• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Feeling discouraged today.....

I just have to say that Apple's AAC compression codec sounds great to my ears.

Download fubar and use the ABX comparator to see if you can reliably tell the difference with level matched files. That's what I did when I was trying to figure out which compression level to use for my mp3 player. I found it difficult to tell the difference around 192kbps VBR but from what I've read Apples codec is even better at these levels, I've not tried it myself.

These kinds of tests are useful for determining what compression level to use when you have to weigh file size vs. audio quality. With enough capacity it's a moot point.
 
Please note that I only said that something must be surely wrong if 320 kbps mp3 sounded that bad. I personally wouldn't archive in lossy but I can see why others might.

Your studio archiving argument is a silly straw man. Once you go to lossy you only have an end product, you can't do anything else with it. You can't transcode it to lower bitrates or effectively modify it in any way because to do so would mean you'd have to decode to wave and then recode to 320 kbs, which is a bad idea.

Mp3 is a tool and how people use it is up to them. I personally wouldn't use a crescent wrench to remove lug nuts, others might. I still think it is a useful tool though.

Using lossy compression is exactly the same as using a crescent wrench on lug nuts. Sure, the wrench gets the nuts off. The busted knuckles and rounded edges are the same as what lossy compression throws away.

Please don't start suggesting I don't know or understand how perceptual compression works. I taught computer languages and programming. I'm quite familiar with the algorithms that lossy compression schemes are built around.

I've noticed quite a few posters on various forums who lament that they elected to use lossy compression for archival purposes. They remind me of those folks who sold their LP's when CD's were introduced. Those guys have spent the last few years trying to recreate their lost collections.

Storage is so cheap in todays world there is no excuse for using any kind of compression (especially lossy) except for portable devices. Even that will change. Technology marches on!
 
Using lossy compression is exactly the same as using a crescent wrench on lug nuts. Sure, the wrench gets the nuts off. The busted knuckles and rounded edges are the same as what lossy compression throws away.

Please don't start suggesting I don't know or understand how perceptual compression works. I taught computer languages and programming. I'm quite familiar with the algorithms that lossy compression schemes are built around.

I've noticed quite a few posters on various forums who lament that they elected to use lossy compression for archival purposes. They remind me of those folks who sold their LP's when CD's were introduced. Those guys have spent the last few years trying to recreate their lost collections.

Storage is so cheap in todays world there is no excuse for using any kind of compression (especially lossy) except for portable devices. Even that will change. Technology marches on!

(Rant not cut this time)

Are you rebutting something I posted? It appears we are saying something similar but I'm not sure.
 
I think a lot in this thread has been missed by many : I think the OP was feeling a sense of loss , not being incensed at his friend , or not admonishing anyone...... I know I feel the same way too ; when you feel you share a bond with somebody : a bond built out of common interest , shared experiences, and time and you see it come to an end you feel a sense of loss. In a hobby and pastime (and passion) as esoteric as audio most of us cherish the connections we have with those of like mind. Just think of the loss we would feel if everybody at AK said "we were wrong all along .......mp3's on a cheap player are as good as anything " and AK closed up ..... I think this is what the OP was expressing .....not something born out of snobbery
I think I am going to have to disagree
After picking myself off the floor I launched into a 10 minute tirade about how no self respecting lover of music could be satisfied with the MP3 format, how he could've done much better than Bose for less money
Websters definition of tirade " a protracted speech usually marked by intemperate, vituperative, or harshly censorious language"

How would you feel if some one told you no self respecting lovers of cars would buy what you just bought ?
How would you feel if after you bought a new car and was enjoying it tremendously, a "friend" came over and went on a 10 minute tirade telling you how you screwed up and could have bought a much better car for less money.....

The judge has a good 2 channel stereo so he knows what he likes to listen to. After listening to his good 2 channel system for who knows how long, he chose to go a different direction - he is happy and did not deserve a talking down to because he happens to enjoy an Ipod and a pair of Bose speakers.
 
I may not have gone into a tirade. However, I would have made my disappointment obvious.
 
I may not have gone into a tirade. However, I would have made my disappointment obvious.

Not sure what this means but I think we're saying the same thing. Don't use lossy for archiving. Beyond that my only point was that if someone made a 320 kbps mp3 for background music and was embarrassed by the sound quality obviously something went wrong.
 
Hey, we all bust our friend's kahunas once in a while, it's a fact of life, and sometimes we all need to get some things off our chest....another fact of life.....let the guy vent to his fellow audiophiles......LOL
 
You obviously did something wrong but for whatever reason the codec always gets blamed. If the faults were that obvious do you think some people here at AK would be using it to store their music collection and others using even lower bitrates for portable use?
Yes, as a matter of fact, I DO.
Popular Opinion doesn't make it the correct opinion.
Doing something wrong...all I can say is that I followed the instructions that came w/Nero deluxe. But, in all intent, I used lossless and wave for storing when my computer was my main source of audio output. Since I've started collecting vintage audio, that habit has come to a halt altogether.
..My guess is that fans of compressed formats are merely enjoying the song(s). They're not so much interested in the subtle nuances from the different band members of a particular track. To my ear, it would appear that fast Rock'nRoll would serve well being compressed. But if the music slows down, the compression is truly recognized....
 
Last edited:
I can hear the difference between a 128k mp3 and a CD but am getting past it. mp3's and streaming on Pandora are two things my iPhone can do....This way when I am at work, or mowing, no matter what I feel like listening to I'll have it. Lossless would eat up the phone's storage space pretty darn quick.
 
"Once you start down the dark path, forever will it dominate your destiny, consume you it will..." Yoda

Being a judge, your friend started down the dartk path upon entering law school (assumuing he's a lawyer here).:thmbsp:
 
With the right gear, a lossless digital format can sound as good as anything else. And a music server streaming to a good 2 channel system with good speakers is working out great for me!
 
I think a lot in this thread has been missed by many : I think the OP was feeling a sense of loss

I think the OP dropped a turd in a punchbowl to see if it would get thrown out or stirred in.

Five pages later............he has his answer.:smoke:
 
Working at an "Unnamed University", I had the opportunity to question a concert level pianist (also unnamed) concerning his use of a very low end cassette player as a music source in his office. He responded,"No matter how it is played, I hear all of the music." -- food for thought...
 
You know I think some perspective is needed here...this isn't cassette vs LP here, this is subtle and mostly inaudible differences in highly advanced compression algorithms.

It's extremely subtle. You don't lose swaths of frequency response, you don't lose sampling rate, at worst you get compression artifacts and dithering problems on uncommon sound patterns. For example, I had a wav of a song with a lot of synth stuff in it. The bassline was a mostly sawtooth waveform and it got chewed to pieces @ 128k. Turned it into static. But at 320 the difference from the original was negligible. And in both cases the midrange/hi end was basically untouched.

And there is the trade-off between fidelity and portability. An 8 gig ipod touch fills up pretty quick on lossless flac or wav. Not to mention a maximum headphone output of 60mw. Large headphones have a power handling of anywhere from 500 to 3000 milliwatts and that'd suck an ipod battery dry. Now I'd like to play records on the bus, but I can't, and even a cd discman won't fit in my jeans pocket. So in order to get the most music without sacrificing basic quality, keeping the most compatibility, and on a music player that won't kill battery life overpowering headphones, 320k and/or VBR mp3 is a pretty reasonable compromise. Show me how I can do better without sacrificing capacity, quality, or battery.

That judge made a fair call on this one. Plus he's not using stock earbuds, that's a step ahead of most ipod users. He's doing fine, give him a break. There's pros and cons to any system.
 
At least the OP's friend is listening to something.

(I skipped from the first page to the last. Whatever else was going on seemed a bit futile)
 
Back
Top Bottom