• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Getz/Gilberto Comparison

A little trivia question for all the old people here..... How many own an original Verve copy that they bought new? I thinks it ranks in the top five or so albums sold. Miles Davis and Dave Brubeck are two others on that list. I pulled mine out of storage about six months ago and as @mackat noted, the first thing I did after listening was go to Google Maps and find the Ipanema and Copacabana beaches.
 
Uploaded my LP (remaster). Interestingly, Astrud's voice is on the right side. Guess I never critically listened to this song (esp on phones). :idea:

Getz gilberto (3) small.jpg

Girl From Ipanema. Off Getz/Gilberto. Verve Records. UCJU-9068. Sony (Japan) Joseph Palmaccio remaster. 2007.
Run-out: V6-8545 JP
 
So I'm listening on my relatively bright, relatively detailed system.

I'd definitely put C in last place. Obviously the brightest but it borders on sounding etched on my system.

B sounds the second most bright but it's in a much more natural manner than C.

D sounds the most CD like and the most clean but I don't think it sounds quite as natural as A.

So to my ears in this system, today, I'm going to say A is my favorite followed by probably B. I'm guessing D is the newest or a remaster or a CD. C is definitely in last place for me. It almost sounds as if someone captured it then tweaked the EQ pretty heavy-handedly and was listening on a very dark system.

I have a Verve recording that I bought in very used condition. It sounds brighter than A, B and D but far less etched or harsh than C.
 
Uploaded my LP (remaster). Interestingly, Astrud's voice is on the right side. Guess I never critically listened to this song (esp on phones). :idea:

View attachment 2435997

Girl From Ipanema. Off Getz/Gilberto. Verve Records. UCJU-9068. Sony (Japan) Joseph Palmaccio remaster. 2007.
Run-out: V6-8545 JP

Yeah, this sounds closer to my version, though it still sounds brighter than my copy. Of course, cartridge, setup and loading will all play a role here.
 
Yeah, this sounds closer to my version, though it still sounds brighter than my copy. Of course, cartridge, setup and loading will all play a role here.

In my opinion --- that upper midrange is an Audio Technica house sound. I'll try my Denon. :)
 
In my opinion --- that upper midrange is an Audio Technica house sound. I'll try my Denon. :)

Of course, it still sounds great as your uploads always do.

So I pulled it out and mine definitely sounds more forward overall than the ones in the OP and more similar to Mr Boochie's.

Here's my take. I have to reduce to MP3 to upload but as far as tonality and balance, it should be pretty honest, just missing out on a slight bit of detail. I think I had the gain set slightly too high by a dB or so.

This is my LP1240 with a Grado Opus3 into the iFi Zen. I will say this doesn't sound quite as bright as I remember, though the Grado is a bit darker than my three main previous carts on this table, the AT VM95ML, 2M Blue and esp the AT VM520EB which was on it for quite a while.

https://clyp.it/jgzfnwuq
 
I am listening to the tracks via the files app on my iPad, going into a Topping D10 DAC, JDS Atom headphone amplifier, and Dan Clark Aeon 2 headphones which I’ve turned into the Noire by changing the earpads.

Both A & D both sound very good to me, I am having a hard time telling the difference between them. If I had to guess, I would say that D is the AP 33, and A is the AP 45. It could be the other way around though, as I find them very difficult to distinguish between. I would be very surprised if one of these were not an AP version.

I don’t particularly like the sound of either B or C. C sounds quite tinny and “artificially-detailed” to me. The channel balance on B sounds shifted somewhat to the right. Aside from that, I’d like to say that I would prefer B to C, but I would take A or D any day over either.

So, my ranking is: A&D tie, B, and then C.
 
Of course, it still sounds great as your uploads always do.

So I pulled it out and mine definitely sounds more forward overall than the ones in the OP and more similar to Mr Boochie's.

Here's my take. I have to reduce to MP3 to upload but as far as tonality and balance, it should be pretty honest, just missing out on a slight bit of detail. I think I had the gain set slightly too high by a dB or so.

This is my LP1240 with a Grado Opus3 into the iFi Zen. I will say this doesn't sound quite as bright as I remember, though the Grado is a bit darker than my three main previous carts on this table, the AT VM95ML, 2M Blue and esp the AT VM520EB which was on it for quite a while.

https://clyp.it/jgzfnwuq

Thanks, for the compliment! :thumbsup: Much does go into recording & uploading. :) What you hear live while recording, often does NOT sound the same, off the Net. YouTube uses MP4 to upload their videos. I think that the audio is a bit better (bandwidth wise) than MP3. :idea:

Yours sound very good! I think you have a better vinyl of this album than me. Good MM do have this immediate sound. :)

Ripped with Denon DL-103SA (boron cant and NCL tip) on my Sony 2251 with SME 3009 arm.
 
Thanks for doing this JP.

Samples in order of preference: A, D, B, C.
  • Sample A sounds like my 2014 EU Verve stereo vinyl repressing of the '64 Verve stereo pressing.
  • Sample D sounds similar to A but with more detail, perhaps a digital version.
  • Sample B has nice detail but I prefer my EU stereo version.
  • Sample C sounds like a different mix than the EU Verve pressing, and while there was more detaiI I liked it the least of the 4 samples.
 
Last edited:
Did any of you the the press, perhaps ten years ago, about the estates/families of Jobim and Gilberto not allowing the woman who WAS the girl from Ipanema, to use that name for the gift shop that she ran near the beach? I thought that was very small of them. As I recall, in the end she won her lawsuit and thus got legal permission to call her shop "The Girl From Ipanema".
 
Did any of you the the press, perhaps ten years ago, about the estates/families of Jobim and Gilberto not allowing the woman who WAS the girl from Ipanema, to use that name for the gift shop that she ran near the beach? I thought that was very small of them. As I recall, in the end she won her lawsuit and thus got legal permission to call her shop "The Girl From Ipanema".

The song seemed to have brought a couple of notable lawsuits. Sad, really. :(
 
Thanks, for the compliment! :thumbsup: Much does go into recording & uploading. :) What you hear live while recording, often does NOT sound the same, off the Net. YouTube uses MP4 to upload their videos. I think that the audio is a bit better (bandwidth wise) than MP3. :idea:

Yours sound very good! I think you have a better vinyl of this album than me. Good MM do have this immediate sound. :)

Ripped with Denon DL-103SA (boron cant and NCL tip) on my Sony 2251 with SME 3009 arm.

On both your rips, the entry vocals have a sympathetic buzzing type vibration. It reminds me of snares vibrating on a drum head. I almost want to say minor groove damage, but it's of a character that I don't normally associate with groove damage.
 
Thanks, for the compliment! :thumbsup: Much does go into recording & uploading. :) What you hear live while recording, often does NOT sound the same, off the Net. YouTube uses MP4 to upload their videos. I think that the audio is a bit better (bandwidth wise) than MP3. :idea:
I think if you look at what audio is available to download, the default when playing the video is AAC 44.1k @ 96kbps bit rate, with options for AAC 44.1k @ 128kbps and WebM 48k @ 160kbps (max).
 
So I'm listening on my relatively bright, relatively detailed system.

I'd definitely put C in last place. Obviously the brightest but it borders on sounding etched on my system.

B sounds the second most bright but it's in a much more natural manner than C.

D sounds the most CD like and the most clean but I don't think it sounds quite as natural as A.

So to my ears in this system, today, I'm going to say A is my favorite followed by probably B. I'm guessing D is the newest or a remaster or a CD. C is definitely in last place for me. It almost sounds as if someone captured it then tweaked the EQ pretty heavy-handedly and was listening on a very dark system.

I have a Verve recording that I bought in very used condition. It sounds brighter than A, B and D but far less etched or harsh than C.
Yea, I think this is pretty accurate with regard to how I hear them too. C definitely has a boosted low and high end, B is boosted too but not quite as bad, and A and D are almost the same to me, and by far my favorites, with maybe the nod going to A.

I'm gonna record my MFSL and compare, I'll have to switch the channels, but be interesting.
 
Last edited:
I find C to stand out quite a lot coming right off something like A. However, if I listen to it without having listened to any of the others for awhile, it strikes me differently.
 
Uploaded my LP (remaster). Interestingly, Astrud's voice is on the right side. Guess I never critically listened to this song (esp on phones). :idea:

View attachment 2435997

Girl From Ipanema. Off Getz/Gilberto. Verve Records. UCJU-9068. Sony (Japan) Joseph Palmaccio remaster. 2007.
Run-out: V6-8545 JP
I just pulled out my copy from my record cabinet. Your label has (ICJU-9068) under the album number. Mine says (63 VG 160). What does this say about my album?

Reading the album cover notes here is the only comment regarding Astrud I could find written by her husband;
"Finally just a word about Astrud, my wife. She always liked to sing and we often sing together at home. I like the way she sings 'The Girl from Ipanema.' Getz heard her sing it and asked her to record it with us. This is her first recording date, and I am glad she was among friends." João Gilberto. Her name is not mentioned anywhere else.

What an understatement regarding the song and breakout singer on the album.
 
Another unrelated question about my copy of this album as well as many others I own. I was a cheap college student in the late 60's and early 70's. Many of my albums have punch holes in the corner. Were these factory seconds or overruns? I never heard anything obviously wrong.
 
Back
Top Bottom