• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Feeling discouraged today.....

I remember when iPods first came into our lives a customer of mine who listened to one through earphones all the time. She loved the little widget--about the size of a pack of cigarettes--and wanted me to check it out, and hear how great it was. I listened, and was not as impressed. I nodded in polite approval and handed back the headphones, and asked a lot of questions about how many songs she had on there, etc. She felt good about the thing, so I was thinking why take the wind out of her sails?

But that was then, and this is now. The storage capabilities and other characteristics make such sound OK now, and my ear for such things is probably less critical than once it was, and my hearing bandwidth has gone down some with age.

If a friend is happy--or seems happy--with what they have, then the best bet is probably to let them be. If instead that friend asks for tips on perhaps how to improve their system then instead of dissing their current setup make suggestions about directions in improving things.

While I enjoy my audio gear I don't for a minute pretend that it is the best around--or even anywhere near the top percentile for that matter. But I enjoy it, and allow myself to do so. I also extend this courtesy to everyone else--regardless of what they have in audio gear. If they enjoy it--let 'em.

If someone has a setup that I find pleasant to the ear then I may ask them about such equipment, how they came by it, etc.... It often pays to keep an open mind.
 
It really became apparent just how little information there was in Mp3's when I started compressing my master files of things that I recorded and mixed to Mp3 for easy distribution.

AAC is a much better compression codec, and I use it whenever it is necessary to use lossy compression.
 
I've a friend named Randy. He's an older fellow, Federal Judge by day, Jazz lover by night. He has a wonderful 2 channel system in his home in a dedicated room just for that. Today I asked him what he was listening to these days and he said "I just picked up Jeff Beck's last two albums. I downloaded em on my MP3 player and these Bose Headphones makes the music sound great."

After picking myself off the floor I launched into a 10 minute tirade about how no self respecting lover of music could be satisfied with the MP3 format, how he could've done much better than Bose for less money. I extolled the virtues of ripping lossless to a dedicated server which would give him access to his entire library thoughout his house. He sat in stoney silence and finally said that "that's all well and good for you, you're a musician and can hear the difference, I cannot so this is good enough for me."

It was like watching a life long friend turn to the dark side of the force. I was saddened and sickened to think that this was the current state of the listening habits of America and to top it off, there was a decent system sitting unused for no good reason. Sigh....

I feel so depressed.

Worf

you sir, are GUILTY on all counts! (one count of impersonating a drama queen, and one count of harassment of a sitting judge) :thumbsdn:
 
Last edited:
With soooo many people turning away from listening to music altogether, why lecture a friend for listening to what he likes in any shape or form?

I have LOTS of old friends who have turned away from listening to their music completely, so condemning a friend for changing his listening habits would be like shooting more toes off a foot that is already missing a few! there are too many things wrong with the world these days to worry about what my audio friends perceive as good or bad. I'm more than happy to help people with putting together a good system or how to make their digital files sound better, but if they choose to listen to 128 kps mp3s, that's okay too.

The problem with too many forums is there are too many people who will turn up their nose if they don't feel your equipment or knowledge is good enough for their tastes. That's one HUGE reason I stay around AK, because people are so down to earth and easy to get along with. I appreciate those who have both high knowledge and incredible audio gear, but elitism is not my thing.
 
I'm surprised a judge would allow a 10 minute tirade. If I was a judge I'd be smacking that gavel down after the first minute!:D
Seriously though, my first thought was I'd be all over that 2 channel system. Does that make me a bad guy or friend?
 
While I enjoy my audio gear I don't for a minute pretend that it is the best around--or even anywhere near the top percentile for that matter
+1 - I would say the majority of us do not own a really high end system.
Just because we spin vinyl or may even know the difference between analog and digital (not saying either is better, just the difference in how they are made), does not make us experts in all things audio. It means most of us have an idea of how we wish our systems to sound for our ears.
Does not make our audio any better then the person who is listening to a walmart mp3 player and enjoys it tremendously - is just a different way to please ourselves.
I can not even begin to count the stupid things I have asked or the times I have changed directions in what i wanted. We often forget the vast majority of people do not wish to make listening to music their hobby. It is something they enjoy and do not need to here the air whistling past the drumsticks to be happy. Most people i know think I am the one who is nuts and would prefer sitting and watching tv in the evenings.
Does not make them right, does not make me right - we each just do what pleases us.
You should see the look on most people's faces when I have not seen them for a while and they ask me what is up - an immediate glaze comes over their face.
Even if they hear my stereo, they always really like it, but VERY few actually even shut up long enough to really hear it. Try to get a "normal" person to shut up for just one complete song.....almost impossible.
They want background noise and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.
 
I've a friend named Randy. He's an older fellow, Federal Judge by day, Jazz lover by night. He has a wonderful 2 channel system in his home in a dedicated room just for that. Today I asked him what he was listening to these days and he said "I just picked up Jeff Beck's last two albums. I downloaded em on my MP3 player and these Bose Headphones makes the music sound great."

After picking myself off the floor I launched into a 10 minute tirade about how no self respecting lover of music could be satisfied with the MP3 format, how he could've done much better than Bose for less money. I extolled the virtues of ripping lossless to a dedicated server which would give him access to his entire library thoughout his house. He sat in stoney silence and finally said that "that's all well and good for you, you're a musician and can hear the difference, I cannot so this is good enough for me."

It was like watching a life long friend turn to the dark side of the force. I was saddened and sickened to think that this was the current state of the listening habits of America and to top it off, there was a decent system sitting unused for no good reason. Sigh....

I feel so depressed.

Worf

Maybe he was just pulling your chain and enjoying every minute of it... Some people (usually very smart ones) just love to do that when we get on our high end horse and start pontificating :D
 
When I burned a collection of 320kbps onto dvd and played that dvd at a party I hosted, I was most embarrassed, and my guests picked up on it as well...
From that point forward, I never consider anything less than .wav formats.
My guess is that fans of compressed formats are merely enjoying the song(s). They're not so much interested in the subtle nuances from the different band members of a particular track. To my ear, it would appear that fast Rock'nRoll would serve well being compressed. But if the music slows down, the compression is truly recognized.
 
Last edited:
When I burned a collection of 320kbps onto dvd and played that dvd at a party I hosted, I was most embarrassed. From that point forward, I never consider anything less than .wav formats.

Counterpoint...
My daughter played her iPod for her graduation party last year through an Akai AA-35 amp and a set of Utah 3 way speakers out in the yard and everybody loved it. And she uses whatever the regular format is, my guess 128 kps.

I have much of my stuff burned at 320 and don't feel embarrassed; and I've played it for other members who didn't know it wasn't redbook on CD and they never said a word.

Sometimes, ignorance is bliss :D
 
Last edited:
When I burned a collection of 320kbps onto dvd and played that dvd at a party I hosted, I was most embarrassed.

You obviously did something wrong but for whatever reason the codec always gets blamed. If the faults were that obvious do you think some people here at AK would be using it to store their music collection and others using even lower bitrates for portable use?
 
A couple days ago, a high school kid interning for us came into my office to interview me about the music industry for a report he's doing. Afterward, he commented that I had a cool office. (Probably because it's a junkyard of audio gear and media.) He then proceeded to tell me about his audio system at home--iPod and dock plugged into either Bose headphones or his bass guitar amp (!). Both sound excellent, apparently. I didn't comment on either one of these suspect-sounding scenarios because (a) if they make him happy, there's no need for me to try to rain on his parade and (b) I haven't heard them personally, so who am I to judge, anyway?
 
Music is music,yes there are better ways to listen to it but to each his own I say!Much the same in many other aspects of life, take food for instance,"people gotta eat" but this one dictated only by the people themselves as to what to eat,when to eat,where to eat and how they do it is their own business as well as what vehicle to bay,drive and restore so I say the same about music and how or what you do with it!
 
Last edited:
I think a lot in this thread has been missed by many : I think the OP was feeling a sense of loss , not being incensed at his friend , or not admonishing anyone...... I know I feel the same way too ; when you feel you share a bond with somebody : a bond built out of common interest , shared experiences, and time and you see it come to an end you feel a sense of loss. In a hobby and pastime (and passion) as esoteric as audio most of us cherish the connections we have with those of like mind. Just think of the loss we would feel if everybody at AK said "we were wrong all along .......mp3's on a cheap player are as good as anything " and AK closed up ..... I think this is what the OP was expressing .....not something born out of snobbery
 
I think a lot in this thread has been missed by many : I think the OP was feeling a sense of loss , not being incensed at his friend , or not admonishing anyone...... I know I feel the same way too ; when you feel you share a bond with somebody : a bond built out of common interest , shared experiences, and time and you see it come to an end you feel a sense of loss. In a hobby and pastime (and passion) as esoteric as audio most of us cherish the connections we have with those of like mind. Just think of the loss we would feel if everybody at AK said "we were wrong all along .......mp3's on a cheap player are as good as anything " and AK closed up ..... I think this is what the OP was expressing .....not something born out of snobbery

I agree :yes:
 
I think a lot in this thread has been missed by many : I think the OP was feeling a sense of loss , not being incensed at his friend , or not admonishing anyone...... I know I feel the same way too ; when you feel you share a bond with somebody : a bond built out of common interest , shared experiences, and time and you see it come to an end you feel a sense of loss. In a hobby and pastime (and passion) as esoteric as audio most of us cherish the connections we have with those of like mind. Just think of the loss we would feel if everybody at AK said "we were wrong all along .......mp3's on a cheap player are as good as anything " and AK closed up ..... I think this is what the OP was expressing .....not something born out of snobbery

I too felt the same way about the OP. It's in the same catagory as "friends don't let friends drive drunk".
 
You obviously did something wrong but for whatever reason the codec always gets blamed. If the faults were that obvious do you think some people here at AK would be using it to store their music collection and others using even lower bitrates for portable use?

Maybe it should get blamed. How many studios store their masters as lossy compressed files? Even I can answer that. NONE!!! If lossy compression was/is so good why would any studio bother with 24/96 or Bitstream? In any case, storage is so cheap why take the chance you might hear the difference. I can understand using compression for portable devices. For archival storage? You must be kidding.

Why would anyone throw out part of the music when doing archival storage? From the posts I'm seeing on this and other sites, those who used lossy compression for archival storage are realizing they made a mistake and attempting to get non lossy versions of their files. They remind me of those people who sold their vinyl at fire sale prices when the CD was introduced. Yeah, the same people who even now are trying to recreate their lost vinyl collections.

As for me, I'll stay away from compression on my music server. Portable use is not an issue with me. I can't stand headphones. I gave my Stax phones to a buddie who has late night listening issues. Currently I don't own any phones. Nor do I have a portable music player
 
Maybe it should get blamed. (rant deleted)

Please note that I only said that something must be surely wrong if 320 kbps mp3 sounded that bad. I personally wouldn't archive in lossy but I can see why others might.

Your studio archiving argument is a silly straw man. Once you go to lossy you only have an end product, you can't do anything else with it. You can't transcode it to lower bitrates or effectively modify it in any way because to do so would mean you'd have to decode to wave and then recode to 320 kbs, which is a bad idea.

Mp3 is a tool and how people use it is up to them. I personally wouldn't use a crescent wrench to remove lug nuts, others might. I still think it is a useful tool though.
 
I just have to say that Apple's AAC compression codec sounds great to my ears. I did a quick comparo of a 24/48 AIFF master of a singer/songwriter to the 320k AAC compression, and it sounded pretty close. Seemed like there was less air around the guy's guitar, and everything was not as clearly defined. but still a lot better than the Mp3's I have been going thru to pay at a party later today.
 
I think a lot in this thread has been missed by many : I think the OP was feeling a sense of loss , not being incensed at his friend , or not admonishing anyone...... I know I feel the same way too ; when you feel you share a bond with somebody : a bond built out of common interest , shared experiences, and time and you see it come to an end you feel a sense of loss. In a hobby and pastime (and passion) as esoteric as audio most of us cherish the connections we have with those of like mind. Just think of the loss we would feel if everybody at AK said "we were wrong all along .......mp3's on a cheap player are as good as anything " and AK closed up ..... I think this is what the OP was expressing .....not something born out of snobbery

Well said.
 
Back
Top Bottom