provides -- but it is likely the most probable way in concept that it would be accomplished. So while the method didn't provide the best possible pentode performance, it still served to show what the result would be when operating in that mode, as produced from the way that most would likely use to achieve it.

No doubt that using a proper screen grid supply (regulated at ~ 290 vdc) would have materially produced similar final internal resistance results, as output stage internal resistance would have risen, but OLG would also increase to compensate. Therefore, the final result would likely be very similar.

The trend in frequency response would still be present, and likely accentuated due to the increase in OLG that proper pentode operation would afford.

Maximum power output would also be quite similar, as the effective over-powering of the screen grids would certainly not reduce power output in my tests.

However, a proper screen grid supply would produce improved distortion results, with all figures being reduced due to the improved loading conditions provided. But the basic pentode characteristic of increasing distortion as the load varied from optimum would not change.

In all then, I felt that the simple approach I used was adequate for the needs of the exercise, particularly so since most adventurous experimenters would not likely go to the effort of building the proper supply needed.

Thanks for the interest!

Dave
 
Back
Top Bottom